Files
aimsight-labeling/auto/analyses/MICHIGAN_2026-10-12T1600_2026-10-23T2000/analysis.md
T
maximeandClaude Opus 5.5 ddb17c2189 auto: labels requalified under the 5-noise rules (only what stands out from the noise): 32 analyses refined, the 6 paused periods verified, the long labels requalified with the fixes the period analysts found; 1153 -> 961 labels
- 32 analyses: each label kept, rewritten or removed by its analyst (section Requalification of the report; mm magnitudes where the targets have them)
- SNCF01 x3, WILDSTRUBEL 2026-09-01 -> 2026-10-06 x3: verified from their existing labels under the new rules
- long labels (no analysis): auto/analyses/long-labels/<STATION>/; NORDEND-169 and -195 run to 07/11, so NORDEND-283 and -284 (their continuation) are removed
- reading-rules.md, stations.md: the citations of removed or rewritten labels point to their successor, or to [expert]

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
2026-11-17 23:58:00 +01:00

105 lines
16 KiB
Markdown
Raw Blame History

This file contains ambiguous Unicode characters
This file contains Unicode characters that might be confused with other characters. If you think that this is intentional, you can safely ignore this warning. Use the Escape button to reveal them.
# Labels: MICHIGAN, 2026-10-12T16:00Z → 2026-10-23T20:00Z (UTC)
Request (first pass): verify the 4 existing labels of the range (`work/existing.jsonl`). Second pass, 2026-11-17: requalification under the new rule of `labeling-rules.md` §1 (only what stands out from the noise, 5 noises), see section "Requalification" at the end. After it: 3 labels kept unchanged (MICHIGAN-6, -8, -9), 1 removed (MICHIGAN-16, the former MICHIGAN-5). `DETECTORS: no`.
## Verdict per old id
| Old id | Verdict | Evidence |
|---|---|---|
| MICHIGAN-5 | **corrected** (end 16T16 → 16T12, description) | The corr_x descent is real (median of the targets −0.17 at 15T16, all 14 targets below their level), but (1) the label says "the camera stops nodding forward and straightens a little": the tilt goes down on 13–14 Oct (0.0126 → 0.0097) then rises on 15–16 Oct to 0.0197 at 16T12, its highest of the range so far; the axis that follows the corr_x is the pan (r = −0.96 on 12T16–15T20), not the tilt; (2) it ends at 16T16 and says "then goes up again", while the return is MICHIGAN-7's (from 16T12): the trough is flat from 15T16 to 16T12 (−0.167, −0.157, gap, −0.132), the cut goes in the flat and the two phases touch (labeling-rules §2, §3). The expert sentences are kept. |
| MICHIGAN-6 | kept | No measurement 16T00, 16T04, 16T08 (inventory), no image between 15T20 and 16T12, no metric 15T23 → 16T10; BusVoltage 14.08–14.39 V and battery at 100 % just before and after. `stations.py`: the gap starts at 23:00 on the nine stations measuring then (BREITHORN, CLARIDEN, FLORIDA, JUNGFRAU, MICHIGAN, NEBRASKA, NIEDERHORN, NORDEND, SNCF01); LENZSPITZE starts at 02:10. Everything the label says that I could check holds. |
| MICHIGAN-8 | kept | 17T16 corr_x −0.089 (all targets below), 17T20 corr_y −0.160 (−3.9 noises, all 14 targets beyond 3 noises on the rolling level), 18T04 corr_x +0.118 and corr_y +0.131 (all 14 targets beyond 2 noises), back at 18T08 (corr_y +0.007; corr_x +0.085, in the band of the following days). Gap REF42−REFG43N: y −0.04 px at 17T20, x +0.05 px at 18T04; tilt 0.0228 then 0.0084, rotation swings. Temperature 31.25–32.5 °C without a brief drop at these hours. Thumbnails 17T12, 17T20, 18T04, 18T16: spots of the references and targets intact. NEBRASKA and BREITHORN do not move. |
| MICHIGAN-9 | kept | corr_y −0.201 at 19T04, −0.225 at 19T08 (−5.5 noises, the only day above 5 noises), corr_x −0.039 at 19T08, back at 19T12. Tilt 0.0278 then 0.0337 (max of the range), rotation −0.026, scale 0.99983 (min); gap REF42−REFG43N −0.07 then −0.05 px in y. Housing temperature: 31.0 at 19T04, 32.0 at 05:00, 29.5 from 07:00 to 09:00 (lowest of the range), 30.25 at 11–12:00: the first affected measurement precedes the drop, as the label says. The temperatures of NEBRASKA and BREITHORN drop already at 19T04. Thumbnails 19T04, 19T08: nothing in front. Confidence on the thermal cause medium: the same signature (nod forward, corr_y down) occurs at 17T20 without a drop (MICHIGAN-8). |
Spanning labels (not changed):
- **MICHIGAN-3** (REFPOU22 lost): holds within the range: REFPOU22 rejected at all 65 instants (error_value at its level near 0.99), the compensation on REF42 and REFG43N only (2 retained at every instant).
- **MICHIGAN-7**: wrong within the range on one point: it says "from 16 October … the camera nods forward again"; from 16T12 to 17T12 the tilt goes down (0.0197 → 0.0095, the camera straightens), it rises only from 17T16 (0.0172, then 0.020–0.034). The corr_x rise of 16T12 → 17T08 (−0.132 → +0.012) is the return of the descent of MICHIGAN-5 and follows the pan turning back (−0.0122 → −0.0169), not the tilt. The rest (step of corr_x on 17–18 Oct, slow descent of corr_y, faster tilt from the 17th with the housing temperature dropping) holds.
## 1. My labels
### 2026-10-15T20:00Z → 2026-10-16T12:00Z (MICHIGAN-6, kept)
- **Requalification**: kept unchanged: the station delivers nothing (no measurement of any sensor at 16T00, 16T04, 16T08, no metric), the No data rule of §1.
- **Phenomenon of the catalogue**: "A gap common to several stations".
- **Precedents**: none needed beyond the label itself.
- **Family**: No data: no measurement for any sensor.
- **Measured**: see the verdict table.
- **Images**: none in the gap (no file between 15T20 and 16T12).
- **Confidence**: high.
### 2026-10-17T12:00Z → 2026-10-18T08:00Z (MICHIGAN-8, kept)
- **Requalification**: kept unchanged. All 14 targets deviate together at 17T20 (corr_y) and 18T04 (corr_x, corr_y); at least one target passes 5 noises under a rolling level (COLH19N' corr_y −5.3, REFH22' −5.1, COLH21'' −5.0 at 17T20 with `--rolling 3`; COLH18' corr_y +5.3 at 18T04 with `--rolling 9`, `12`, `18`); `--rolling 6` gives at most −4.8 (COLH19N', 17T20), the fixed level of the whole range at most 4.7 (COLH18' corr_y, 18T04). Borderline, but passes in four of the five rolling readings and is all the targets at once: held.
- **Phenomenon of the catalogue**: "A compensation on two references" / "The base changes without a reference lost".
- **Precedents**: MICHIGAN-12 (same signature on 27 Oct, validated); JUNGFRAU-110, FLORIDA-72 (one-measurement common jumps through the base, Displacement).
- **Family**: Displacement: no temperature drop at these hours, no visible cause.
- **Measured**: see the verdict table; rolling level ±6 measurements, `ranges.py --instants`: 17T20 all 14 targets corr_y −4 to −5 noises; 18T04 all targets corr_x +2 to +3, corr_y +2 to +4.
- **Images**: thumbnails 17T12, 17T20, 18T04, 18T16; whole image 17T20: indoor scene, dark, all spots present.
- **Confidence**: high on the bounds; cause not established.
### 2026-10-19T00:00Z → 2026-10-19T12:00Z (MICHIGAN-9, kept)
- **Requalification**: kept unchanged. Beyond 5 noises in every reading: fixed level of the whole range, 8 targets in corr_y at 19T04–19T08 (POUH21'' −5.7, COLH20' −5.3, POUH18' −5.3, …); `--rolling 6`, 9 targets (POUH18' −5.8 at 19T08); `--rolling 12`, 4 targets (POUH18' −5.7 at 19T08). The corrected curves keep it: the thermal rule of §1 holds.
- **Phenomenon of the catalogue**: "The camera drifts away when the temperature of its housing drops, without a daily cycle".
- **Precedents**: MICHIGAN-2, -10, -11, -13 (validated, same signature with a brief drop of the housing temperature).
- **Family**: Thermal displacement, as the validated precedents of this station; see the reservation above.
- **Measured**: see the verdict table.
- **Images**: thumbnails 19T04, 19T08: nothing in front.
- **Confidence**: medium on the cause (the plunge starts before the drop recorded at the camera; the neighbours cool at 19T04), high on the bounds.
## 2. What I left without a label
### Removed by the requalification
- **MICHIGAN-16** (the former MICHIGAN-5 corrected in the first pass), 2026-10-12T16:00Z → 2026-10-16T12:00Z, Displacement: the common drift of corr_x (down every afternoon, lowest on 15–16 Oct) and the slight dip of corr_y on 15–16 Oct never reach 5 noises on any target. Largest deviations: over the label's own range (level and noise of the window) 3.8 noises in corr_x (REFH22', 15T16) and 4.6 in corr_y (COLH20'', 16T12); on the level of the whole range 4.9 (COLH18' corr_y, 16T12, the resumption after the gap) and at most 4.5 in corr_x (COLH20', 15T16); with a margin before (09T12 → 16T12) 3.9; under a rolling level (±3 to ±18 measurements) nothing above 4. It is part of the ordinary wobble of this station compensated on two references (below). Its first-pass reading is kept here for the record:
#### 2026-10-12T16:00Z → 2026-10-16T12:00Z (MICHIGAN-5, corrected)
- **Phenomenon of the catalogue**: "A compensation on two references" (family of what disturbs them), and "The camera tilts little by little" for the context of the month.
- **Precedents**: MICHIGAN-4, -7 (the neighbouring pieces of the same month, validated), MICHIGAN-12 (validated: "it is the two references that move slightly away from the targets, and the compensation on them alone carries this gap over"), which I followed to state the mechanism.
- **Family**: Displacement: a drift of several days that the housing temperature does not explain alone (r(corr_x, T) = −0.36 on 12T16–15T20), not Thermal displacement; consistent with MICHIGAN-4 and -7.
- **Measured**: median of the targets of corr_x minus their level (`scripts/table.py`, `work/table.txt`): 12T16 −0.001, 13T16 −0.139, 14T00 −0.030, 14T16 −0.129, 15T00 −0.033, 15T16 −0.167, 15T20 −0.157, 16T12 −0.132, 16T16 −0.071; lower at 12:00–20:00 every day, higher at 00:00. corr_y: +0.03 to +0.09 until 15T08, −0.073 at 15T12, −0.023, −0.035, −0.098 at 16T12, −0.011 at 16T16. Gap REF42−REFG43N in raw x: +0.03 px on 12–14 Oct, 0.00 from 15T08 (r(corr_x, gap x) = +0.85). Pose: pan −0.0174 → −0.0089 at 15T16 (r(corr_x, pan) = −0.96), tilt 0.0126 → 0.0097 (13T08) → 0.0176 (15T12) → 0.0197 (16T12). `overview.py --rigid` base 12T16: targets' residual median ≤ 0.015 px, max ≤ 0.037 px; residuals of the references ≤ 0.06 px. Housing temperature 31.75–34.5 °C, peaks in the afternoons (13T12 34.5, 14T16 34.0, 15T16 34.5). Days: corr_x never above 5 noises of the night level (−2.0 at most, `days.py --bounds`). Neighbours: the tilts of NEBRASKA (0.0275 → 0.0239) and BREITHORN (0.0200 → 0.0172) go down over 13–16 Oct; MICHIGAN's rises on 15–16.
- **Images**: thumbnails of REF42, REFG43N, COLH18S''', POUH19N', COLH21 at 12T16, 13T16, 14T00, 15T16, 15T20, 16T12, 16T16 (`--fixed`): spots intact, nothing in front.
- **Confidence**: high on the curves and the mechanism; the cause of the change of the gap between the two references is not established.
### Left without a label in the first pass
The corrected curves of all the targets are agitated together all through the range, through the compensation on two references (MICHIGAN-3): the raw positions are given to the hundredth of a pixel and a change of one or a few hundredths of the gap between REF42 and REFG43N becomes about a tenth of a pixel on all the targets (r(corr_y, gap y) = +0.8, r(corr_x, gap x) = +0.8 on each part of the range). Left without a label, because they stay under the threshold that the labelled moments pass (median of the targets under 3.5 noises of its level; `days.py`: never above 5 noises outside 19 Oct; `ranges.py --rolling 6 --k 3 --instants 6`: only 17T20, 19T04, 19T08 in the range):
- the **corr_x of all the targets higher at the 00:00 measurement** from 19 to 23 Oct (+0.12 to +0.15, the other hours +0.02 to +0.08), following the pan; the lowest points 20T04 (−0.043, all targets −2 to −4 noises against the rolling level, pan jumping to −0.0134), 21T08 (−0.033, −2 to −3 noises), 22T16, 23T20. 20T04 is the closest to a label: about as large as the 18T04 part of MICHIGAN-8, but alone in x, and as deep as 21T08 against the median level of these days (−2.2 and −2.0 noises): I treat both as the troughs of this agitation, not as events;
- **small dips of the corr_y of all the targets with a nod of the camera** (tilt up, rotation down), about half of those of MICHIGAN-8 and -9: 16T12 (−0.098, at the resumption), 17T04 (−0.082), 19T16 (−0.101), 21T00 (−0.083), 21T08 (−0.073), 23T08 to 23T20 (−0.094, −0.082, −0.047, −0.078, tilt 0.019 → 0.028 at 23T08 and staying there): the latter precede MICHIGAN-10 (24 Oct, outside the range), whose camera nod starts at 23T08 already;
- the daily wave of the corr_x on 13–15 Oct, described in MICHIGAN-5 (under 5 noises, no separate thermal label: labeling-rules §1).
## 3. The documentation
- `families.md` ("A compensation on two references") and `reading-rules.md` (§5: neighbouring cameras read together; at least three references) framed everything; `stations.md` (MICHIGAN: two references since 09.10, a measurement every four hours, indoors) too.
- What was missing: nothing tells how big a common deviation must be to be labelled on a station compensated on two references, where all the targets always move together; the "5 noises" rule exists only for the thermal cycle. I took the moments already validated as the threshold (about 4 noises of the median of the targets).
- What misled: the validated labels MICHIGAN-5 and -7 tell the camera's tilt from the narrative of the three cameras of the building ("stop and slight backward movement from 13 to 16, resumption from the 17th"); on MICHIGAN itself the tilt rises on 15–16 Oct and goes down on 16–17 Oct, and the corr_x follows the pan. A description of a camera axis is to be read on the station's own pose (labeling-rules §5, "checked axis by axis").
- The raw positions are rounded to the hundredth of a pixel: the gap between the two references moves by steps of that size, which `overview.py --rigid` shows only as residuals of a few hundredths; computing the gap REF42 − REFG43N directly (`scripts/table.py`) made the mechanism plain.
- No weather: `data/MICHIGAN/weather/` does not exist (station without a Swiss position, indoors).
## Requalification
2026-11-17, rule of `labeling-rules.md` §1: a movement is kept if at least one target deviates from its level by more than 5 of its own noises (`ranges.py --k 5`, `--rolling` under a drift); No data only when the station delivers nothing. Noises are the targets' own; the same in px and mm.
Commands (outputs in `work/`):
- `python3 tools/scripts/ranges.py data/MICHIGAN --columns corr_x,corr_y --k 5 --start 2026-10-12T16:00Z --end 2026-10-23T20:00Z` → `work/requal_ranges_k5.txt`: only 19T04–19T08 in corr_y (8 targets, up to −5.7, POUH21'') and one point of COLH18' corr_x at 21T00 (+5.3, inside the 00:00 corr_x wobble of 19–23 Oct described in section 2: not a label under review, no new event sought).
- the same with `--rolling 6` and `--rolling 12` → `work/requal_ranges_rolling.txt`: rolling 6, only 19T04/19T08 (9 targets, POUH18' −5.8); rolling 12, 18T04 (COLH18' corr_y +5.3) and 19T08 (4 targets).
- the same at `--k 3` on each label's window, on the whole range (fixed, rolling 12) and with a margin before (09T12 → 16T12) → `work/requal_ranges_labels.txt`, `work/requal_ranges_k3.txt` (the windows of MICHIGAN-8 and -9 hold only 5 and 4 measurements: their own noise is inflated by the event, so their deviations are read on the whole range).
- sweep `--k 4 --rolling 3,6,9,12,18` → `work/requal_rolling_sweep.txt`.
| id | bounds | family | max deviation | verdict |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| MICHIGAN-16 | 12T16 → 16T12 | Displacement | 4.9 (COLH18' corr_y 16T12, whole-range level); 3.8 x / 4.6 y on its own window; ≤ 4 rolling | removed |
| MICHIGAN-6 | 15T20 → 16T12 | No data | no measurement of any sensor | kept |
| MICHIGAN-8 | 17T12 → 18T08 | Displacement | 5.3 (COLH19N' corr_y 17T20, rolling 3; COLH18' corr_y 18T04, rolling 9–18); 4.8 rolling 6; 4.7 fixed | kept (borderline) |
| MICHIGAN-9 | 19T00 → 19T12 | Thermal displacement | 5.7–5.8 (POUH21'', POUH18' corr_y 19T08), every reading | kept |
Kept 3, rewritten 0, removed 1. `validate.py`: 0 errors.
## Difficulties
- `plot.py --zone` takes one range per flag (`--zone A/B --zone C/D`), not several after one flag.
## Sources read
- requalification: `instructions/analyst.md`, `labeling/labeling-rules.md` (§1–3), `tools/GUIDE.md` (ranges), `work/requalify_input.jsonl`, `tools/scripts/ranges.py`, `tools/scripts/inventory.py` (distances, mm/px)
- `agents/agents/analyst.md`, `instructions/analyst.md`, `work/prompt.txt`, `work/existing.jsonl`, `work/spanning.jsonl`
- `tools/GUIDE.md`, `tools/DATA.md`, `labeling/families.md`, `labeling/labeling-rules.md`, `labeling/reading-rules.md`, `labeling/stations.md`
- `labeling/auto/MICHIGAN.jsonl` (MICHIGAN-2, -4, -10, -11, -12, -13 for the edges and the precedents)
- precedents: `precedents.py` (JUNGFRAU-110, -112, FLORIDA-72, NORDEND-80, WYOMING-17, NEBRASKA-10, MICHIGAN-2, -11, -13, -15)
- tools: `inventory.py`, `overview.py --rigid` (`work/overview.txt`), `metrics.py` (`work/metrics.txt`), `ranges.py --rolling` (`work/ranges_rolling.txt`), `days.py --bounds` (`work/days.txt`), `stations.py` (all stations at the gap; MICHIGAN, NEBRASKA, BREITHORN over the range), `thumbnails.py`, `plot.py`; whole image 2026-10-17T20:00Z
- my script `scripts/table.py` (per instant: medians of the targets, gap REF42 − REFG43N, pose, hourly temperature; `work/table.txt`)