# Labels: MICHIGAN, 2026-10-23T20:00Z → 2026-11-01T00:00Z (UTC) Request: requalify the 7 labels of this analysis (`work/requalify_input.jsonl`) under the new rule (`labeling/labeling-rules.md` section 1): only what stands out from the noise of the corrected curves, at least one target beyond 5 of its own noises. This is a requalification, not a new reading; the previous analysis is in `work/analysis.before-requalify2.md`. DETECTORS: no. Station context (unchanged from the first analysis): indoors, same building as BREITHORN and NEBRASKA; one measurement every 4 h (50 instants, none missing); REFPOU22 rejected at every measurement, so the compensation runs on REF42 and REFG43N alone; no image-quality metrics; no `weather/` folder for MICHIGAN, so no MeteoSwiss station or distance to give (indoors anyway). Targets from 9 m (COLH18', POUH18', 3.6 mm/px) to 51 m (REFH22', 20.2 mm/px); the far targets (COLH21, COLH21', COLH21'', POUH21'' near 41 m, REFH22') carry the most mm. Result: **4 kept as they are** (MICHIGAN-11, -13, -14, -15, with their review field), **0 rewritten**, **3 removed** (MICHIGAN-20, -12, -21). ## 1. My labels ### 2026-10-25T16:00Z → 2026-10-26T16:00Z (MICHIGAN-11, kept as is) - **Phenomenon of the catalogue**: The camera drifts away when the temperature of its housing drops, without a daily cycle; A compensation on two references. - **Precedents**: MICHIGAN-9 (validated, same signature on the same station). - **Family**: Thermal displacement: the pose and the curves follow the housing temperature and come back with it. - **Measured**: at 26T08, 7 targets beyond 5 noises together in corr_x (COLH20'' −7, COLH21' −7, COLH21 −6, REFH22' −6, COLH20' −5, COLH21'' −5, POUH21'' −5) with the level rolling over ±1 day and the noise computed outside the 28–30 Oct cold episode (`--outside 2026-10-28T00:00Z/2026-10-30T16:00Z`); with the default noise (computed over the whole batch, episode and 29T12 step included) the largest is REFH22' −4.7. I take the first: the 28–30 Oct episode and the step of 29T12 are themselves labelled anomalies and inflate the noise of corr_x (COLH21' noise 0.020 px outside, 0.033 px over the whole batch); the guide gives `--outside` for this case. corr_y: largest −3.8 noises (POUH18', 26T04), under the threshold. In mm: COLH21' about 5.0 → 2.6 mm, REFH22' about 5.0 → 1.8 mm in x; near targets under 0.3 mm. - **Images**: 26T04 (first analysis): nothing in front. - **Confidence**: medium: beyond the threshold only with the noise read outside the cold episode; the pose, the housing temperature and the 7 targets together make it coherent. ### 2026-10-28T00:00Z → 2026-10-28T16:00Z (MICHIGAN-13, kept as is) - **Phenomenon of the catalogue**: idem. - **Precedents**: MICHIGAN-9. - **Family**: Thermal displacement. - **Measured**: 28T08: 9 targets beyond 5 noises in corr_x with the default settings and `--rolling 1d` (REFH22' −7, COLH21' −6, COLH21 −6, POUH21'' −6, COLH20' −6, POUH20' −6…); 12 targets, up to −10 (COLH21'), with the noise outside the episode. corr_y under the threshold (−3.3). In mm: far targets about −4 to −5 mm in x (REFH22' 5.3 → 0.1 mm, COLH21 4.5 → −0.6 mm). - **Images**: 28T08: nothing in front. - **Confidence**: high. ### 2026-10-28T16:00Z → 2026-10-29T16:00Z (MICHIGAN-14, kept as is) - **Phenomenon of the catalogue**: idem. - **Precedents**: MICHIGAN-9. - **Family**: Thermal displacement. - **Measured**: corr_x beyond 5 noises at 29T00, 29T04, 29T08 on up to 14 targets with the batch level (REFH22' −11.9, COLH21' −10.4, COLH20' −10.1 at 29T08); with `--rolling 1d`, 10 targets at 29T08, REFH22' −8.4. corr_y under the threshold (−4.6 batch level, −3.0 rolling). In mm: REFH22' 5.3 → −4.4 mm, COLH21 about −10 mm from its level before; near targets about −1 mm. - **Images**: 29T08: nothing in front. - **Confidence**: high. ### 2026-10-29T16:00Z → 2026-10-30T12:00Z (MICHIGAN-15, kept as is) - **Phenomenon of the catalogue**: idem. - **Precedents**: MICHIGAN-14. - **Family**: Thermal displacement. - **Measured**: corr_x beyond 5 noises at 30T00, 30T04, 30T08 (batch level: REFH22' −11.6, COLH20' −10.4, COLH21' −10.1 at 30T04); `--rolling 1d`: 11 targets at 30T04, REFH22' −9.4. corr_y −4.7 at most. In mm: REFH22' about −4.2 mm, COLH21 about −5.2 mm at 30T04, from a level near +2 to +3 mm. - **Images**: 30T04: nothing in front. - **Confidence**: high. ## 2. What I left without a label Removed labels (not submitted again): - **MICHIGAN-20**, 2026-10-23T20:00Z → 2026-10-25T00:00Z, Thermal displacement: largest deviation inside the label 2.7 noises (COLH20' corr_x, 25T00) with `--rolling 1d`, 3.6 with the batch level (REFH22' corr_x), 4.0 with the noise outside the cold episode (COLH21' corr_x, 25T00); corr_y 2.5 to 3.1. The camera does move with the housing temperature, but the corrected curves stay within the noise: a camera movement largely absorbed by the compensation. In mm: about 1 to 1.5 mm on the far targets. - **MICHIGAN-12**, 2026-10-26T20:00Z → 2026-10-27T20:00Z, Displacement: corr_y rise of all the targets at 27T04, largest 3.2 noises (COLH18S''') with `--rolling 1d`, 3.3 with the noise outside the cold episode; with the batch level 5.0 exactly (COLH18S'''), not beyond, and that level is pulled down by the low corr_y plateau of the end of the month (spanning MICHIGAN-7); ranges.py at `--k 5` gives no corr_y range over the whole batch. corr_x under 2 noises. In mm: about +2 mm on the far targets. It was validated on 2026-11-17; it falls under the new threshold. - **MICHIGAN-21**, 2026-10-31T00:00Z → 2026-10-31T16:00Z, Thermal displacement: under 2 noises in both columns with `--rolling 1d` (and with the noise outside the cold episode); 2.7 noises with the batch level (COLH20' corr_x, 31T12). A small camera nod, absorbed: about 1 mm. Unchanged from the first analysis: 25T12 (a single measurement, pose wobble), 01T00 (start of the cold event of 1 November, next range), the spanning MICHIGAN-3 (REFPOU22 rejected) and MICHIGAN-7 (slow camera tilt) not touched by this requalification. ## Requalification Commands (from the repository root, outputs in `work/requalify/`): - `python3 tools/scripts/ranges.py data/MICHIGAN --columns corr_x,corr_y --k 5 --start 2026-10-23T20:00Z --end 2026-11-01T00:00Z` (`batch_k5.txt`): corr_x ranges only on 28T20–30T08 instants (29T00/04/08, 30T00/04/08), up to −11.9 noises (REFH22', 29T08); corr_y: none. - same with `--rolling 1d --instants 2` (`batch_k5_roll1d.txt`): 28T08 (9 targets), 29T04 (9), 29T08 (10), 30T04 (11), all in corr_x; corr_y: none. - same with `--rolling 1d --outside 2026-10-28T00:00Z/2026-10-30T16:00Z --instants 2` (`batch_k5_roll1d_outside.txt`): adds 26T08 (7 targets, up to −7) and more targets on 28–30 Oct (up to −13, COLH21', 30T04). - `--k 2` runs (batch level, `--rolling 1d`, `--rolling 3`, `--rolling 1d --outside …`) and `scripts/requalify_max.py` for the largest deviation inside each label (`max_per_label.txt`): | id | bounds | batch level x / y | rolling 1d x / y | rolling 1d, noise outside 28–30 Oct x / y | verdict | |---|---|---|---|---|---| | MICHIGAN-20 | 23T20 → 25T00 | 3.6 / 3.1 | 2.7 / 2.5 | 4.0 / 2.5 | removed | | MICHIGAN-11 | 25T16 → 26T16 | 4.5 / 2.2 | 4.7 / 3.6 | **7.1** / 3.8 | kept | | MICHIGAN-12 | 26T20 → 27T20 | 4.0 / 5.0 | <2 / 3.2 | <2 / 3.3 | removed | | MICHIGAN-13 | 28T00 → 28T16 | 4.6 / 2.1 | **6.7** / 3.2 | **10.1** / 3.2 | kept | | MICHIGAN-14 | 28T16 → 29T16 | **11.9** / 4.6 | **8.4** / 3.0 | **11.8** / 3.3 | kept | | MICHIGAN-15 | 29T16 → 30T12 | **11.6** / 4.7 | **9.4** / 3.9 | **13.2** / 4.0 | kept | | MICHIGAN-21 | 31T00 → 31T16 | 2.7 / <2 | <2 / <2 | <2 / <2 | removed | (absolute values, in noises; the batch level is skewed by the slow drift of MICHIGAN-7, so the rolling columns decide.) - `summary.py --column corr_x_mm --instants …` for the magnitudes in mm; `plot.py --columns corr_x_mm,corr_y_mm` (`curves_mm.png`). - `python3 labeling/scripts/validate.py labels.jsonl`: 4 labels, 0 errors. ## 3. The documentation - `labeling-rules.md` section 1 (the 5-noise threshold, also for the thermal) decided; the request's rule ("with `--rolling` under a drift or a thermal cycle") was needed: the slow tilt of the month (MICHIGAN-7) skews the batch level. - What is not said: which noise to use when the batch contains a strong labelled episode. Here the noise of corr_x over the whole batch is inflated by the 28–30 Oct cold mornings and the 29T12 step, and MICHIGAN-11 lies on either side of the threshold depending on it (4.7 / 7.1). I used `--outside` on the episode, as `tools/GUIDE.md` (ranges) allows; a sentence in `labeling-rules.md` on this choice would remove the ambiguity. - The first analysis noted that its labels 20 and 12 did not reach 5 noises from the night level and kept them after the validated precedents; the new rule settles it: removed. MICHIGAN-12 was validated by the user on 2026-11-17; it falls under the threshold on every variant. - No precedent consulted for this requalification (the decisions are measurements, not classifications). ## Difficulties - `plot.py` takes `--zone` once per zone, not several values after one flag (first call failed). ## Sources read `instructions/analyst.md`, `work/requalify_input.jsonl`, the previous `analysis.md` and `report.md` (kept in `work/`), `labeling/labeling-rules.md` (sections 1–3), `tools/GUIDE.md` (ranges, plot), `work/inventory.txt` and `inventory.py` (distances, mm/px). Tools on `data/MICHIGAN`: `ranges.py` (k 5 and k 2, batch level, `--rolling 1d`, `--rolling 3`, `--outside`, `--instants 2`), `summary.py --column corr_x_mm --instants`, `plot.py`. Scripts: `scripts/requalify_max.py`.