Files
aimsight-labeling/knowledge/expert-annotated-cases.md
T

49 lines
4.7 KiB
Markdown
Raw Blame History

This file contains ambiguous Unicode characters
This file contains Unicode characters that might be confused with other characters. If you think that this is intentional, you can safely ignore this warning. Use the Escape button to reveal them.
# Cases annotated by the expert (displacements)
Two analysis reports handed to the client by the AIMsight team (May 2026, revision 1.0, in French), stored as they are in `docs/aimsight/`:
- `Mur de soutènement GN-1.472.pdf` (16 p.): written report;
- `Mur de soutènement GN-5.054.pdf` (7 p.): draft, partly in notes; the introduction announces three walls, only one is detailed.
Masonry retaining walls along a railway line, monitored for nearly two years, with prisms and adhesive reflective strips ("ciblettes"). Verdict of both reports: **no notable structural displacement**; each apparent displacement is attributed to an external cause, with evidence (images, `error`, brightness).
They serve as reference truth for `displacement`, with two limits:
- the exports of these walls are not in `data/`: neither the signatures can be verified nor an event replayed. They therefore do not enter the diagnostic agent's event base (`events/`, D-048);
- the signatures below are read from the figures of the reports (axes illegible in GN-5.054); no time is given there.
## Wall GN-1.472 (01/01 to 15/03/2026, detail from 15/02 to 15/03)
| Finding | Signature (report figures) | Expert diagnosis | Evidence cited |
|---|---|---|---|
| H22 and H27, at the top of the wall | vertical: 24 h cycle, correlated between the two, ~10 mm peak to peak, whole period | mutual interference of two very close prisms; persistent anomaly, not a movement of the structure | photo of the two prisms; brightness of H27 well above its neighbors |
| H18, H26, H31, H21 | isolated peaks, one target at a time, up to ~30 mm | a neighboring prism that is too bright hampers detection; too large for masonry | images without obstruction; `error` > 0.7 (H18, and H26 or H22: the report contradicts itself); unbalanced brightness |
| C17 | horizontal: square waves by day, around −65 mm, return at night | dim prism, insufficient contrast against daylight | day and night images; `error` rises by day, without exceeding 0.7 |
| Camera movements | pan, roll, tilt: 24 h cycle badly compensated; scale stable | not a camera movement: 2 references out of 4 masked by vegetation (growing since March 2025), insufficient base for the transformation | images of March 2025 and current |
| Snow, 11/01/2026 | noise and apparent movements on all sensors and the camera; brief data loss | snowfall; probably a flake in front of the lens for the loss | photo of the flakes; images before and after, signal quickly back |
| Interruption (date not given) | gap, drawn in straight lines | `possible`: frost or condensation ("it could be", cold period) | none |
- A badly configured offset shifts the horizontal curves of a target below zero: parametric, no effect on interpretation.
- Remedies proposed: fewer targets, prisms instead of strips, one more reference, brush clearing or moved references, alarms when a target or a reference becomes invisible.
## Wall GN-5.054-MU-G-AV (nearly two years)
103 targets, the largest surface; the most exposed system (altitude, snow clearing that pushes snow against the station).
| Finding | Signature | Expert diagnosis | Evidence cited |
|---|---|---|---|
| Snow | the traces of the hidden targets disappear, the others stay stable | outright obstruction by snow | winter images |
| R2_C20 | jump in the measurements | a plant grows in front of the strip and gradually hides it (partial obstruction) | two images two days apart |
| Data lost in winter | gap | remote solar panel covered with snow, unfavorable orientation: accepted compromise (budget) | operator context |
| Station moved after the first winter | (not shown) | station buried, freeze-thaw cycles that destabilized the mast; guy wires added | on-site intervention |
| Power connector | (not shown) | partly torn off by a snow projection during clearing; replaced by a more robust variant | on-site intervention |
- Most delicate obstruction according to the expert: vegetation (growth, leaves in the wind), partial, for which the default acceptance threshold was not enough.
- Strips up to 40 m; some, near much brighter prisms, badly measured or eliminated.
## What these events add to the framing
Families absent from the table §4.1 of `docs/displacement/cadrage.md`, to be confronted with data when we have some:
- **interference between neighboring targets**: clear image, but a neighbor that is too bright; *Dominance* (FAQ) measures this risk, in the HDF5 only;
- **progressive occlusion** (vegetation): days or weeks, not reversible from one measurement to the next like a passing occlusion;
- **masked references**: 24 h cycle on pan, roll, tilt, not to be read as a camera movement (instability of the compensation, `labeling/knowledge/displacement-columns.md`);
- **daytime contrast**: the "Lighting" family, here on a single prism, in day / night square waves.