- 32 analyses: each label kept, rewritten or removed by its analyst (section Requalification of the report; mm magnitudes where the targets have them) - SNCF01 x3, WILDSTRUBEL 2026-09-01 -> 2026-10-06 x3: verified from their existing labels under the new rules - long labels (no analysis): auto/analyses/long-labels/<STATION>/; NORDEND-169 and -195 run to 07/11, so NORDEND-283 and -284 (their continuation) are removed - reading-rules.md, stations.md: the citations of removed or rewritten labels point to their successor, or to [expert] Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
115 lines
17 KiB
Markdown
115 lines
17 KiB
Markdown
# Labels: NIEDERHORN, 2026-10-11T05:00Z → 2026-10-21T12:00Z (UTC)
|
||
|
||
Request (2026-11-17): requalify the 45 labels of this analysis (`work/requalify_input.jsonl`, identical to the previous `labels.jsonl`) under the new rules (`labeling-rules.md` section 1, `families.md` "What is not labeled"): only what stands out from the noise of the corrected curves is labelled. Not a new reading: each label is measured with `ranges.py` at `--k 5` and kept, rewritten or removed. DETECTORS: no.
|
||
|
||
Station context (unchanged from the verification of this range): railway tracks seen from below a road, references PWD_REF08 to PWD_REF12 on the road, floodlight at night, hourly cadence (232 instants). No `weather/` folder for NIEDERHORN (station without a Swiss position): no MeteoSwiss weather. Image quality columns empty: no `quality.py`. Distances (`inventory.py`): the PWD targets from 11.7 m (PWD_RMP_B12_017_C09, 4.2 mm/px) to 29.7 m (PWD_RMP_B17_026_C09, 10.5 mm/px); the e targets have no distance, so no mm.
|
||
|
||
Result: **39 labels: 37 kept as they are, 2 rewritten, 6 removed.**
|
||
|
||
## 1. My labels
|
||
|
||
The labels are those of the verification (see its reasoning in the previous version of this file, `git log` of the labeling repository); only their measurement under the new threshold is added here. Deviations: the largest |deviation| of a target, in its own noise, at `--rolling 3` for a short event (a passage, the sun, the plant), from the night level for a thermal cycle, across the step for a lasting jump. The references and PWD_IMP_B07_016_C09 (the plant) are left out of the thermal test.
|
||
|
||
| Id | Bounds (UTC) | Family | Verdict | Deviation that holds it (noises) |
|
||
|---|---|---|---|---|
|
||
| NIEDERHORN-163 | 11T05 → 11T07 | No data | kept | no measurement at all at 06:00 |
|
||
| NIEDERHORN-54 | 11T15 → 11T18 | Thermal displacement | kept | PWD_IMP_B07_018_C09 corr_x −8.1 at 16:00 from the night level, 2 of 3 measurements beyond 5 |
|
||
| NIEDERHORN-164 | 11T21 → 12T06 | Visibility | kept | PWD_RMP_B15_020_C09 corr_x −20.9 at 12T01, e10 −18.2, PWD_IMP_B08_025_C09 −17.1 (26 target-columns beyond 5); the description already states these drops |
|
||
| NIEDERHORN-56 | 12T03 → 12T05 | Obstruction | kept | PWD_RMP_B12_018_C09 corr_y +16.3, PWD_RMP_B12_017_C09 +13.9, PWD_RMP_B12_019_C09 corr_x −12.3 at 12T04 |
|
||
| NIEDERHORN-57 | 12T15 → 13T00 | Thermal displacement | kept | PWD_IMP_B07_018_C09 corr_x −12.1, PWD_RMP_B12_018_C09 −11.8 from the night level (18 target-columns beyond 5 on ≥ 2 measurements) |
|
||
| NIEDERHORN-58 | 12T16 → 12T19 | Obstruction | kept | PWD_IMP_B07_016_C09 corr_y +5.2 at 12T18 (rolling ±3; +5.8 against the batch level): just over the threshold |
|
||
| NIEDERHORN-60 | 13T07 → 13T20 | Obstruction | kept | PWD_IMP_B07_016_C09 corr_x +14.6 at 13T12, +12.9 at 10:00, corr_y +10.3 at 19:00 |
|
||
| NIEDERHORN-61 | 13T08 → 13T15 | Visibility | **rewritten** | PWD_RMP_B15_020_C09 corr_x −14.7 at 10:00, PWD_IMP_B08_025_C09 −14.6, PWD_RMP_B16_026_C09 −13.4 at 12:00, e15 −19.2, e14 −8.3, PWD_RMP_B12_017_C09 +11.6 at 12:00, e06 −9.9 at 14:00 |
|
||
| NIEDERHORN-62 | 13T12 → 13T14 | Obstruction | kept | PWD_RMP_B12_019_C09 corr_y +23.4, PWD_RMP_B12_020_C09 +18.2, e13 corr_x −8.8 at 13T13 |
|
||
| NIEDERHORN-165 | 13T13 → 14T06 | Thermal displacement | kept | PWD_RMP_B12_019_C09 corr_x +17.6, PWD_RMP_B16_026_C09 +17.1, PWD_RMP_B15_020_C09 +15.3, all 9 measurements beyond 5 (30 target-columns) |
|
||
| NIEDERHORN-66 | 13T22 → 14T00 | Obstruction | kept | PWD_RMP_B12_019_C09 corr_y +35.0, PWD_RMP_B12_020_C09 +29.1, PWD_RMP_B12_018_C09 +17.6, e14 +14.5 at 13T23 |
|
||
| NIEDERHORN-67 | 14T07 → 15T02 | Obstruction | kept | PWD_IMP_B07_016_C09 corr_y +11.3 at 14T18, −6.6 at 14T13 |
|
||
| NIEDERHORN-68 | 14T11 → 14T14 | Visibility | kept | e10 corr_x −19.7, PWD_RMP_B12_018_C09 +12.9, PWD_IMP_B08_025_C09 corr_y +12.3 at 14T12 |
|
||
| NIEDERHORN-69 | 14T13 → 14T23 | Thermal displacement | kept | PWD_IMP_B07_018_C09 corr_x −9.4 from the night level, 8 of 9 measurements beyond 5; PWD_IMP_B08_024_C09 −9.0 |
|
||
| NIEDERHORN-166 | 15T01 → 15T03 | Obstruction | kept | e09 corr_x +8.0, corr_y −5.3, PWD_RMP_B16_026_C09 corr_x +5.3 at 15T02 |
|
||
| NIEDERHORN-167 | 15T01 → 15T04 | Displacement | kept | PWD_RMP_B16_026_C09 corr_y from about 1.41 px (four measurements before) to 1.66-1.71 px from 02:00 until the gap: about ten noises (batch noise 0.027 px), lasting |
|
||
| NIEDERHORN-71 | 15T13 → 15T22 | Thermal displacement | kept | PWD_RMP_B15_018_C09 corr_y +9.7 at 17:00, PWD_IMP_B07_018_C09 corr_x −6.4, 4 of 9 measurements beyond 5 |
|
||
| NIEDERHORN-72 | 15T22 → 16T11 | No data | kept | no measurement at all for twelve steps |
|
||
| NIEDERHORN-168 | 15T22 → 16T12 | Displacement | kept | e10 corr_x jump −48.8 noises across the gap, e09 −33.3, e13 −22.2, PWD_RMP_B16_026_C09 −25.4, and it stays |
|
||
| NIEDERHORN-169 | 16T11 → 16T18 | Visibility | **rewritten** | PWD_IMP_B08_025_C09 corr_x −34.9 at 11-12:00, PWD_RMP_B15_020_C09 −16.8, PWD_IMP_B08_024_C09 −14.8, PWD_RMP_B17_026_C09 −11.8 then −13.2 at 13:00, e14 −10.6, PWD_RMP_B15_019_C09 corr_y +16.4 at 13:00, PWD_RMP_B16_026_C09 corr_x −14.5 at 14:00, e10 −18.8 at 16:00 |
|
||
| NIEDERHORN-170 | 16T11 → 17T12 | Thermal displacement | kept | against the calm night of 14-15.10 (no night before the label, the gap): PWD_IMP_B08_025_C09 corr_x −11.8 at 17T11 (5 of 18 measurements beyond 5), PWD_RMP_B12_018_C09 corr_y +8.8, corr_x +7.6, PWD_RMP_B12_020_C09 corr_x +7.2; against the night of 17-18.10, PWD_IMP_B08_025_C09 −7.6. Left-edge targets left out (their step) |
|
||
| NIEDERHORN-76 | 16T14 → 17T01 | Obstruction | kept | PWD_IMP_B07_016_C09 corr_x +5.8 at 16T21, +5.7 at 20:00, +5.6 at 16:00 (rolling ±3; +6.8 against the batch level) |
|
||
| NIEDERHORN-77 | 16T16 → 16T18 | Obstruction | kept | PWD_RMP_B17_026_C09 corr_y −11.3, PWD_RMP_B16_026_C09 +9.5 at 16T17 |
|
||
| NIEDERHORN-78 | 16T18 → 16T20 | Obstruction | kept | PWD_RMP_B17_026_C09 corr_y +10.0, PWD_RMP_B16_026_C09 +5.9 at 16T19 |
|
||
| NIEDERHORN-171 | 17T12 → 17T16 | Visibility | kept | PWD_IMP_B08_025_C09 corr_x +8.6, PWD_IMP_B07_017_C09 +7.2, PWD_RMP_B12_017_C09 +6.5 at 17T14 |
|
||
| NIEDERHORN-82 | 17T12 → 18T00 | Thermal displacement | kept | PWD_RMP_B12_018_C09 corr_x −21.3 from the night level, 8 of 8 measurements beyond 5 (26 target-columns) |
|
||
| NIEDERHORN-172 | 18T12 → 18T15 | Visibility | kept | PWD_IMP_B07_017_C09 corr_x −8.0, e13 +7.4 at 18T13, PWD_RMP_B15_018_C09 +6.9 at 14:00 |
|
||
| NIEDERHORN-85 | 18T12 → 19T00 | Thermal displacement | kept | PWD_RMP_B12_018_C09 corr_x −21.5, PWD_RMP_B12_020_C09 −15.4, 9 of 9 measurements beyond 5 |
|
||
| NIEDERHORN-87 | 19T05 → 19T22 | Obstruction | kept | PWD_IMP_B07_016_C09 corr_y +10.7 at 19T20, +9.3 at 19T06 |
|
||
| NIEDERHORN-88 | 19T09 → 19T11 | No data | kept | no measurement at all at 10:00 |
|
||
| NIEDERHORN-173 | 19T11 → 19T15 | Visibility | kept | e13 corr_x −11.8, e06 −11.7, e15 −11.2, PWD_RMP_B17_026_C09 −9.9 at 19T12 |
|
||
| NIEDERHORN-90 | 19T11 → 20T00 | Thermal displacement | kept | PWD_RMP_B12_018_C09 corr_x −22.0, PWD_IMP_B07_018_C09 −20.1 from the night level (26 target-columns) |
|
||
| NIEDERHORN-91 | 19T20 → 19T22 | No data | kept | no measurement at all at 21:00 |
|
||
| NIEDERHORN-92 | 20T05 → 20T13 | Obstruction | kept | PWD_IMP_B07_016_C09 corr_y −13.0 at 20T09, −11.7 at 07:00, corr_x −10.1 |
|
||
| NIEDERHORN-93 | 20T11 → 20T13 | Obstruction | kept | PWD_RMP_B15_020_C09 corr_y +46.2, PWD_RMP_B12_019_C09 +33.5, PWD_RMP_B12_020_C09 +28.7 at 20T12 |
|
||
| NIEDERHORN-174 | 20T12 → 20T15 | Visibility | kept | PWD_IMP_B08_025_C09 corr_x −6.2 at 14:00 (−8.8 at rolling ±6), PWD_RMP_B15_019_C09 −6.1 at 13:00 |
|
||
| NIEDERHORN-95 | 20T12 → 20T23 | Thermal displacement | kept | PWD_IMP_B08_024_C09 corr_x −17.8, PWD_IMP_B07_018_C09 −15.9, e06 +15.8 from the night level (29 target-columns) |
|
||
| NIEDERHORN-96 | 20T16 → 20T18 | Obstruction | kept | PWD_RMP_B17_026_C09 corr_y +6.3 at 20T17 with its recognition error up at that measurement (a spike, not the thermal ramp): just over the threshold |
|
||
| NIEDERHORN-97 | 20T20 → 20T22 | No data | kept | no measurement at all at 21:00 |
|
||
|
||
### NIEDERHORN-61, rewritten: 2026-10-13T08:00Z → 2026-10-13T15:00Z
|
||
- **Phenomenon of the catalogue**: Rain / visibility drops over the whole scene, without an obstacle (unchanged).
|
||
- **Precedents**: none new; the label was validated (review 2026-11-17) on the same reading.
|
||
- **Family**: Visibility, unchanged: the whole group of targets degrades together, the references hold.
|
||
- **Measured**: the description listed the rejections and "the others fluctuate"; under the new rule the label holds by what the episode does to the curves still measured, so the description now states it (values in the table). The 13:00 train (62) and the plant (60) are named as labelled apart. Bounds, family and cause unchanged; it loses its review field.
|
||
- **Images**: none new (the 11:00 thumbnails of the verification).
|
||
- **Confidence**: high on the effect, medium on the cause (rain or mist not distinguished).
|
||
|
||
### NIEDERHORN-169, rewritten: 2026-10-16T11:00Z → 2026-10-16T18:00Z
|
||
- **Phenomenon of the catalogue**: Rain / visibility drops over the whole scene (unchanged).
|
||
- **Precedents**: NIEDERHORN-61, -164, same station, same family.
|
||
- **Family**: Visibility, unchanged.
|
||
- **Measured**: the description rested on the rejections at the resumption; it now states the drops of PWD_IMP_B08_025_C09, PWD_RMP_B15_020_C09, PWD_RMP_B17_026_C09, PWD_IMP_B08_024_C09 and e14 at 11:00-12:00 (back at 14:00, read on the values: PWD_IMP_B08_025_C09 corr_x −0.44, −0.01, +0.04 then +0.28 px), PWD_RMP_B15_019_C09 corr_y at 13:00, and the unsettled PWD_RMP_B16_026_C09 and e10 until the afternoon (e10 −18.8 at 16:00). The left-edge targets at 11-13:00 are not named for their deviation there: the rolling level mixes values from before the step (168). Bounds and cause unchanged. No review field before.
|
||
- **Confidence**: high on the effect, low on the cause.
|
||
|
||
## 2. What I left without a label
|
||
|
||
**Removed by the requalification** (6):
|
||
|
||
- **NIEDERHORN-59**, 2026-10-13T04:00Z → 06:00Z, Obstruction (lit vehicle, PWD_IMP_B07_017_C09, PWD_RMP_B12_018_C09, PWD_RMP_B15_018_C09 rejected for one measurement): **missing points only**. At rolling ±3, no target beyond 5 noises at 05:00 (largest under 5; the static +7.6 of PWD_RMP_B16_026_C09 and the ±12 +7.9 of PWD_IMP_B08_025_C09 are the level of the day, the 05:00 values lie between their neighbours: B16_026 corr_x 0.374, 0.410, 0.422 px at 04, 05, 06:00).
|
||
- **NIEDERHORN-64**, 2026-10-13T16:00Z → 18:00Z, Obstruction (passenger train, e02, e06, e09, PWD_RMP_B17_026_C09 rejected): **missing points only**. The only rolling deviation, PWD_IMP_B07_017_C09 corr_x −7.2 at 17:00, is the trough of the thermal cycle (NIEDERHORN-165), not a spike: its values −0.249, −0.202, −0.039 px at 16, 17, 18:00 put 17:00 between its neighbours, the same smooth trough as PWD_RMP_B12_018_C09 (−0.585, −0.485, −0.403).
|
||
- **NIEDERHORN-65**, 2026-10-13T19:00Z → 21:00Z, Obstruction (e02 rejected alone, the underside of a wagon): **missing point only**. At 20:00, e15 (+6.6), PWD_RMP_B17_026_C09 (+6.0) and e09 (+5.4) jump together on corr_x without their recognition error rising (0.06, 0.04, 0.17 as before), while the references PWD_REF09_C09 and PWD_REF11_C09 move apart on corr_x (about −5 and +4 noises): a hesitation of the compensation in the evening thermal return, already under NIEDERHORN-165; a wagon over e02 at the bottom of the image cannot move the left-edge targets and the references on the road.
|
||
- **NIEDERHORN-80**, 2026-10-17T04:00Z → 18:00Z, Obstruction (plant in front of PWD_IMP_B07_016_C09): **under the threshold**. Largest rolling ±3 deviation of PWD_IMP_B07_016_C09: corr_y +4.1 at 17:00, corr_x −3.7 at 09:00, −3.6 at 12:00 (with `--k 3`); its two rejections (05:00, 14:00) are missing points. The deviations above 5 against the batch level (corr_x +6.1 at 09:00, corr_y +7.0 at 17:00) are the cold-night drift (170) and the thermal cycle (82), which every target shares that morning.
|
||
- **NIEDERHORN-83**, 2026-10-18T06:00Z → 10:00Z, Obstruction (tip of a leaf on PWD_IMP_B07_016_C09, no rejection): **under the threshold**. Largest rolling ±3 deviation: corr_x +4.1 at 09:00, +3.8 at 07:00, corr_y −3.2 at 09:00; against the night level (about −0.23 px at 00-05:00) the 09:00 value +0.089 px is about 4.3 noises.
|
||
- **NIEDERHORN-86**, 2026-10-18T20:00Z → 22:00Z, Obstruction (PWD_IMP_B07_016_C09 rejected alone): **missing point only**. No target beyond 5 noises at rolling ±3 at 21:00; PWD_RMP_B17_026_C09 corr_x 0.265, 0.371, 0.300 px at 20, 21, 22:00 is about 4 noises over its neighbours (+6.5 only at rolling ±6, within the thermal return of 85).
|
||
|
||
**Still under a label but noted**: NIEDERHORN-58 (+5.2) and NIEDERHORN-96 (+6.3) are just over the threshold: kept, since one target exceeds 5 noises; a stricter reading would remove them. In 96, e15 rises over 16-18:00 as a ramp (0.336, 0.460, 0.577 px), not the one-measurement jump the description says; left as is (the label holds, its bounds and text are not touched).
|
||
|
||
The rest of section 2 of the verification stands (PWD_IMP_B08_024_C09 at 14T03 covered by its Target issue; the night relaxation of the pan; REF11 error at 20T16 and REF09 at 17T12, 18T12 without effect on the curves).
|
||
|
||
## 3. The documentation
|
||
|
||
- `labeling-rules.md` section 1 and `families.md` "What is not labeled" gave the rule directly; the request's instruction "`ranges.py` at --k 5, with --rolling under a drift or a thermal cycle" was the key to the plant labels: against the batch level, PWD_IMP_B07_016_C09 crosses 5 noises in 80 and 83 because of the cold-night drift and the thermal cycle, not of the plant.
|
||
- Missing in the rule: which level for a thermal label right after a gap (170 has no night before it). I took the nearest calm nights on each side (14-15.10 and 17-18.10), which both give more than 5 noises.
|
||
- Missing: a rule for a passage that falls on the steep part of a thermal ramp (64): the rolling median then gives several noises without any spike. Reading the values at the measurement before and after settles it; worth a line in `reading-rules.md`.
|
||
- The validator reports 5 overlaps between Obstruction labels (the plant labels and the trains of the same hours): they are two events on different targets, kept as before.
|
||
- 167 still refers to the step during the gap as "NIEDERHORN#73", its old id (now NIEDERHORN-168); not changed, since a label that holds is kept exactly.
|
||
|
||
## Requalification
|
||
|
||
Commands (from the repository root; outputs in `work/requal/`):
|
||
|
||
```
|
||
python3 tools/scripts/ranges.py data/NIEDERHORN --columns corr_x,corr_y --start 2026-10-10T17:00Z --end 2026-10-21T12:00Z [--rolling 3|6|12] > work/requal/ranges_{static,r3,r6,r12}.txt
|
||
python3 scripts/requalify.py <folder> # per label, the targets whose k5 extreme falls inside it, each mode -> work/requal/requalify.txt
|
||
python3 tools/scripts/ranges.py ... --rolling 3 --k 3 --sensors PWD_IMP_B07_016_C09 # the plant labels under the threshold
|
||
python3 scripts/thermal_night.py <folder> 6 # thermal labels against the level of the 6 h before their start -> work/requal/thermal_night.txt
|
||
python3 scripts/values.py T1 T2 SENSORS # values around 13T05, 13T17, 13T20, 15T02, 16T11-19, 17-18.10, 18T21, 20T17
|
||
python3 scripts/write_labels.py <folder> # labels.jsonl
|
||
python3 labeling/scripts/validate.py <folder>/labels.jsonl # 39 labels, 0 errors, 5 overlaps to look at
|
||
```
|
||
|
||
Values: see the tables of sections 1 and 2. Noises (batch, own noise of `ranges.py`, px): PWD_IMP_B07_016_C09 corr_x 0.074, corr_y 0.12; PWD_RMP_B16_026_C09 corr_y 0.027; e09 corr_x 0.023; PWD_IMP_B08_025_C09 corr_x 0.021; PWD_RMP_B12_018_C09 corr_x 0.027; PWD_RMP_B17_026_C09 corr_x 0.025, corr_y 0.023.
|
||
|
||
## Difficulties
|
||
- My first parser of the `ranges.py` output missed the short sensor names (e01-e15), whose name is followed by spaces; fixed before any decision.
|
||
- The thermal test first skipped the instants under the long plant labels, which emptied 69 and 170; the plant labels touch one target, so that target was left out instead.
|
||
|
||
## Sources read
|
||
`instructions/analyst.md`, the request, `labeling/labeling-rules.md` (in full), `labeling/families.md` (sections "A gap", "Target issue", "What is not labeled", and the families table), `tools/GUIDE.md` (ranges, days), `work/requalify_input.jsonl`, the previous `analysis.md` and `report.md` of this folder, `work/inventory.txt` and `inventory.py` (distances, mm/px), `data/NIEDERHORN/` through `tools/scripts/data.py`. Tools: `ranges.py` (static, `--rolling 3/6/12`, `--k 3`, `--outside`), `inventory.py`; my scripts `scripts/requalify.py`, `scripts/thermal_night.py`, `scripts/write_labels.py`, `scripts/values.py` (from the verification).
|