- 32 analyses: each label kept, rewritten or removed by its analyst (section Requalification of the report; mm magnitudes where the targets have them) - SNCF01 x3, WILDSTRUBEL 2026-09-01 -> 2026-10-06 x3: verified from their existing labels under the new rules - long labels (no analysis): auto/analyses/long-labels/<STATION>/; NORDEND-169 and -195 run to 07/11, so NORDEND-283 and -284 (their continuation) are removed - reading-rules.md, stations.md: the citations of removed or rewritten labels point to their successor, or to [expert] Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
125 lines
16 KiB
Markdown
125 lines
16 KiB
Markdown
# Labels: NORDEND, 2026-08-23T05:15Z → 2026-09-04T06:15Z (UTC)
|
||
|
||
Request: requalify the 42 labels of this analysis (`work/requalify_input.jsonl`) under the new rules (`labeling-rules.md`, section 1): only what stands out from the noise of the corrected curves, at least one target beyond 5 of its own noises; no label for missing points alone; a thermal label only if the corrected curves keep it; No data only when the station delivers nothing. Not a new reading: the previous verification (kept in `work/rq/analysis.before-requalify.md`) stands. DETECTORS: no.
|
||
|
||
Result: **35 kept as they are** (id and review field unchanged), **3 rewritten** (NORDEND-66, NORDEND-252, NORDEND-79: right in substance, their description rested on CTR01's missing curve), **4 removed** (NORDEND-53, NORDEND-248, NORDEND-253, NORDEND-83); 38 labels in `labels.jsonl`.
|
||
|
||
Context (unchanged from the verification): no `data/NORDEND/weather/` folder, so no MeteoSwiss weather (station without a Swiss position): the images are the only witness of the weather. No image quality metrics (old camera). Housing temperature 26.5 to 46.9 °C, pan r = −0.98, scale r = +0.97 against it: the daily camera cycle is thermal. Targets 84 m (PR08, PR16) to 151 m (PR01, PR09) from the camera, 31 to 60 mm per px; the corr noise of a target is 0.004 to 0.007 px, i.e. about 0.15 to 0.35 mm (PR04 0.012 px, Target issue NORDEND-24).
|
||
|
||
## 1. My labels
|
||
|
||
How each label was measured (section "Requalification" below): the short labels against a rolling level (±8 measurements, ±2 h, self excluded), at k = 5, in the target's own noise over the batch; the thermal labels per target, hourly median of corr minus the level of the night before the cycle (3 h before its start), in the same noise, the instants of the other short labels left out. References CTR02, CTR03, CTR04 are not counted (they are not targets); PR04 is left out of the thermal check (Target issue NORDEND-24).
|
||
|
||
### The 35 labels kept as they are
|
||
|
||
| id | Family | Largest deviation of a target in the label (noises) | mm |
|
||
|---|---|---|---|
|
||
| NORDEND-51 | Thermal | PR18 corr_x −17.8 (23/08 07h) | ≈ 5 |
|
||
| NORDEND-52 | Thermal | PR18 corr_x −23.0 (24/08 08h), PR16 −14, PR18 corr_y +12.8 | ≈ 7 |
|
||
| NORDEND-54 | No data | the station delivers nothing at 01:30 | – |
|
||
| NORDEND-55 | Thermal | PR18 corr_x −13.4 (25/08 08h) | ≈ 4 |
|
||
| NORDEND-56 | Thermal | PR18 corr_x −11.1 (26/08 11h); −9.5 against the following night | ≈ 3.4 |
|
||
| NORDEND-57 | Visibility | PR16 corr_x +18.6 (08:30), PR08 +14, PR14 +14, PR06 +13.5 | PR01 y 3.8, PR16 x 3.3 |
|
||
| NORDEND-58 | No data | nothing at 01:30 | – |
|
||
| NORDEND-246 | Thermal | PR18 corr_x −13.9 (27/08 10h), PR16 −10 | ≈ 4 |
|
||
| NORDEND-247 | Visibility | PR08 corr_x −24.5 (21:45), PR06 −15, PR05 −13; PR08 −16 (hourly) around midnight | ≈ 3 |
|
||
| NORDEND-61 | Obstruction | PR18 corr_y −13.6 (21:15), PR13 corr_y +13.4 (21:30), PR08 corr_x −24.5 (21:45) | ≈ 3.4 |
|
||
| NORDEND-62 | No data | nothing at 01:45 | – |
|
||
| NORDEND-64 | No data | nothing 08:00 → 11:45 | – |
|
||
| NORDEND-249 | Visibility | PR12 corr_x +7.1, PR03 +5.8, PR11 +5.6 (12:15) | ≈ 1.5 |
|
||
| NORDEND-65 | Visibility | PR14 corr_x −64, PR07 −63, PR05 −58, PR13 −56 (12:45) | ≈ 12 |
|
||
| NORDEND-67 | Visibility | PR08 corr_x −15.8 (16:15), PR07 −14, PR15 +12.7 | ≈ 2.5 |
|
||
| NORDEND-68 | Thermal | PR18 corr_x −12.2 (29/08 07h), PR18 corr_y +10.1 | ≈ 3.7 |
|
||
| NORDEND-250 | Displacement | PR15 corr_x +8.6, PR16 +7.7 (12:00) | ≈ 1.5 |
|
||
| NORDEND-69 | Visibility | PR07 corr_x +10.0 (18:45), −9.4 (16:15), PR16 +9.4 | ≈ 1.8 |
|
||
| NORDEND-70 | Visibility | PR16 corr_x +11.2, PR15 corr_y +10.1 (22:30) | ≈ 2 |
|
||
| NORDEND-71 | Visibility | PR14 corr_x +20.5, PR15 +15.8 (00:45) | ≈ 4 |
|
||
| NORDEND-72 | Thermal | PR14 corr_x −5.9 (30/08 18h), −5.4 (08h); PR18 corr_y +5.5 (09h) | ≈ 1.2 (marginal) |
|
||
| NORDEND-73 | Visibility | PR15 corr_x −12.1 (00:00), PR14 +10.7 (00:15) | ≈ 2.2 |
|
||
| NORDEND-74 | Thermal | PR18 corr_y −5.1, PR01 corr_y +5.3 (31/08 14h); PR18 corr_x −6.1 (10h) against the following night | ≈ 1 (marginal) |
|
||
| NORDEND-251 | Displacement | PR05 corr_x −12.0 (11:45), PR08 −8.4, PR12 −6 | ≈ 2.4 |
|
||
| NORDEND-75 | Visibility | PR14 corr_x −21.2 (13:00), corr_y −15 (13:15), PR16 corr_y +12.7 | ≈ 4 |
|
||
| NORDEND-77 | No data | nothing at 01:00 | – |
|
||
| NORDEND-78 | Thermal | PR18 corr_x −8.0 (01/09 08h); −10.1 against the following night | ≈ 2.4 |
|
||
| NORDEND-80 | Displacement | PR11 corr_x −7.1, PR17 −6.6, PR13 corr_y −6.3, PR08 −6 (15:45) | ≈ 1.7 |
|
||
| NORDEND-81 | Thermal | PR18 corr_x −12.9 (02/09 10h), PR16 −9 | ≈ 3.9 |
|
||
| NORDEND-82 | No data | nothing at 01:30, 01:45 | – |
|
||
| NORDEND-254 | Visibility | PR07 corr_y +8.3 (09:00) | ≈ 1.7 |
|
||
| NORDEND-255 | Visibility | PR15 corr_x +10.4, PR16 corr_y +9.8, PR12 +8.8 (13:30); PR18 corr_x +5.7 (13:45) | ≈ 2–3 |
|
||
| NORDEND-85 | Visibility | PR14 corr_x +11.3, PR07 +9.6, PR18 +9.1 (16:45) | ≈ 2.8 |
|
||
| NORDEND-86 | Obstruction | PR16 corr_x +18.0 (23:00), corr_y −17.4 (23:15), PR15 corr_x −16.6 (23:30) | ≈ 3.2 |
|
||
| NORDEND-87 | No data | nothing at 01:15, 01:30 | – |
|
||
|
||
The seven No data labels all mark instants where no sensor has a measurement (inventory: steps absent for all sensors): they hold under the new rule whatever their length. NORDEND-72 and NORDEND-74 are just above the threshold (hourly medians at 5.3 to 6.1 noises, depending on the reference night); they stay, as the rule asks, but they are the weakest labels of the batch.
|
||
|
||
### 2026-08-28T14:15Z → 2026-08-28T14:45Z (NORDEND-66, rewritten)
|
||
- **Phenomenon of the catalogue**: The sun in the field or behind a spot (CTR01), with a whole-scene error_value rise of one measurement
|
||
- **Precedents**: NORDEND-249 (same day, a whole-scene error_value rise of two measurements with small jumps, Visibility); the old description of this label
|
||
- **Family**: Visibility, unchanged: the whole image degraded for one measurement in strong sun, no object, no camera step
|
||
- **Measured**: at 14:30 the error_value of 21 sensors, the three references included, rises together (+20 to +74 noises; CTR04 0.28, CTR02 0.17, CTR03 0.20, inlier 1 for all), CTR01 rejected; PR18 corr_x +7 noises (+2.1 mm), PR09 −5 (−1.8 mm), PR14 +5 (+1.0 mm); 14:45 back. The old description spoke only of CTR01's missing curve, which is no longer labelled: rewritten on the effect on the other targets. PR12 corr_x is at −6 noises already at 14:15, the opening measurement: strictly the start would be 14:00; the bounds of a label that holds are not moved here.
|
||
- **Images**: 14:30 thumbnail (from the verification): rock in full sun around CTR01
|
||
- **Confidence**: high on the event (just above threshold), cause of the whole-scene rise not established
|
||
|
||
### 2026-08-31T14:30Z → 2026-08-31T15:00Z (NORDEND-252, rewritten)
|
||
- **Phenomenon of the catalogue**: same as NORDEND-66
|
||
- **Precedents**: NORDEND-66 (same signature three days before)
|
||
- **Family**: Visibility, unchanged
|
||
- **Measured**: at 14:30 (the opening measurement), error_value of 20 sensors up together (+12 to +62 noises), PR18 corr_x +5, PR03 corr_y +7 noises (+2.0 mm); at 14:45 CTR01 rejected, PR18 corr_x +6 noises (+1.8 mm); 15:00 back. Rewritten: the old description rested on CTR01's missing curve and pointed to NORDEND-253, now removed. As for NORDEND-66, the effect starts at the start bound (14:30): strictly the start would be 14:15; left as it is (bounds not moved in a requalification), to be fixed by the user if wanted.
|
||
- **Images**: 14:45 thumbnail (from the verification): rock in full sun around CTR01
|
||
- **Confidence**: medium: the jumps are just above the threshold
|
||
|
||
### 2026-09-01T14:45Z → 2026-09-01T15:30Z (NORDEND-79, rewritten)
|
||
- **Phenomenon of the catalogue**: The sun in the field or behind a spot (CTR01)
|
||
- **Precedents**: NORDEND-66, NORDEND-252
|
||
- **Family**: Visibility, unchanged (same episode as the other sunny afternoons of CTR01)
|
||
- **Measured**: CTR01 rejected 15:00, 15:15; at 15:00 PR01 corr_y +7 noises (+3.0 mm), at 15:15 PR05 corr_x +7 (+1.3 mm), PR14 +5 (+1.1 mm), PR01 corr_y +6; the error_value of the other sensors stays at its level (only CTR01's rises), all references retained; 15:30 back. Rewritten on the effect on the other targets; the old description cited dates outside the range for its deduced cause.
|
||
- **Images**: none (cause deduced, as in the old label)
|
||
- **Confidence**: medium: just above threshold, the link between CTR01's sun and the jumps of the others is not established
|
||
|
||
## 2. What I left without a label
|
||
|
||
### The removed labels
|
||
|
||
| id | Bounds | Family | Why |
|
||
|---|---|---|---|
|
||
| NORDEND-53 | 2026-08-24T11:00Z → 2026-08-25T12:30Z | Obstruction | Missing points only: PR07 rejected almost without interruption under a cobweb thread. PR07 is not a reference, its loss moves nothing else. The deviations inside the range belong to other events: PR01 corr_y +8.9 and PR14 corr_x +6.8 noises at 24/08 15:15 (afternoon agitation of the thermal day, under NORDEND-52), PR18 corr_x −7.6 at 25/08 09:30 and −7 at 08:45 (morning of the thermal cycle NORDEND-55). PR07 is not rejected almost always over the batch (135 rejections out of 1133 measurements, by episodes): not a Target issue. |
|
||
| NORDEND-248 | 2026-08-28T07:00Z → 2026-08-29T06:00Z | Thermal displacement | Compensated thermal: the night of 28/08 before the cycle is under the cobweb (NORDEND-247), so the level was taken on the night of 27/08 and on that of 29/08. Max 5.9 noises against 27/08 (PR15 corr_y at 18h, the tail of the afternoon episode NORDEND-67; PR14 corr_x +5.8 at night, a difference of night level, not a cycle), 5.1 against 29/08 (PR15 corr_y 18h again); the daytime remainder of the camera cycle itself is at most 4.4 noises (PR18 corr_y 14h). The label itself said "the corrected curves hardly depart from it". |
|
||
| NORDEND-253 | 2026-08-31T15:45Z → 2026-08-31T16:15Z | Visibility | Missing point only: CTR01 rejected at 16:00; no target beyond 5 noises (the error_value of all the sensors rises at 16:00 and 16:15, without effect on corr). |
|
||
| NORDEND-83 | 2026-09-03T06:30Z → 2026-09-04T06:15Z | Thermal displacement | Compensated thermal: outside the cobweb thread of NORDEND-86 (kept, it carries the 23:00 deviations of PR15, PR14, PR16 up to 16–21 noises), the largest deviation from the night level is 4.6 noises (CTR01 corr_y) against the night of 03/09, 3.8 against the night of 04/09; PR15's "drop a little" stays under the threshold. |
|
||
|
||
Consequences on the kept labels: NORDEND-246 and NORDEND-68 now touch a day without a thermal label (28/08), which is right (camera cycle absorbed that day). The descriptions of NORDEND-247 and NORDEND-249 cite only labels that remain (gap NORDEND-64, spider NORDEND-61, CTR04 NORDEND-65). NORDEND-252 cited NORDEND-253 ("next label"): rewritten.
|
||
|
||
### Unchanged from the verification
|
||
- **Morning agitation of the thermal cycles** (23/08 08:30, 24/08 08:00-09:00, 25/08 08:15-09:30, 30/08 09:00, 01/09 08:15-08:30, 02/09 08:30-09:45): 3-9 targets at 5-9 noises during the fast morning movement of the camera: inside the thermal labels, described there.
|
||
- **Afternoon jumps under the pose agitation** (23/08 15:15 and 15:45, 24/08 15:15 and 15:45, 26/08 14:45 and 16:15): 2-5 targets at 4-9 noises, error_value not rising: the agitation of the thermal day, inside the thermal labels.
|
||
- **Whole-scene error_value rises with nothing on the curves** (27/08 10:45, 11:45, 19:30; 28/08 13:30; 29/08 07:45, 10:00; 30/08 10:30; 31/08 08:45, 09:00, 11:00, 12:00, 14:00, 15:15, 16:15, 16:30; 01/09 11:15): no target at 5 noises.
|
||
- **References alone at 5-8 noises** (23/08 05:15-05:45, 24/08 08:30, 08:45 and 17:00, 27/08 10:45 and 14:30, 28/08 15:30, 02/09 09:00): their corr only, the targets do not follow.
|
||
- **Missing points not labelled** (new rule): CTR01's sunny-afternoon rejections and PR07's rejections are labelled only where they come with jumps of the other targets (the labels above).
|
||
|
||
## Requalification
|
||
|
||
Commands (from the repository root, outputs in `work/rq/`):
|
||
- `python3 tools/scripts/ranges.py data/NORDEND --columns corr_x,corr_y --k 5 --rolling 8 --start 2026-08-23T05:15Z --end 2026-09-04T06:15Z` → `ranges_roll8.txt` (level ±2 h, noise per target over the batch); with `--columns corr_x,corr_y,error_value --instants 1` → `instants_roll8.txt` (who deviates at each instant, the references).
|
||
- `python3 scripts/requalify.py work/requalify_input.jsonl work/rq/ranges_roll8.txt` → `requalify.txt` (short labels: target ranges overlapping the label, max in noises; thermal labels: hourly median against the night before, the instants of the short labels left out → `thermal_excl.txt`).
|
||
- `python3 scripts/thermal_nights.py … NORDEND-248 2026-08-27T02:45Z NORDEND-248 2026-08-29T03:00Z NORDEND-72 … NORDEND-74 … NORDEND-83 … NORDEND-78 … NORDEND-56 …` → `thermal_nights.txt` (the weak thermal days against the night before and the night after).
|
||
- `python3 tools/scripts/ranges.py data/NORDEND --columns corr_x,corr_y --k 5 --min-measurements 4 --start S --end E` on the weak thermal days → `thermal_MM-DD.txt` (window level; confirms that 28/08 and 03/09 keep nothing of their own outside the short labels).
|
||
|
||
Values: thermal max (noises, night before / night after): 51 17.8; 52 23.0; 55 13.4; 56 11.1 / 9.5; 246 13.9; **248 5.9 / 5.1, cycle itself ≤ 4.4 → removed**; 68 12.2; 72 5.9 / 4.5; 74 5.3 / 6.7; 78 8.0 / 10.1; 81 12.9; **83 4.6 / 3.8 → removed**. Short labels: max 6.0 (252) to 64 (65); **253: none beyond 5 → removed**; **53: nothing of its own → removed**. `validate.py labels.jsonl`: 38 labels, 0 errors.
|
||
|
||
## 3. The documentation
|
||
|
||
- `labeling-rules.md`, section 1 and `families.md` ("What is not labeled", "A gap") gave the three decisions directly: missing points alone (NORDEND-53, 253), compensated thermal (NORDEND-248, 83), the CTR01 labels kept only for their effect on the others.
|
||
- The rule for thermal labels says "beyond 5 noises from the night level" without saying which noise: I took the target's own noise at the native step over the batch (the `ranges.py` noise) against the hourly median, which is a little lenient for a slow cycle; at the native step the weak days give the same verdicts. It also does not say what to do when the night before is under another event (28/08): I used the nights on either side.
|
||
- Requalifying without moving bounds leaves two known bound errors (NORDEND-66, NORDEND-252: the effect on the others is already at the opening measurement); noted above for the user.
|
||
- From the verification (still valid): the catalogue has no entry for a whole-scene error_value rise of one or two measurements by day without an obstacle (28/08 12:00-12:45, 14:30; 31/08 14:30); the brief PR07 labels are Visibility by consistency, though the boundary text would say Displacement for a jump without a seen nuisance; NORDEND-77, 82, 87 cite JUNGFRAU only while WILDSTRUBEL measures at those minutes.
|
||
|
||
## Difficulties
|
||
- No weather for NORDEND (no `weather/` folder), no image quality (old camera).
|
||
- The thermal threshold depends on the reference night chosen for the two weakest days kept (NORDEND-72, NORDEND-74): both nights are given.
|
||
|
||
## Sources read
|
||
- `instructions/analyst.md`, the request, `work/requalify_input.jsonl`, the previous `analysis.md` and `report.md` (now in `work/rq/`)
|
||
- `labeling/labeling-rules.md`, `labeling/families.md` (in full), `tools/GUIDE.md` (`ranges.py`, reading order), `tools/DATA.md` (in full); `labeling/reading-rules.md`, `labeling/stations.md` read in full during the verification
|
||
- Tools: `ranges.py` (k 5, `--rolling 8`, `--instants 1`, windows of the weak thermal days), `inventory.py` (distances, mm per px), `validate.py`
|
||
- My scripts: `scripts/requalify.py`, `scripts/thermal_nights.py` (new), `scripts/scan.py`, `scripts/thermal_days.py` (verification)
|