Files
aimsight-labeling/auto/analyses/NORDEND_2026-10-13T0745_2026-10-24T1630/analysis.md
T

168 lines
16 KiB
Markdown
Raw Blame History

This file contains ambiguous Unicode characters
This file contains Unicode characters that might be confused with other characters. If you think that this is intentional, you can safely ignore this warning. Use the Escape button to reveal them.
# Labels: NORDEND, 2026-10-13T07:45Z → 2026-10-24T16:30Z (UTC)
Request: verify the 33 existing labels of the range (`work/existing.jsonl`), keep, correct, remove, add. DETECTORS: no.
Weather: `data/NORDEND/weather/` does not exist (no MeteoSwiss data for this station): no weather; the weather is read on the images only.
Image quality metrics (peak to snr): empty on this camera (`inventory.py`), so `quality.py` does not apply; spots read on IRON thumbnails.
## Verdict per existing label
| Old id | Verdict | Evidence |
|---|---|---|
| NORDEND-181 | kept | thermal cycle of the 13th; pose and corr as described (`days.py --bounds`) |
| NORDEND-182 | kept | 10:00-10:30: CTR04 error_value up (0.27 at 10:00), PR04/PR07 rejected, PR14-PR16 jump (`ranges.py --instants`) |
| NORDEND-183 | kept | PR09 rejected 17:15 → 07:00, PR04/PR07 from 16:15; targets touched from 16:30 |
| NORDEND-184 | kept | 05:15-06:00 CTR02, CTR03 rejected, no pose, targets jump by tens of noises; back at 06:15 |
| NORDEND-185 | kept | cycle of the 14th, tilt first exceedance 07:15 |
| NORDEND-186 | kept | CTR01 rejected 15:30-15:45; CTR03 error_value also up 15:00-16:00 (see section 2) |
| NORDEND-187 | kept | cycle of the 15th, pan/tilt from 07:45 |
| NORDEND-188 | kept | CTR01 rejected 15:45 |
| NORDEND-189 | kept | 10 steps missing 22:45 → 01:00, images missing too |
| NORDEND-190 | kept | cycle of the 16th |
| NORDEND-191 | kept | CTR01 rejected 08:15 |
| NORDEND-192 | kept | 13:30 missing; 13:45 and 14:00 present, so two labels with 193 |
| NORDEND-193 | kept | 14:15 missing |
| NORDEND-194 | kept | PR07 from 19:15, PR09 20:30 → 09:45 |
| NORDEND-196 | **corrected** (bounds, description) | starts 19:00 (targets already shift at 19:15 as CTR04's error_value rises), ends 23:00 (common jumps continue 21:30-22:45 while CTR04's error_value stays raised after its return) |
| NORDEND-197 | kept | weak cycle of the 17th |
| NORDEND-198 | kept | 13:00-15:30 rolling deviations PR12-PR16 |
| NORDEND-199 | kept | PR09 rejected 13:00 → 02:15 |
| NORDEND-200 | kept | weak cycle of the 18th |
| NORDEND-201 | kept | PR09 18:00 → 10:45, PR04/PR07 evening; PR01 rejected four times too (not named, minor) |
| NORDEND-202 | kept | cycle of the 19th |
| NORDEND-203 | kept | 09:00 missing |
| NORDEND-204 | kept | 09:45 missing (09:15 and 09:30 present: two labels) |
| NORDEND-205 | kept | 20:45 missing |
| NORDEND-206 | kept | cycle of the 20th |
| NORDEND-207 | kept | PR07 touched 20:30, PR09 22:15 → 05:15 |
| NORDEND-208 | kept | day pose below 5 noises but night cooling beyond (pan +13 noises at 01:15 on the 22nd): the label stands |
| NORDEND-209 | **corrected** (split in two, description) | two episodes separated by a calm from 12:15 to 14:15; "the other targets do not move" is false: PR15 corr_x −0.07 at 10:45-11:15, PR16 +0.076, PR14 +0.06; PR15 +0.25 corr_x at 16:45 |
| NORDEND-210 | kept | pan on the morning of the 23rd still lower than the day before (0.016 vs 0.027) |
| NORDEND-211 | **corrected** (split in two, description) | two episodes (09:15-11:00, 12:00-14:00); "the other targets do not move" is false: PR05 corr_x −0.20 / corr_y +0.33 at 09:30, PR14 +0.12 at 10:00, PR07 −0.086 at 12:30, PR16 +0.055 at 12:15 |
| NORDEND-212 | **corrected** (description) | bounds right (PR09 back at 08:00), but 06:00-07:30 the whole scene is hit by the dawn rain (new label): PR01, PR02, PR03, PR11, PR12, PR13 rejected; "the other targets remain measured" is false at that hour |
| NORDEND-213 | kept | rain day and night; the base step inside it is labelled apart (new label) |
| NORDEND-214 | kept | weak warming of the 24th; the two one-measurement jumps of the afternoon are labelled apart |
Spanning labels (not changed): NORDEND-152 (PR04), NORDEND-169 (PR17), NORDEND-195 (CTR01) hold within the range: PR04 rejected scattered by day and night; PR17's curve changes offset 21-24; CTR01 rejected only on sunny afternoons and left-edge nights before 16T19:00, much of the time after.
## 1. My labels
Only the corrected and added labels are detailed; the kept ones are in the table above.
### 2026-10-13T12:15Z → 2026-10-13T12:45Z (added)
- **Phenomenon of the catalogue**: Visibility drops over the whole scene (a brief drop of the light)
- **Precedents**: NORDEND-255 (PR07 rejected one measurement, PR15/PR16 jump, weak PR07 spot, Visibility), NORDEND-69 (validated): same family and wording
- **Family**: Visibility: the whole group's spots weaken, no object in front
- **Measured**: 12:30: PR07 rejected (error_value 0.82); corr_x PR16 −0.073, PR15 −0.062, PR14 −0.051, PR08 −0.039, PR06/PR05 −0.038, PR13 −0.036; refs ±0.003; error_value of PR11, PR14, PR16 up; 12:45 back
- **Images**: thumbnails 12:15/12:30/12:45 of PR07, PR14, PR16: at 12:30 spots smaller (PR07 peak 94 vs 246), background brighter; whole image 12:30: overcast, nothing in front
- **Confidence**: high for the event, medium for the cause
### 2026-10-16T19:00Z → 2026-10-16T23:00Z (NORDEND-196 corrected)
- **Phenomenon of the catalogue**: A reference loses its brightness, without an obstacle; A reference dropped: the base changes
- **Precedents**: the old label itself; NORDEND-173 (CTR04 discarded, all targets jump)
- **Family**: Visibility (unchanged)
- **Measured**: CTR04 error_value 0.034 → 0.047 (19:15) → 0.084 (19:30), rejected 19:45-20:45; at 19:15 corr_x PR16 +0.071, PR15 +0.045, PR06/PR08 +0.035; after the return (21:00), CTR04 error_value 0.05-0.19 until 22:30 and the targets jump together: PR08 +0.115 (21:45), −0.107 (22:30), +0.048 (22:45); 23:00 back (PR08 −0.005)
- **Images**: 20:00 (old label); not redone
- **Confidence**: high
### 2026-10-20T15:15Z → 2026-10-20T17:15Z (added)
- **Phenomenon of the catalogue**: A faint spot lost when the light is missing
- **Precedents**: NORDEND-69 (PR07 late afternoon, weak spot, Visibility, validated)
- **Family**: Visibility; not Target issue (PR07 is not rejected every evening at this hour)
- **Measured**: PR07 corr_x +0.104 at 15:30 (error 0.27), rejected 15:45, −0.058 at 16:30, −0.048 at 17:00 (error 0.13-0.28); PR09 corr_y +0.054, PR15 +0.045 at 15:45; refs flat; 17:15 back
- **Images**: thumbnails 14:30, 15:30, 15:45, 16:45: the image darkens to the noisy night image; PR07 spot faint, nothing in front
- **Confidence**: medium
### 2026-10-20T23:45Z → 2026-10-21T01:45Z (added)
- **Phenomenon of the catalogue**: Part of the scene goes dark at night
- **Precedents**: the left-edge night labels of NORDEND (same station, other targets)
- **Family**: Visibility: spots weaken without an object
- **Measured**: error_value PR14 0.17 → 0.42 (rejected 00:15), PR16 0.20-0.37, PR15 0.08-0.18 (00:00-00:30); corr_y PR15 −0.063, PR16 −0.084 (00:15); corr_x of most targets +0.02 to +0.05 (00:00-00:45); PR15 corr_x −0.064 to −0.090 from 00:45 to 01:30, −0.014 at 01:45; refs flat
- **Images**: thumbnails 23:30, 00:15, 00:30, 01:15 (fixed frame): PR14, PR15, PR16 spots much smaller (p99 138 vs 238), PR12 a little
- **Confidence**: high for the event, low for the cause
### 2026-10-21T10:15Z → 12:15Z and 2026-10-21T14:15Z → 17:15Z (NORDEND-209 split)
- **Phenomenon of the catalogue**: A faint spot lost when the light is missing
- **Precedents**: NORDEND-209 itself
- **Family**: Visibility (unchanged)
- **Measured**: first: PR07 rejected 10:30-10:45, PR09 10:30-11:15; PR15 corr_x −0.064/−0.073/−0.069 (10:45-11:15), PR16 +0.076 (11:15) and +0.048 (12:00), PR14 +0.062 (10:30); 12:15 back. Second: PR07 +0.045 (14:30), then rejected 14:45-15:15 and 16:30-16:45; PR09 rejected 14:45-16:45; 16:45 PR15 corr_x +0.253 and corr_y +15 noises, PR16 +0.078, PR14 +0.054, all error_values about doubled; 17:00 PR16 +0.036; 17:15 back
- **Images**: zone thumbnails 10:00, 10:45, 15:00, 16:45: spots smaller at 10:45, noisy night image at 16:45
- **Confidence**: high
### 2026-10-22T08:30Z → 2026-10-22T09:00Z (added)
- **Phenomenon of the catalogue**: none sure (a pass-by hiding targets for one measurement would fit, not seen)
- **Precedents**: WYOMING-17 (one-measurement jump, cause not established, Displacement); JUNGFRAU-55
- **Family**: Displacement: jump then return without an established cause (families.md boundary)
- **Measured**: 08:45: PR02 corr_x +0.079, corr_y +0.147, error 0.145; PR03 corr_x −0.050, corr_y +0.221, error 0.231; others and refs flat; 09:00 back
- **Images**: thumbnails 08:30, 08:45, 09:00 (zone, contrast): nothing seen
- **Confidence**: high for the event, cause unknown
### 2026-10-22T09:15Z → 11:00Z and 2026-10-22T12:00Z → 14:00Z (NORDEND-211 split)
- **Phenomenon of the catalogue**: A faint spot lost when the light is missing
- **Family**: Visibility (unchanged)
- **Measured**: 09:30: error_value PR03 0.15, PR05 0.21, PR06 0.20, PR15 0.21; PR05 corr_x −0.203, corr_y +0.328; PR14 corr_x +0.079 (09:30), +0.124 (10:00), +0.094 (10:15), back 10:30; PR09 rejected 09:30-10:45. Second: PR07 corr_x +0.044 (12:15), −0.086 (12:30); PR16 +0.055 (12:15), PR15 −0.051 (12:30); PR09 rejected 12:30-13:15 and 13:45
- **Images**: thumbnails 08:30, 08:45, 09:30, 10:00 and 11:45, 12:15, 12:30, 14:15: spots smaller at 09:30, much weaker at 12:15-12:30, nothing in front
- **Confidence**: high
### 2026-10-22T20:15Z → 2026-10-23T08:00Z (NORDEND-212, description only)
- Bounds kept; the description adds the dawn rain of the 23rd (new label) and moves PR01's rejections to it. Measured: PR09 rejected 20:30 → 04:30 and 06:00 → 07:45.
### 2026-10-23T05:45Z → 2026-10-23T07:45Z (added)
- **Phenomenon of the catalogue**: Rain
- **Precedents**: NORDEND-213 (the rain of the same day), NORDEND-184 (dawn mist of the 14th)
- **Family**: Visibility: drops on the window seen, whole scene
- **Measured**: error_value of all sensors 0.12-0.23 at 06:15; rejected PR01 06:00-07:00, PR02, PR03, PR11, PR12, PR13 06:15-06:45; corr_x PR15 +0.052/+0.133 (06:00/06:15), PR16 +0.065, PR08 −0.082, PR06 −0.061 (06:45); 07:15 most targets −0.02 to −0.04; 07:45 back
- **Images**: 06:45 whole image: dark hazy scene, blurred drops in the lower left of the window
- **Confidence**: high
### 2026-10-23T14:15Z → 2026-10-23T14:45Z (added)
- **Phenomenon of the catalogue**: The base changes without a reference lost
- **Precedents**: LENZSPITZE-105/106/108 (base change, Displacement); JUNGFRAU-117 (targets stay shifted after rain)
- **Family**: Displacement: lasting step without an established cause, all references kept
- **Measured**: corr_x CTR02 −0.002 (14:15) → −0.040 (14:30) → −0.028 (14:45), −0.028 (16:45), −0.030 (17:45 on); CTR03 +0.004 → +0.035 → +0.027, +0.030. Night medians before (22nd and 23rd, 02:00-05:00) and after (24th, 04:00-07:00): corr_x CTR02 0.000 → −0.019, CTR03 0.021 → 0.043, PR02 0.013 → 0.045, PR03 0.028 → 0.052, PR12 0.062 → 0.105; corr_y CTR02 0.091 → 0.109, CTR04 −0.014 → −0.022, PR06 0.091 → 0.050, PR08 −0.015 → −0.049; hourly medians stable through the 24th until 16:30 (no return). Raw x of the references move with the targets (no raw jump of the targets)
- **Images**: none useful (rain)
- **Confidence**: medium (the step is clear; its cause is unknown, and the levels change again on the 25th-26th, outside the range)
### 2026-10-23T14:45Z → 2026-10-24T07:30Z (added)
- **Phenomenon of the catalogue**: The camera moves through a thermal effect (cooling)
- **Precedents**: WYOMING-7 (evening cooling with rain, thermal), NORDEND-210 (camera not coming back at night)
- **Family**: Thermal displacement: the pose follows the housing temperature and comes back with it on the 24th
- **Measured**: housing temperature 28.2 °C (14:00) → 25.0 (21:00) → 23.5-24.5 (00:00-07:00), back to 28.6 at 12:00 on the 24th; pan (hourly) 0.010-0.018 by day on the 23rd → 0.022-0.027 at night → 0.011-0.013 at 11:00-13:00 on the 24th; tilt −0.124 → −0.140 → −0.126; corr flat apart from the rain and the base step
- **Images**: none
- **Confidence**: medium (pose partly hidden by the two-reference instants of 15:00-17:30)
### 2026-10-24T14:00Z → 2026-10-24T14:30Z (added)
- **Phenomenon of the catalogue**: A step of the camera that the compensation does not erase (one measurement)
- **Family**: Displacement: jump and return, cause not established
- **Measured**: 14:15: raw y of CTR04 −0.5 px, CTR02 and CTR03 −0.4, PR16 −0.5 (all together); tilt −0.132 vs −0.125/−0.127; error_value of all sensors 0.11-0.14 (vs 0.03-0.06); corr_y PR06 −0.036, PR14 −0.029, PR18 −0.028, PR15 −0.027, PR13 −0.022; corr_x PR16 +0.026; 14:30 back
- **Images**: zone and reference thumbnails 14:00, 14:15: nothing in front, overcast
- **Confidence**: medium
### 2026-10-24T15:00Z → 2026-10-24T15:30Z (added)
- **Phenomenon of the catalogue**: The base changes without a reference lost (one measurement)
- **Family**: Displacement
- **Measured**: 15:15: corr_y PR16 +0.068, PR15 +0.057, PR06 +0.054, PR13 +0.053, PR12 +0.048, PR18 +0.046; corr_x PR06 −0.038, PR11 −0.033, PR16 −0.033; corr_x CTR02 −0.012, CTR03 +0.010; CTR04 error_value 0.077 (vs 0.05), others at level; raw y of the targets unchanged; 15:30 back
- **Images**: thumbnails 15:00, 15:15: darker background at 15:15, nothing in front of the references
- **Confidence**: medium
## 2. What I left without a label
- 2026-10-14 15:00-16:00: CTR03 error_value up to 0.21 (sun on the rock), the references' corr_y move apart a little (±0.027), targets' corr_y +0.02 to +0.05 during the afternoon thermal return: within the time of NORDEND-186 and the thermal label; not split.
- 2026-10-20 18:15: PR07 corr_x −0.054 for one measurement, error_value at its level: PR07 is the noisiest target (faint spot); left as noise.
- 2026-10-24 11:15: the corr of the three references move by a few thousandths (7-8 noises of their own tiny noise), targets flat.
- Error_value spikes on all sensors without effect on corr: 2026-10-21 17:45, 2026-10-22 07:00, 2026-10-23 08:30, 2026-10-24 09:30.
- Isolated single-sensor deviations of about 6 noises (PR07, PR09, PR13, CTR04), listed by `scripts/uncovered.py 6`.
## 3. The documentation
- Helpful: `labeling-rules.md` "one label, a single event" and "a range ends at the measurement after the last touched", which decided the splits of 209 and 211 and the end of 196; `families.md` "The base changes without a reference lost"; the precedents NORDEND-69/255 for PR07 in dim light.
- The old labels 209 and 211 said "the other targets and the references do not move": contradicted by the residuals (PR05, PR14, PR15, PR16 jump by tens of noises). The earlier reading likely followed the rejections, not the corr of the measured targets.
- The base step of the 23rd is hidden under the rain label and only shows when the night levels before and after are compared (`scripts/levels.py`): the guide could suggest comparing night levels on each side of a long Visibility episode.
- No weather folder for NORDEND, and no image quality metrics: the causes rest on the IRON thumbnails.
## Difficulties
- The thermal labels cover the whole range, so a coverage check of the jumps has to ignore them (`scripts/uncovered.py`).
- The Write tool refused `.md` files in this session; analysis.md and report.md were written through Bash.
## Sources read
`agents/agents/analyst.md`, `instructions/analyst.md`, `tools/GUIDE.md`, `tools/DATA.md`, `labeling/families.md`, `labeling/labeling-rules.md`, `labeling/reading-rules.md`, `labeling/stations.md`, `work/existing.jsonl`, `work/spanning.jsonl`, `precedents.py` (queries cited above). Tools: `inventory.py`, `overview.py`, `ranges.py --rolling 8 --instants 3`, `days.py --bounds`, `metrics.py`, `summary.py`, `plot.py`, `thumbnails.py`; scripts `scripts/tab.py`, `scripts/levels.py`, `scripts/uncovered.py`, `scripts/build.py`. Images: whole images 2026-10-13 12:30 and 2026-10-23 06:45; thumbnail sheets in `work/`.