Files
aimsight-labeling/docs/archive/knowledge/expert-annotated-cases.md
T

48 lines
4.7 KiB
Markdown
Raw Normal View History

# Cases annotated by the expert (displacements)
Two analysis reports handed to the client by the AIMsight team (May 2026, revision 1.0, in French), stored as they are in `docs/aimsight/`:
- `Mur de soutènement GN-1.472.pdf` (16 p.): written report;
- `Mur de soutènement GN-5.054.pdf` (7 p.): draft, partly in notes; the introduction announces three walls, only one is detailed.
Masonry retaining walls along a railway line, monitored for nearly two years, with prisms and adhesive reflective strips ("ciblettes"). Verdict of both reports: **no notable structural displacement**; each apparent displacement is attributed to an external cause, with evidence (images, `error`, brightness).
They serve as reference truth for `displacement`, with two limits:
- the exports of these walls are not in `data/`: neither the signatures can be verified nor an event replayed. They therefore do not enter the diagnostic agent's event base (`events/`, D-048);
- the signatures below are read from the figures of the reports (axes illegible in GN-5.054); no time is given there.
## Wall GN-1.472 (01/01 to 15/03/2026, detail from 15/02 to 15/03)
| Finding | Signature (report figures) | Expert diagnosis | Evidence cited |
|---|---|---|---|
| H22 and H27, at the top of the wall | vertical: 24 h cycle, correlated between the two, ~10 mm peak to peak, whole period | mutual interference of two very close prisms; persistent anomaly, not a movement of the structure | photo of the two prisms; brightness of H27 well above its neighbors |
| H18, H26, H31, H21 | isolated peaks, one target at a time, up to ~30 mm | a neighboring prism that is too bright hampers detection; too large for masonry | images without obstruction; `error` > 0.7 (H18, and H26 or H22: the report contradicts itself); unbalanced brightness |
| C17 | horizontal: square waves by day, around −65 mm, return at night | dim prism, insufficient contrast against daylight | day and night images; `error` rises by day, without exceeding 0.7 |
| Camera movements | pan, roll, tilt: 24 h cycle badly compensated; scale stable | not a camera movement: 2 references out of 4 masked by vegetation (growing since March 2025), insufficient base for the transformation | images of March 2025 and current |
| Snow, 11/01/2026 | noise and apparent movements on all sensors and the camera; brief data loss | snowfall; probably a flake in front of the lens for the loss | photo of the flakes; images before and after, signal quickly back |
| Interruption (date not given) | gap, drawn in straight lines | `possible`: frost or condensation ("it could be", cold period) | none |
- A badly configured offset shifts the horizontal curves of a target below zero: parametric, no effect on interpretation.
- Remedies proposed: fewer targets, prisms instead of strips, one more reference, brush clearing or moved references, alarms when a target or a reference becomes invisible.
## Wall GN-5.054-MU-G-AV (nearly two years)
103 targets, the largest surface; the most exposed system (altitude, snow clearing that pushes snow against the station).
| Finding | Signature | Expert diagnosis | Evidence cited |
|---|---|---|---|
| Snow | the traces of the hidden targets disappear, the others stay stable | outright obstruction by snow | winter images |
| R2_C20 | jump in the measurements | a plant grows in front of the strip and gradually hides it (partial obstruction) | two images two days apart |
| Data lost in winter | gap | remote solar panel covered with snow, unfavorable orientation: accepted compromise (budget) | operator context |
| Station moved after the first winter | (not shown) | station buried, freeze-thaw cycles that destabilized the mast; guy wires added | on-site intervention |
| Power connector | (not shown) | partly torn off by a snow projection during clearing; replaced by a more robust variant | on-site intervention |
- Most delicate obstruction according to the expert: vegetation (growth, leaves in the wind), partial, for which the default acceptance threshold was not enough.
- Strips up to 40 m; some, near much brighter prisms, badly measured or eliminated.
## What these events add to the framing
Families absent from the table §4.1 of `docs/displacement/cadrage.md`, to be confronted with data when we have some:
- **interference between neighboring targets**: clear image, but a neighbor that is too bright; *Dominance* (FAQ) measures this risk, in the HDF5 only;
- **progressive occlusion** (vegetation): days or weeks, not reversible from one measurement to the next like a passing occlusion;
- **masked references**: 24 h cycle on pan, roll, tilt, not to be read as a camera movement (instability of the compensation, `labeling/knowledge/displacement-columns.md`);
- **daytime contrast**: the "Lighting" family, here on a single prism, in day / night square waves.