11 KiB
Labels: BREITHORN, 2026-10-03T00:00Z → 2026-10-13T00:00Z (UTC)
Task: verify the 8 existing labels of the range (work/existing.jsonl, all reviewed on 2026-11-17) and the spanning label BREITHORN-2. Cadence 4 h (00, 04, 08, 12, 16, 20 UTC), 61 instants, no missing step, a pose at every instant, no image-quality metrics (old camera). No weather: BREITHORN has no place in ~/aimsight-data/extraction/stations.txt (the line has the name only), so I fetched no MeteoSwiss data. The station is indoors, in a factory (stations.md).
Verdict per old id
| id | verdict | evidence |
|---|---|---|
| BREITHORN-1 | kept | REFPOU22, COLH20''' and POUI22 rejected from 03T04 to 04T16 (10 steps, inventory); everything back at 04T20; the vehicle is at the bottom of the 04T08 image; the corr_x of REFH22 goes from about −0.009 to −0.03/−0.046 and comes back at 04T20. Starts at the first measurement of the data (edge). |
| BREITHORN-2 (spanning) | correct inside the range | drift of corr_x: COLJ19 0.076 → 0.170, POUI19 0.110 → 0.287, COLI21 −0.001 → 0.081, COLH20 0.029 → 0.070, POUI20 0.036 → 0.077, COLI20 −0.003 → 0.040; COLI24 corr_y −0.033 → −0.138; POUI19 corr_y flat. Tilt 0.0094 → 0.0197, pan and rotation going down, housing temperature 31.5 → 30. Nothing to change. |
| BREITHORN-3 | kept | 04T16: every sensor out of level (rolling ranges: REFH22 corr_y +44 noises, refs −24, targets −9 to −26); REFH22 error_value 0.566 (threshold 0.7), POUI24 rejected; back at 04T20. |
| BREITHORN-4 | kept | COLI22, COLI24, POUI22 rejected 06T20 → 07T04; nothing else out of level; back at 07T08. |
| BREITHORN-5 | kept | 07T12: REFI'21 rejected (error 0.99), 3 references retained; COLJ19, POUI19 corr_y +9 noises, COLI20, COLI22, POUI24 +6 to +8; back at 07T16. |
| BREITHORN-6 | kept | COLI24 rejected 07T20–08T00, COLI22 and POUI22 08T00; POUI22 corr_y +0.199 at 07T20 (+18 noises), POUI24 corr_y +0.409 at 08T00 (+59 noises); back at 08T04. |
| BREITHORN-7 | kept | REFH22, COLI22, COLI24, POUI22 rejected 09T00 → 09T04; POUI24 corr_x +0.17, corr_y +0.27/+0.35 (+40/+52 noises); back at 09T08. The other targets shift a little (REFG44N, REFI'21 corr_y −0.013, COLI21 −0.033, under 3 noises): "without making the other targets jump" holds at the 5-noise threshold. |
| BREITHORN-8 | kept | COLI22, COLI24, POUI22 rejected at 09T20 only; nothing else out of level. |
| BREITHORN-9 | kept | 10T04: COLI22, COLI24, POUI22, POUI24 rejected; REFH22 error 0.475, corr_y +70 noises; every other sensor −8 to −27 noises; back at 10T08. |
1. My labels
The 8 kept labels are in labels.jsonl unchanged (with their review field). Here are the 4 added ones.
2026-10-04T00:00Z → 2026-10-04T12:00Z
- Phenomenon of the catalogue: the camera moves through a thermal effect.
- Precedents: BREITHORN-14, -21, -24, -17 (reviewed): the same morning signature at this station (rotation and scale deviate at the temperature trough, COLH20 and REFPOU22 up in corr_y, REFG44N/REFI'21 down, back at noon), labelled Thermal displacement on the expert's word. They set the family, the bounds (from the last calm measurement to the noon return) and the wording.
- Family: Thermal displacement. Not Visibility: the error_value of COLH20 stays at its level and nothing is in front of it. Not Obstruction: the vehicle of BREITHORN-1 hides only COLH20''', POUI22 and REFPOU22.
- Measured: compared with the previous evening (
scripts/thermal_table.py,work/thermal_table.txt), COLH20 corr_y is +0.049 at 04T04 and +0.046 at 04T08, then +0.011 at 04T12. COLI21 is +0.017 at 08. The rotation is −2.9e-3° and −2.5e-3° (days.py --bounds: −6.3 noises, 04T04 → 04T08); the scale is −2.5e-5 and −5.1e-5. The housing temperature goes 32.5 → 30.5 → 29.5 °C, then back to 31. REFPOU22 is rejected (3 references), so the usual reference signature cannot be read. - Images: 04T08: the parked vehicle is in the foreground at the bottom of the scene; the spots in the upper part, including COLH20, are clear.
- Confidence: medium. The rotation and COLH20 match the signature, but with only 3 references and the vehicle present the case is less clean than 5 and 6 Oct.
2026-10-05T00:00Z → 2026-10-05T12:00Z
-
Phenomenon of the catalogue: the camera moves through a thermal effect.
-
Precedents: as above; BREITHORN-24 (28 Oct) has the same amplitude and the same two-measurement shape.
-
Family: Thermal displacement. The error_value of the references stays far below threshold (REFG44N 0.09 → 0.125, REFPOU22 0.057 → 0.066), with no rejection and nothing on the images.
-
Measured: compared with the previous evening:
- at 05T04 / 05T08, REFPOU22 corr_y is +0.049 / +0.046 (+5.5 noises with a rolling level), COLH20 +0.040 / +0.062, REFG44N −0.027 / −0.012 (−5.3 noises at 04), REFI'21 −0.021 / −0.008;
- the scale is −5.3e-5 / −7.7e-5 (−6.5 noises at 08) and the rotation −1.4e-3 / −2.6e-3 (−5.5 noises at 08);
- at 05T12 everything is back (+5, +13, +3, +5 ×1e-3);
- the housing temperature falls to its daily trough (30.0 / 29.5 °C).
The corr_y of COLJ19 and POUI19 rise at 05T08 and keep part of it: that belongs to the drift of BREITHORN-2.
-
Images: 05T08 and 05T16 are identical in content: spots clear, nothing in front.
-
Confidence: high.
2026-10-05T20:00Z → 2026-10-06T12:00Z
- Phenomenon of the catalogue: the camera moves through a thermal effect.
- Precedents: as above; BREITHORN-17 and -25 also start at night.
- Family: Thermal displacement (same reasons).
- Measured: compared with the previous evening:
- at 06T00 / 04 / 08, REFPOU22 corr_y is +0.029 / +0.040 / +0.045 (+5.0 noises at 08), COLH20 +0.040 / +0.035 / +0.045, REFG44N −0.022 / −0.014 / −0.018, REFI'21 −0.019 / −0.011 / −0.014;
- the scale is −2.9e-5 / −2.8e-5 / −6.1e-5 (−5.2 noises at 08);
- at 06T12 the corr are back (+9, +15, −1, −1); the scale is still −3.1e-5 there and back at 16. That is the slow relaxation of a secondary axis, which does not push the end back;
- at 05T20 all is calm (+3, +13, −1, +1);
- the housing temperature is 31.5 → 30.0 → 31.0 °C.
- Images: 06T08: spots clear, a small light at the far left, away from any spot.
- Confidence: high.
2026-10-11T20:00Z → 2026-10-12T16:00Z
-
Phenomenon of the catalogue: the camera moves through a thermal effect.
-
Precedents: BREITHORN-21, a weaker case accepted in review.
-
Family: Thermal displacement.
-
Measured: compared with the previous evening:
- at 12T00 / 04 / 08, REFPOU22 corr_y is +0.021 / +0.025 / +0.025, COLH20 +0.010 / +0.028 / +0.019, REFG44N −0.014 / −0.007 / −0.007;
- COLI21 is −0.011 / −0.026 / −0.016 and COLH20''' −0.014 / −0.023 / −0.013;
- POUI24 is −5.9 noises at 12T04 (rolling level), and POUI19 −5.2 noises at 12T08 (corr_y −0.172 / −0.179 against about −0.12 to −0.13 before). POUI19 is still −0.146 at 12T12 and back at 12T16 (−0.100), hence the end;
- the scale is −2.7 / −3.8 / −3.3 e-5 and the rotation −0.4 / −1.3 / −1.3 e-3;
- the housing temperature is 29.5 → 28.75 °C, the lowest of the range, then 30–31.
The corr of single targets pass 5 noises, so the "no cycle" rule does not apply.
-
Images: 12T04: identical to the calm images, nothing in front.
-
Confidence: medium. The pattern is coherent, but it is the weakest of the four, and only two targets pass 5 noises.
2. What I left without a label
- 3 Oct, morning: COLH20 corr_y is higher at 03T08 (about +0.028 against the 03T04/03T12 values) and the scale is −3e-5 (2.7 noises), with the housing temperature at 30.25. There is no previous evening to compare with, REFPOU22 is rejected from 03T04 (the base changes), and nothing passes 5 noises. Not labelled.
- 11 Oct, morning: REFPOU22 +0.013 / +0.018, COLH20 +0.011 / +0.019 at 04/08, scale −3.8e-5 (3.2 noises). No sensor and no pose axis reaches 5 noises: no thermal label (labeling-rules §2/§1, 5-noise rule).
- 7 Oct night and 8 Oct: the scale is low all day and the rotation steps down from 08T08 (−8 noises, no return). That is the progressive tilt of BREITHORN-2 (spanning), not a daily cycle; COLH20/REFPOU22 do not show the morning signature.
- 12T16 and 12T20: the camera pose is exactly the same at both instants, and so is the corr of the four references, while the targets differ a little (within their noise). It looks like a registration reused from the previous measurement. The corr show nothing abnormal, so there is no label; noted as a data oddity.
- The drift itself (corr_x of COLJ19, POUI19, COLI21…) is BREITHORN-2, out of my scope.
3. The documentation
- The cases that decided it were the reviewed BREITHORN thermal labels (14, 17, 21, 24, 25, 27) and NEBRASKA-10. Together they give a very specific signature for this indoor station: rotation and scale deviate at the housing-temperature trough, COLH20 and REFPOU22 rise in corr_y, REFG44N and REFI'21 go down, everything is back at noon. Searching for it over the whole range (labeling-rules §1, "a signature found once is searched over the whole batch") found 4 occurrences that the existing labels of the range missed. The previous analysts of this range seem to have looked only at rejections.
- The 5-noise rule ("no thermal label on a day when neither the pose nor the corr deviate by more than 5 noises") sits uneasily with this precedent. On a 4 h cadence the noise is the step between consecutive measurements, and those steps already include the cycle. Several reviewed labels (BREITHORN-21: REFPOU22 about 3.5 noises) fall below it. I applied the rule per sensor and per pose axis: 11 Oct was left out, 12 Oct kept because POUI19 and POUI24 pass it. A note in
labeling-rules.mdon how to measure the noise at a slow cadence would help. days.py --boundson the median of the targets did not show these cycles, because the targets move in opposite directions and cancel. The per-sensor table of my script andranges.py --rolling 6 --instants 2showed them.- No weather for BREITHORN (no place in
stations.txt); for an indoor station it matters little.
Difficulties
- My first run of
thermal_table.pymatched no instants: the measurement times carry seconds (00:00:03.37), while the pose and temperature are on the minute. I fixed it by rounding to the minute. validate.pyflags the overlap of BREITHORN-1 and BREITHORN-3 (two Obstruction labels). It was already there and was reviewed by the user, so I kept it as it is.
Sources read
instructions/analyst.md, tools/GUIDE.md, tools/DATA.md, labeling/families.md, labeling/labeling-rules.md, labeling/reading-rules.md, labeling/stations.md, labeling/auto/BREITHORN.jsonl (ids, and the texts of 10, 11, 14, 17, 21, 24), work/existing.jsonl, work/spanning.jsonl, the precedents (precedents.py, thermal morning query). Data: inventory.py, summary.py (corr_x, corr_y, error_value at 4 h, --mark), metrics.py (4 h, 2 → 14 Oct), days.py --night 12-23 --bounds, ranges.py --rolling 6 --instants 2, plot.py, scripts/thermal_table.py (my own, 3 → 30 Oct), images 04T08, 05T08, 05T16, 06T08, 12T04. tools/scripts/data.py was read for its loader API only.