79 lines
12 KiB
Markdown
79 lines
12 KiB
Markdown
# Labels: NORDEND, 2026-09-17T05:45Z → 2026-09-30T04:15Z (UTC)
|
|
|
|
Task: verify the 23 existing labels of the range (`work/existing.jsonl`, all reviewed by the user on 2026-11-17) and look for what they miss. Result: 23 kept, 0 corrected, 0 removed, 1 added.
|
|
|
|
Weather: `data/NORDEND/weather/` does not exist: no MeteoSwiss weather for this station (no Swiss position); the causes were read on the images and the curves only.
|
|
|
|
Station: export columns `peak` to `snr` empty over the window: no image-quality metrics, `quality.py` not applicable. 1243 instants, every 15 min, none missing, a pose at every instant, an image every 15 min. Three references CTR02, CTR03, CTR04, all retained at every instant except 20/09 09:00-09:45 and 10:15-11:30 (CTR04 rejected).
|
|
|
|
## Verdict per old id
|
|
|
|
| Old id | Range (UTC) | Family | Verdict | Evidence |
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
|
|
| NORDEND-126 | 17/09 05:45 → 18/09 06:30 | Thermal displacement | kept | pan drops from 06:30, tilt up from 06:00 (max 09:15), scale up; PR18 corr_x about -0.07 px at 09:15, PR13-PR16 small dips; next cycle starts at the turning point 18/09 06:30 (pan 17.7 → 15.5 mdeg at 07:00, tilt leaving -120). Remark: PR18 corr_y rises about as much as on 19/09 (+0.04 px at 09:30), where the label says "rises"; "hardly moves" is a soft wording, not wrong enough to cancel the review |
|
|
| NORDEND-127 | 17/09 20:00 → 22:45 | Obstruction | kept | PR07 rejected 20:30, 21:45-22:15; PR14, PR15 corr_x +7, +8 noises at 20:15, PR11, PR16 at 20:30, PR16 corr_y -8.6 noises at 22:00-22:15, PR07 corr_x +7 noises at 22:30, nothing at 22:45: bounds right |
|
|
| NORDEND-128 | 18/09 06:30 → 19/09 06:15 | Thermal displacement | kept | turning point 06:30; fast part 07:00-07:30; PR18 corr_x -0.083 px at 08:00, PR16 -0.054, PR15 -0.048, PR14 -0.034, PR18 corr_y +0.047; next start 06:15 (pan 14.9 → 13.4 mdeg at 06:45, tilt -118 → -115) |
|
|
| NORDEND-129 | 18/09 14:45 → 16:00 | Visibility | kept | CTR01 rejected 15:00-15:45 (4), sunny-afternoon signature; bounds right |
|
|
| NORDEND-130 | 19/09 06:15 → 20/09 07:30 | Thermal displacement | kept | PR18 corr_x -0.078 px at 09:00, PR16 -0.052, PR18 corr_y +0.040; tilt max 08:45 |
|
|
| NORDEND-131 | 20/09 07:30 → 21/09 06:00 | Thermal displacement | kept | weak day: tilt only +5 noises (13:30); pan up all night (+0.02 deg at 21/09 01:15), tilt down all night (-0.022 deg at 00:45); the visibility drop 08:45-12:00 is labelled apart (132) |
|
|
| NORDEND-132 | 20/09 08:45 → 12:00 | Visibility | kept | 08:45 still normal on every sensor (the rolling flags at 08:45 come from a median pulled by 09:00); CTR04 rejected 09:00-09:45, 10:15-11:30, compensation on two references (CTR02, CTR03 corr at 0); 13 to 19 targets rejected at times; PR08 corr_x -0.48, PR06 -0.42, PR16 -0.40 px; 10:00 one-measurement return when CTR04 comes back; 11:45 all back except PR07 corr_x +14 noises; 12:00 back: end right |
|
|
| NORDEND-133 | 20/09 15:15 → 15:45 | Visibility | kept | CTR01 rejected at 15:30 alone |
|
|
| NORDEND-134 | 21/09 06:00 → 22/09 06:30 | Thermal displacement | kept | tilt max +0.042 deg at 09:00, pan min 14:00; PR18 corr_x -0.125 px, PR16 -0.071, PR15 -0.062, PR14 -0.049, PR18 corr_y +0.056. Remark: on 22/09 the tilt already steps at 06:15 (-137.6 → -132.3 mdeg), the pan leaves at 06:00 → 06:15, PR03 and PR05 corr_y rise at 06:15-06:30; the turning point is 06:00, two steps before the cut 06:30 between 134 and 136; both are Thermal displacement, so every instant stays under the right label: not changed |
|
|
| NORDEND-135 | 21/09 14:30 → 16:15 | Visibility | kept | CTR01 rejected 14:45-16:00 (6); my thumbnail of 21/09 15:00 shows the rock around CTR01 in full sun |
|
|
| NORDEND-136 | 22/09 06:30 → 23/09 06:00 | Thermal displacement | kept | tilt max +0.052 deg at 08:15; PR18 corr_x -0.126, PR16 -0.069, PR15 -0.065, PR14 -0.051, PR18 corr_y +0.065 |
|
|
| NORDEND-137 | 22/09 14:30 → 16:15 | Visibility | kept | CTR01 rejected 14:45-16:00 (6) |
|
|
| NORDEND-138 | 23/09 06:00 → 24/09 07:00 | Thermal displacement | kept | tilt from -137 mdeg at 05:45 to -83 at 07:30 (fast part 07:15-07:30); PR18 corr_x -0.141 px, PR14-PR16 -0.066 to -0.076 at 08:00, PR18 corr_y +0.075; pan back up all night |
|
|
| NORDEND-139 | 23/09 14:15 → 15:45 | Visibility | kept | CTR01 rejected 14:45-15:00; corr_x already -0.07, -0.06 at 14:00-14:15, CTR02 corr_x +0.016 → -0.017 at 15:00-15:15 (largest jump of CTR02, ten noises), CTR03, CTR04 at the same instant |
|
|
| NORDEND-140 | 24/09 07:00 → 25/09 06:00 | Thermal displacement | kept | weakest day: PR18 corr_x -0.062, others -0.02 to -0.03, PR18 corr_y +0.035; pan up all night (+0.021 deg at 25/09 03:15) |
|
|
| NORDEND-141 | 24/09 11:15 → 26/09 12:45 | Obstruction | kept | CTR01 rejected from 11:30, PR09 from 11:45, PR01 at times from 25/09 08:00 to 26/09 11:45; last rejections of CTR01 and PR09 at 26/09 12:30, 12:45 clean; from 24/09 06:00 to 11:15, PR09 and CTR01 at their usual level and error_value. Error_value of CTR02 and PR17 up (60 and 220 noises) without effect on the corr of the others, except the one-measurement common x dip of 25/09 14:00 (section 2) |
|
|
| NORDEND-142 | 25/09 06:00 → 26/09 06:00 | Thermal displacement | kept | tilt max +0.045 deg at 07:45; PR18 corr_x -0.128, PR16 -0.084, PR15 -0.060, PR14 -0.048, PR17 -0.038, PR18 corr_y +0.082 |
|
|
| NORDEND-143 | 26/09 06:00 → 27/09 06:30 | Thermal displacement | kept | tilt max +0.053 deg at 09:00; PR18 -0.131, PR16 -0.074, PR15 -0.070, PR14 -0.052 at 08:45 |
|
|
| NORDEND-144 | 26/09 14:30 → 16:00 | Visibility | kept | CTR01 rejected 14:45-15:45 (5) |
|
|
| NORDEND-145 | 27/09 06:30 → 28/09 05:45 | Thermal displacement | kept | tilt max +0.045 deg at 09:45; PR18 -0.117, PR16 -0.073, PR15 -0.059, PR14 -0.047; next turning point 05:45 (pan 19.6 → 18.9 mdeg, tilt -125 → -122) |
|
|
| NORDEND-146 | 28/09 05:45 → 29/09 06:30 | Thermal displacement | kept | tilt max +0.042 deg at 09:15; PR18 -0.109, PR16 -0.068, PR15 -0.047, PR14 -0.044 |
|
|
| NORDEND-147 | 29/09 06:30 → 30/09 04:15 | Thermal displacement | kept | tilt max +0.034 deg at 12:15, PR18 -0.093, PR15, PR16 -0.049; ends at the range edge, continued by NORDEND-149 |
|
|
| NORDEND-148 | 29/09 14:30 → 16:00 | Visibility | kept | CTR01 rejected 14:45, 15:15-15:45; 15:00 accepted at error_value 0.36 with corr_x -0.062 (inside); 16:00 error_value 0.36, corr_y 0.164 against 0.20 around, about three noises, like the usual afternoon noise: end kept |
|
|
|
|
Spanning label NORDEND-24 (PR04, Target issue, 17/08 → 01/10): within the range, PR04 is rejected at times on 17-20/09, almost without interruption from 20/09 13:15 to 28/09 10:15, then more rarely on 28-29/09; its accepted corr are noisy (noise 0.017 against 0.005 for its neighbours). The label holds within the range.
|
|
|
|
## 1. My labels
|
|
|
|
The 23 kept labels are not repeated here (verdicts above). The added one:
|
|
|
|
### 2026-09-17T14:30Z → 2026-09-17T15:00Z
|
|
- **Phenomenon of the catalogue**: The sun in the field or behind a spot (Visibility); a target left under the threshold keeps its jump (`reading-rules.md`, section 5)
|
|
- **Precedents**: NORDEND-4, -7, -10, -13, -16 (CTR01 rejected on sunny afternoons, sun seen on the rock around it) and the kept 129, 135, 137 of this range: same target, same hour, same cause; here CTR01 stays just under its threshold, so its point stays
|
|
- **Family**: Visibility, like every CTR01 sunny-afternoon label of the station (same target, same family); not Obstruction (nothing in front: the lit background), not Displacement (cause seen)
|
|
- **Measured**: CTR01 corr_x between -0.059 and +0.013 from 12:30 to 14:30, **-0.073 at 14:45**, -0.012 at 15:00: a one-measurement jump of -0.079 px (largest jump of CTR01 in the range, 8.4 noises), back at 15:00; error_value 0.20 at 14:30, **0.353** at 14:45 (threshold 0.4), 0.18 at 15:00; corr_y 0.191 / 0.197 / 0.190 (unchanged). No other sensor beyond 4 noises at 14:45 except PR17 corr_y -4. CTR01 is not rejected that afternoon
|
|
- **Images**: thumbnails 17/09 14:00, 14:45, 15:15 and 21/09 15:00 (`ctr01_sun_2026-09-17.png`): at 14:45 the rock around CTR01 is bright (background 113 against 33 at 14:00 and 20 at 15:15), the spot drowning, the same picture as 21/09 15:00 (rejected then); at 15:15 the area is in shade and the spot sharp
|
|
- **Confidence**: high for the cause (seen); medium for the need of a label: one point, but clearly apart from the noisy afternoon of CTR01 and at the very hour it is rejected on the other sunny days
|
|
|
|
## 2. What I left without a label
|
|
|
|
- **17/09 14:15, 19/09 10:45, 19/09 13:45, 20/09 07:30**: error_value up on 5 to 10 sensors together for one measurement (CTR04, PR06-PR08, PR13-PR18), by day; corr at those instants within 4 noises of the rolling level, except PR02 corr_y +6 noises at 19/09 10:45 (one target, 0.04 px): an error_value rising without effect on the curves.
|
|
- **25/09 14:00**: PR08, PR16 corr_x -7 noises, PR14 -6, PR15, PR17, PR18 -5, PR06, PR12 -4, all in x, one measurement, back at 14:15. `overview.py --rigid` on 25/09 12:00-16:00: the CTR04 residual dx moves by +0.027 px at that instant (-0.016 → +0.012 → -0.026), the base shifts slightly while the camera is agitated in the warm hours (ty jumping by half a pixel from one measurement to the next): the afternoon agitation of the thermal cycle, under NORDEND-142, a few hundredths of a pixel, much smaller than the cycle itself.
|
|
- **22/09 10:00-10:30**: small common corr_y dip (PR10 -7 noises, others -4/-5), then CTR02, CTR03 corr_y diverging at 10:30 (±6 noises), CTR04 corr_x -7: within the warm-hours agitation of NORDEND-136.
|
|
- **Morning steps under the thermal labels** (18/09 07:30-08:00, 20/09 06:45-08:00 PR07, PR16, 23/09 07:30, 25/09 07:30-07:45, 26/09 08:45, 27/09 07:45-08:15 PR18, PR16): one-measurement deviations of 4 to 8 noises of the targets that carry the cycle, during the fast part of the camera movement: part of the cycle.
|
|
- **24/09 09:15-11:15**: PR09 corr_y -5/-6 noises at times: its usual morning scatter (0.09 to 0.14 since 06:00), error_value at its level; the cobweb starts at 11:30.
|
|
- **27/09 11:15**: CTR01 corr_y +6 noises for one measurement, error_value 0.23 (its usual level): a single noisy point, not at the sun hour. **27/09 14:45-15:15**: CTR01 error_value 0.33-0.35, corr unchanged.
|
|
- **CTR02, CTR03, CTR04 corr** at 21/09 17:00, 22/09 10:30: references, 5 to 7 noises of thousandths of a pixel, no target follows.
|
|
|
|
## 3. The documentation
|
|
|
|
- Helped: `labeling-rules.md` section 2 (the camera cycle starts at the morning turning point; one-step tolerance) to judge the cuts between the thermal labels; section 1 and `reading-rules.md` section 5 ("a target left under the threshold keeps its jump") for the added CTR01 point; `families.md` (the boundary "Target issue or episode") and the precedents to keep CTR01 in Visibility; `GUIDE.md`: `ranges.py --rolling --instants` and `overview.py --rigid` to find and explain the short collective deviations.
|
|
- The cut 134/136 on 22/09 falls two steps after the turning point (06:30 against 06:00): beyond the one-step tolerance, but it moves no instant out of a Thermal displacement label; the rules do not say whether such a shift between two consecutive thermal labels is worth losing a validation. I left it.
|
|
- PR18 corr_y in the thermal descriptions ("hardly moves" on 17/09 and 24/09, "rises" on 19/09) with similar amplitudes on 17/09 and 19/09: the wording is relative to the day, not to a fixed scale.
|
|
- No weather for NORDEND (no Swiss position): the instructions foresee it.
|
|
- No precedent for a single under-threshold point of CTR01 in the sun: the added label is the first.
|
|
|
|
## Difficulties
|
|
none
|
|
|
|
## Sources read
|
|
- `agents/agents/analyst.md`, `instructions/analyst.md`, `work/prompt.txt`, `work/existing.jsonl`, `work/spanning.jsonl`
|
|
- `tools/GUIDE.md`, `tools/DATA.md`; `labeling/families.md`, `labeling/labeling-rules.md`, `labeling/reading-rules.md`, `labeling/stations.md` (in full)
|
|
- `labeling/auto/NORDEND.jsonl` (labels from 15/09 to 02/10)
|
|
- `precedents.py` ("CTR01 … one-measurement corr_x jump in the afternoon without being rejected …")
|
|
- Tools: `inventory.py` (window), `overview.py` (window; 25/09 12:00-16:00 with `--rigid`), `ranges.py --rolling 4 --k 6 --instants 2`, `days.py --bounds --night 2-5 --smoothing 5`, `summary.py` (20/09 08:00-12:30: corr_x, corr_y, error_value), `thumbnails.py` (CTR01, PR09 at 17/09 14:00, 14:45, 15:15 and 21/09 15:00)
|
|
- My scripts: `scripts/look.py` (per instant, the sensors beyond K noises of the rolling ±4 level, and the rejections), inline reads of the pose and of CTR01, PR09, PR01 and the references through `tools/scripts/data.py`
|