145 lines
18 KiB
Markdown
145 lines
18 KiB
Markdown
# Labels: NIEDERHORN, 2026-10-11T05:00Z → 2026-10-21T12:00Z (UTC)
|
||
|
||
Request: verify the 43 existing labels of the range (`work/existing.jsonl`), and the 12 spanning ones within the range (`work/spanning.jsonl`). DETECTORS: no.
|
||
|
||
Station context: railway tracks seen from below a road; references PWD_REF08 to PWD_REF12 on the road; floodlight at night; hourly cadence (232 instants in the range). The export is named "Project Toronto": the sun enters the field around 12:00-14:00 UTC, so the local morning falls late in UTC (moments of the day judged on the images). **Weather**: no `weather/` folder for NIEDERHORN (station without a Swiss position): no MeteoSwiss weather; causes read on the images and the curves only. Image quality columns (peak to snr) empty: no `quality.py`.
|
||
|
||
## Verdict per existing label
|
||
|
||
| Old id | Verdict | Evidence |
|
||
|---|---|---|
|
||
| NIEDERHORN-53 | corrected (description) | 11T06:00 missing for all sensors; metrics present (temperature at 06:00); **no image at 06:00** (images gap 05:00 → 07:00), not stated; no other station misses 06:00 (stations.py at 5 min: only LENZSPITZE, not yet running). Text now states the image. |
|
||
| NIEDERHORN-54 | kept | pan beyond 5 noises 16:00-17:00 (days.py --bounds: before 15:00, after 18:00); B07_018 corr_x dip; consistent. |
|
||
| NIEDERHORN-55 | corrected (end 04:00 → 06:00, description) | rejections 11T22 → 12T03 (e06, B12_019, B15_018, B16_026, e09, B07_017, B07_018, B12_017, B12_018); after the 04:00 train, B15_020 still off at 05:00 (corr_x +0.13 vs ~0.03 after, error 0.20 vs 0.05-0.11) and B08_025 (corr_x 0.155 vs ~0.27-0.30), back at 06:00. "Back to normal before midnight" was false (worst 00:00-03:00 UTC). Thumbnails 01:00, 03:00: smaller, weaker spots than at 12T23 (clear night); 05:00 near normal; 11T22 image at dusk. |
|
||
| NIEDERHORN-56 | kept | 12T04: 15 targets rejected, references intact; train per label; one measurement. |
|
||
| NIEDERHORN-57 | kept | pan beyond 5 noises 16:00-20:00 (after 21:00); its undershoot after (min −2.8 noises) stays under 5 noises; end at 00:00 consistent with the station's practice (night corr relaxation follows the scale, a secondary axis). |
|
||
| NIEDERHORN-58 | kept | B07_016 rejected 12T17, corr_y spike 12T18 (1.79 vs ~1.2), back 19:00. |
|
||
| NIEDERHORN-59 | kept | 13T05: B07_017, B12_018, B15_018 rejected alone. |
|
||
| NIEDERHORN-60 | kept | B07_016 rejected 13T13, 13T15, spikes 13T10-12, 13T16, 13T19. |
|
||
| NIEDERHORN-61 | kept | rejections 13T09 → 13T14 of many targets (e06, B16_026 first at 09:00), corr_x drops of B08_024, B08_025, e15, B15_020; start 08:00 checked (no target moves at 08:00, values flat 05-08). |
|
||
| NIEDERHORN-62 | kept | 13T13: 20 targets rejected, B12_019/B12_020 corr_y jump. |
|
||
| NIEDERHORN-63 | corrected (end 14T00 → 14T06, description) | days.py --bounds: pan and tilt beyond 5 noises until 14T02 (after 03:00). Pan keeps going down after 19:00 to −0.019 at 14T00 (morning −0.004), then comes back; tilt drops to −0.069 at 13T19, back to −0.050 at 14T05. Named targets: B07_018 corr_x 0.076 at 14T00 → 0.305 at 04:00 (night level ~0.30); B12_018 −0.22 → −0.12 at 06:00. The old text ("pan goes back down until about 19:00") missed the overshoot and the night return. |
|
||
| NIEDERHORN-64 | kept | 13T17: e02, e06, e09, B17_026 rejected. |
|
||
| NIEDERHORN-65 | kept | 13T20: e02 alone rejected. |
|
||
| NIEDERHORN-66 | kept | 13T23: insects (per label); 13 rejected, others jump. |
|
||
| NIEDERHORN-67 | kept | B07_016 rejected 14T08, 12, 19, 23 → 15T01; spikes 14T13, 14T18. |
|
||
| NIEDERHORN-68 | kept | 14T12: e06, e09, B16_026, B07_018, B15_018, B07_017, B07_016 rejected; B12_019 rejected 13:00 → end 14:00. |
|
||
| NIEDERHORN-69 | kept | pan beyond 5 noises from 14:00 (before 13:00); pan back near −0.002 at 22:00 where it then stays (then the slow rise of every night). |
|
||
| NIEDERHORN-71 | kept | tilt beyond 5 noises 15:00-17:00, pan 18:00-20:00 (after 21:00); measurements stop at 22:00. |
|
||
| NIEDERHORN-72 | kept | 15T22 → 16T11: no measurement, no image; common to all stations measuring (stations.py: 15T23 → 16T01 on all). |
|
||
| NIEDERHORN-73 | corrected (description) | family and bounds kept (cause still not established). Error per 6 h: e06 0.10 → 0.28-0.40, e13 0.08 → 0.23-0.28, B16_026 0.21 → 0.25-0.37 from 16T06, and it stays; rigid residual (base 15T00): e10 dx −0.64, e09 dy +0.65, e15 dx +0.31 at 17T06: these targets move in the image. Thumbnails 16T14: e06 spot split, e13 appendage; zone at 05:00 on 17 and 19.10: spots of the left part smeared, two neighbours merged, not on 14.10 05:00. "Nothing on the thumbnails" was contradicted. |
|
||
| NIEDERHORN-74 | corrected (start 15T22 → 16T11) | the disturbance starts at the resumption (16T11: 12 targets rejected); rule "an event that starts at the resumption starts at that measurement". Description kept. |
|
||
| NIEDERHORN-75 | corrected (end 16T16 → 17T12, description) | housing temperature 34 °C (16T14) → 17 °C (17T12), far below the other nights; pan −0.008 (16T13) → +0.0157 (17T12), scale 1.00022 (16T15) → 0.99968 (17T12); days.py: pan beyond 5 noises 17T03-17T09 and still rising; targets 16T18 → 17T11: B12_018 corr_x −0.13 → +0.15, B12_020 0.21 → 0.51, B08_025 0.25 → 0.08, e10 −0.14 → −0.29; corr_y e09 0.31 → 0.58, e06 −0.19 → −0.03, B12_018 1.56 → 1.75. At equal temperature (24.5 °C at 17T00 and 17T23) the pose is equal (scale 0.99995 both). "After 16:00 nothing follows the temperature" was false. |
|
||
| NIEDERHORN-76 | kept | B07_016 rejected 16T15, 17, 23 → 17T00. |
|
||
| NIEDERHORN-77 | kept | 16T17: e02, e06, e09, B07_016 rejected. |
|
||
| NIEDERHORN-78 | kept | 16T19: e02, e06, e09 rejected. |
|
||
| NIEDERHORN-80 | kept | B07_016 rejected 17T05, 17T14. |
|
||
| NIEDERHORN-81 | corrected (description) | refs error 17T12-14: REF09 0.16 → 0.31 → 0.49 → 0.41, REF08 0.27 → 0.41; e09 and **e02** rejected at 13:00, **e06 not** (template sentence). Cause cited on the 21.10 image while the 17.10 13:00 image shows the sun in the field (`sun_1300.png`). Bounds kept. |
|
||
| NIEDERHORN-82 | kept | tilt beyond 5 noises 13:00-17:00, pan 13:00 → 18T00; its start at 12:00 now follows the corrected 75. |
|
||
| NIEDERHORN-83 | kept | B07_016 corr_y dips 18T07 (0.63), 18T09 (0.65) vs ~1.05, no rejection. |
|
||
| NIEDERHORN-84 | corrected (end 14:00 → 15:00, description) | refs still above their level at 14:00 (REF08 0.29, REF09 0.30, REF10 0.20, REF11 0.14 vs 0.24/0.16/0.15/0.10), REF11 +8 and REF12 −8 noises on corr_x at 14:00: 14:00 is touched; back at 15:00. Image of the day cited. |
|
||
| NIEDERHORN-85 | kept | tilt 13:00-16:00, pan back at 22:00 to the level where it stays. |
|
||
| NIEDERHORN-86 | kept | B07_016 rejected 18T21 alone. |
|
||
| NIEDERHORN-87 | kept | B07_016 rejected 19T11, 19T15, spikes 19T06, 19T20. |
|
||
| NIEDERHORN-88 | kept | 19T10:00 missing; no image; stations at 5 min: 10:00 also missing on CLARIDEN, FLORIDA, JUNGFRAU, LENZSPITZE, SNCF01 (NORDEND misses 09:45). |
|
||
| NIEDERHORN-89 | corrected (description) | bounds right (19T12: most left targets corr_x −6 to −12 noises; e06 rejected 13-14, e09 13); cause cited on the 21.10 image while the 19.10 image shows the sun. |
|
||
| NIEDERHORN-90 | kept | tilt 12:00-16:00, pan 14:00-18:00. |
|
||
| NIEDERHORN-91 | kept | 19T21:00 missing, no image; at 21:00 also missing on CLARIDEN, FLORIDA, LENZSPITZE, SNCF01 (JUNGFRAU and NORDEND have their 21:00 measurement but miss 20:45: the list in the text is a little too wide; left as is). |
|
||
| NIEDERHORN-92 | kept | B07_016 rejected 20T10-12, spikes 20T06, 07, 09. |
|
||
| NIEDERHORN-93 | kept | 20T12: 14 targets rejected, B15_020/B12_019/B12_020 corr_y jump. |
|
||
| NIEDERHORN-94 | corrected (end 14:00 → 15:00, description) | REF10 0.48, REF11 0.32 at 13:00, still 0.30 and 0.19 at 14:00, REF11/REF12 corr_x ±8 noises at 14:00; image of the day cited. |
|
||
| NIEDERHORN-95 | kept | tilt 13:00-16:00, pan 14:00-20:00 (after 22:00). |
|
||
| NIEDERHORN-96 | kept | 20T17: e02, e06, e09 rejected. |
|
||
| NIEDERHORN-97 | kept | 20T21 missing; 21:00 image exists; at 5 min only CLARIDEN (and SNCF01, in a long gap of its own) miss 21:00. |
|
||
|
||
Spanning labels (not changed): NIEDERHORN-2 to -8 (e03, e04, e05, e07, e08, e11, e12 rejected at all measurements; e07 accepted once at 11T20:00), -9 (PWD_RMP_B15_017_C09), -10 (e01), -11 (PWD_IMP_B08_024_C09), -70 (PWD_RMP_B12_019_C09 from 15T01), -79 (PWD_IMP_B07_018_C09 from 17T03) hold within the range. The isolated night rejection of e01 at 15T02 is the insect passage (new label), not its daytime regime.
|
||
|
||
## 1. My labels
|
||
|
||
Only the changed and added labels are detailed; the kept ones are justified in the table above.
|
||
|
||
### 2026-10-15T01:00Z → 2026-10-15T03:00Z (added)
|
||
- **Phenomenon of the catalogue**: A pass-by hides the targets for the length of one measurement (insects give the same signature: only the image tells)
|
||
- **Precedents**: NIEDERHORN-66 (insects, 13.10, kept here) and NIEDERHORN-130 (insects at 21:00 on 29.10, validated): same signature, Obstruction, one measurement.
|
||
- **Family**: Obstruction: an object in front of a few targets for one measurement; not Visibility (the scene is not veiled as a whole).
|
||
- **Measured**: 15T02: e01 rejected (error 0.53, night level 0.25); e09 corr_x +0.568 vs 0.39/0.42, corr_y −0.42 vs −0.23/−0.25, back at 03:00; e10 corr_x 0.71 (then 0.62), B16_026 0.60 (then 0.54); references corr_y REF11 −0.258 (−0.174 before, −0.198 after), REF12 +0.156 (0.105/0.122), REF09 +0.081 (0.010/0.035); error REF09 0.18 vs 0.14.
|
||
- **Images**: 02:00 whole image: several large blurred pale ellipses (lit insects close to the lens), one over the e09/e10/B16_026 group, others in the upper left near the references and lower middle; 03:00: none.
|
||
- **Confidence**: high.
|
||
|
||
### 2026-10-15T01:00Z → 2026-10-15T04:00Z (added)
|
||
- **Phenomenon of the catalogue**: A target or a small group jumps and stays shifted; close to "An obstacle covers part of the spot" (not proven)
|
||
- **Precedents**: NIEDERHORN-131 (30.10, after the range, validated): at 02:00 at night, the left-edge targets e14, e15, e10 jump and stay, their error changes level at the same instant, Displacement: same signature and same group. LENZSPITZE-83 (a shift that lasts with a light loss): not directly comparable, no quality metrics here.
|
||
- **Family**: Displacement: a lasting step without established cause (rule D-074); not Obstruction, as no object is seen to stay, only a faint haze.
|
||
- **Measured**: B16_026 corr_y 1.43 (15T01) → 1.66 at 02:00, 1.67-1.72 until 15T22 (about ten noises); corr_x 0.42 → 0.54-0.56 (new level at 03:00); e10 corr_x 0.55 → 0.60-0.62, corr_y −0.07 → +0.01; e13 corr_y 0.065 → 0.12. Error per 6 h: e09 0.15 → 0.21-0.24, e10 0.13 → 0.21-0.25, B16_026 0.11 → 0.18-0.22, e13 0.05 → 0.09, all staying until the gap. References and other targets: no level change.
|
||
- **Images**: zone thumbnails 15T00-03 with contrast (`left_targets_15oct_night.png`): at 02:00 a diffuse streaked haze over e09/e10/B16_026, a fainter haze remaining at 03:00; 15T05 zone: brighter background around these three spots, not on 14T05; 80 px thumbnails at 15T03: fine filaments around e10 and the bright neighbour of B16_026.
|
||
- **Confidence**: medium (the step is certain; the cause is not).
|
||
|
||
### NIEDERHORN-55 corrected: 2026-10-11T21:00Z → 2026-10-12T06:00Z
|
||
- **Phenomenon of the catalogue**: Rain / visibility drops over the whole scene, without an obstacle
|
||
- **Precedents**: NIEDERHORN-61 and -74 (same station, same family, same targets first hit).
|
||
- **Family**: Visibility: the whole group of targets degrades together, references hold (higher up).
|
||
- **Measured**: see the table; end read on B15_020 and B08_025 at 05:00.
|
||
- **Images**: 11T22 (dusk), 12T01, 12T03 (spots smaller and weaker than at 12T23), 12T05 (near normal).
|
||
- **Confidence**: medium on the cause (rain or mist not distinguished), high on the bounds.
|
||
|
||
### NIEDERHORN-63 corrected: 2026-10-13T13:00Z → 2026-10-14T06:00Z
|
||
- **Phenomenon of the catalogue**: The camera moves through a thermal effect
|
||
- **Precedents**: the other cycles of the station (NIEDERHORN-57, -69, -82).
|
||
- **Family**: Thermal displacement: the pose follows the housing temperature (43 °C at 13T18, falling to 32.5 °C at 14T05) and comes back.
|
||
- **Measured**: pan 0.0171 (13T17) → −0.0191 (14T00) → −0.0068 (14T05); tilt −0.0690 (13T19) → −0.0501 (14T05); tgt_corr_x +0.07 to +0.09 at 14T00-02, +0.02 at 14T05.
|
||
- **Images**: none needed (signature).
|
||
- **Confidence**: high on the night return; the end at 06:00 within one or two steps.
|
||
|
||
### NIEDERHORN-73 corrected (bounds and family kept)
|
||
- **Phenomenon of the catalogue**: A step taken during a measurement outage; "An obstacle covers part of the spot" and "A spider web in front of the lens" weighed in the text.
|
||
- **Precedents**: NIEDERHORN-131 (same group, same signature on 30.10).
|
||
- **Family**: Displacement kept: cause not established; Obstruction would need the obstacle seen.
|
||
- **Measured / Images**: see the table.
|
||
- **Confidence**: medium.
|
||
|
||
### NIEDERHORN-74 corrected: start 2026-10-16T11:00Z
|
||
- **Confidence**: high (rule on the edge of a gap).
|
||
|
||
### NIEDERHORN-75 corrected: 2026-10-16T11:00Z → 2026-10-17T12:00Z
|
||
- **Phenomenon of the catalogue**: The camera moves through a thermal effect (here a slow drift all night, with an exceptional cooling)
|
||
- **Precedents**: the station's cycles (NIEDERHORN-50, -33): the scale "only comes back slowly, during the night"; here the pan, a main axis, also drifts all night, which they do not show.
|
||
- **Family**: Thermal displacement: pose and temperature go together and come back at equal temperature (17T00 and 17T23).
|
||
- **Measured**: see the table.
|
||
- **Images**: none needed.
|
||
- **Confidence**: high.
|
||
|
||
### NIEDERHORN-81, -84, -89, -94 corrected
|
||
- **Phenomenon of the catalogue**: The sun in the field or behind a spot
|
||
- **Precedents**: NIEDERHORN-98, -101 (next batch, same text).
|
||
- **Family**: Visibility.
|
||
- **Measured**: references' error per hour, see the table.
|
||
- **Images**: 13:00 on 17, 18, 19 and 20.10 (`sun_1300.png`): the sun in the upper middle of the field with halo and rays over the road of the references.
|
||
- **Confidence**: high.
|
||
|
||
### NIEDERHORN-53 corrected
|
||
- **Measured**: 06:00 missing on all sensors, no 06:00 image, temperature metric at 06:00 present.
|
||
- **Confidence**: high.
|
||
|
||
## 2. What I left without a label
|
||
|
||
- 14T03: PWD_IMP_B08_024_C09 corr_x jump (+14 noises against its local level) at its first accepted measurement after the run of rejections 13T13 → 14T02: the target right at its threshold of NIEDERHORN-11 (spanning), covered by it.
|
||
- Every night, after the cycle, the pan rises slowly and the scale relaxes (18-19, 19-20, 20-21.10: pan up by a few thousandths over the night) with no step of the median corrected curves: the slow relaxation of the station, treated by the existing labels as the tail of each cycle; only the night of 16-17.10, far colder, moves the curves (NIEDERHORN-75).
|
||
- 20T16: REF11 error 0.34 for one measurement, its corr unchanged: no effect on the curves.
|
||
- 17T12, 18T12: REF09 error jumps (0.31, 0.60) at the first sun measurement, without any corr moving; left at the start of the sun labels as they are.
|
||
- The day-time agitation from one measurement to the next on 17-20.10 (targets ±6-12 noises on corr_x at 14:00-20:00) is written in the thermal labels.
|
||
|
||
## 3. The documentation
|
||
|
||
- Helped: `labeling-rules.md` section 2 (end of a thermal cycle at the later return of the main axes; an event that starts at the resumption of a gap), section 5 (a sentence taken from a model is reread; the image cited is that of the day; a No data states the image); `families.md` (spider web, obstacle covering part of a spot, insects vs train); `reading-rules.md` section 6 (a swarm of insects is not a train).
|
||
- Precedents: NIEDERHORN-130 and -66 gave the insect signature at once; NIEDERHORN-131 (30.10) shows the same left-edge group stepping again at night with its error, which makes the 15.10 02:00 step and the step during the gap (73) look like one recurring phenomenon of that corner (a spider web suspected, not proven). Worth a look by the expert at the lens.
|
||
- The sun labels were copied day to day (e06 listed when not rejected, the image of 21.10 cited when each day's image exists): the rule is clear, the labels did not follow it.
|
||
- The thermal ends at about 23:00-00:00 every day leave out the night relaxation of the corr (it follows the scale, a secondary axis): consistent with "the slow relaxation of a secondary axis does not push the end back"; I applied it, except on 13.10 (pan overshoot) and 16-17.10 (pan drift), where a main axis keeps moving.
|
||
- Misleading: the 60-minute view of `stations.py` first suggested NIEDERHORN alone at 19T10 and 19T21; at a 5-minute step the common gaps show (an hourly step hides the gaps of stations measuring every 10 or 15 min).
|
||
|
||
## Difficulties
|
||
- The station is not in Switzerland: no weather, and the local morning falls around 12:00 UTC; moments of the day judged on the images.
|
||
- `analysis.md` and `report.md` were written through Bash: the Write tool refused report files in this sub-agent context.
|
||
|
||
## Sources read
|
||
`agents/agents/analyst.md`, `instructions/analyst.md`, the request (`work/prompt.txt`), `tools/GUIDE.md`, `tools/DATA.md`, `labeling/families.md`, `labeling/labeling-rules.md`, `labeling/reading-rules.md`, `labeling/stations.md`, `work/existing.jsonl`, `work/spanning.jsonl`, `labeling/auto/NIEDERHORN.jsonl` (labels after the range, for NIEDERHORN-130/131), precedents (`precedents.py`, three queries). Tools: `inventory.py`, `overview.py` (window, full table, `--rigid` base 15T00), `days.py --bounds`, `metrics.py`, `stations.py` (1 h and 5 min), `summary.py`, `thumbnails.py` (sensors, zones, contrast), whole images 15T02, 15T03; my scripts `scripts/scan.py` (jumps and rejections per instant against the labels), `scripts/values.py` (values per sensor), `scripts/build_labels.py`.
|