Files
aimsight-labeling/auto/analyses/SNCF01_2026-10-22T1030_2026-11-01T0000/analysis.md
T
maximeandClaude Opus 5.5 ddb17c2189 auto: labels requalified under the 5-noise rules (only what stands out from the noise): 32 analyses refined, the 6 paused periods verified, the long labels requalified with the fixes the period analysts found; 1153 -> 961 labels
- 32 analyses: each label kept, rewritten or removed by its analyst (section Requalification of the report; mm magnitudes where the targets have them)
- SNCF01 x3, WILDSTRUBEL 2026-09-01 -> 2026-10-06 x3: verified from their existing labels under the new rules
- long labels (no analysis): auto/analyses/long-labels/<STATION>/; NORDEND-169 and -195 run to 07/11, so NORDEND-283 and -284 (their continuation) are removed
- reading-rules.md, stations.md: the citations of removed or rewritten labels point to their successor, or to [expert]

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
2026-11-17 23:58:00 +01:00

147 lines
17 KiB
Markdown
Raw Blame History

This file contains ambiguous Unicode characters
This file contains Unicode characters that might be confused with other characters. If you think that this is intentional, you can safely ignore this warning. Use the Escape button to reveal them.
# Labels: SNCF01, 2026-10-22T10:30Z → 2026-11-01T00:00Z (UTC)
Task: verify the 28 existing labels of the range (`work/existing.jsonl`) under the rules of 2026-11-17 (5 own noises on `corr_x`/`corr_y`; thermal only when the corrected curves keep it; a missing point not for itself; No data only when nothing is delivered). Result: 26 labels in `labels.jsonl` — **13 kept** unchanged, **12 corrected**, **3 removed**, **1 added**.
Context: no `weather/` folder for SNCF01 (no MeteoSwiss weather: a station without a Swiss position); the system metrics (`BusVoltage`, `BusCurrent`, `Power`, `ShuntVoltage`) are all empty over the window and there is no `sensor_*_deg_c`: no temperature. No image quality metrics (older camera). Images on the hour (plus a few at the measurement minute), none during the outages. Cadence 15 min. 27 sensors, 3 references (BG.3.1, R1, R2), targets 16 to 21 m from the camera, about 6 to 8.5 mm per px (CV.1: no factor, px only). The sun is read on the noon images: 22/10 and 26/10 overcast, 25/10 sunny morning with clouds, 28, 29, 30, 31/10 full sun (`noon_images.png`).
Noise reference (median step between consecutive measurements over the window, `overview.py`): P4–P7 0.005–0.009 px (≈0.04–0.06 mm), P1–P3 0.009–0.014 px, BG.2/BG.3/F4.5/F4.6 ≈0.012 px, CV.2/CV.4 ≈0.03 px, CV.9 0.07–0.08 px.
## Verdict per old id
| Old id | Verdict | Evidence |
|---|---|---|
| SNCF01-70 | kept | 22/10 10:30–13:30: 5+1+3 missing steps separated by single measurements (12:00, 12:30): one No data. Metrics empty, no image in the gaps. |
| SNCF01-71 | corrected (description) | Curves flat within the day but P5.x ≈+10, P7.x +8…+12, P6.y +8…+10 noises above the 21/10 evening level (P5.x −1, P7.x −2): the corrected curves keep the cycle; the old text said the compensation absorbs it (would mean removal). P7.x back from +9 to +2 at the isolated 15:30 measurement with the pan step. Overcast on the images. |
| SNCF01-72 | removed | Turbulence on 22/10 not seen: one exceedance over the 11 measurements (P7.x −5.6 noises at 15:30, the thermal return); `error_value` steps ≤0.013 (vs 0.03–0.07 on sunny days); overcast images. |
| SNCF01-73 | kept | 15:15 missing, 15:30 single measurement, then 259 steps missing to 25/10 08:30: one No data. |
| SNCF01-74 | corrected (end 15:00→13:15, description) | Exceedances 08:30 (CV.4 +5.1, F4.2 −5.9) to 13:00 (CV.1 −5.7, P6.y −5.3, P7.y −6.1); after 13:00 only F4.3 (Target issue SNCF01-5). Sun 09:00–13:00, overcast 12:00 and 14:00. Named targets fixed (CV.4, F4.2, F4.6, CV.9, P1; the old list named BG.3, CV.6, not moving that day). |
| SNCF01-75 | kept | P5.y, P6.y +10…+13 noises by day vs ≈0 the following night; back ≈21:00; pan plateau ≈22:00–22:30. Bounds hold. |
| SNCF01-76 | corrected (description) | 25/10 23:45: P7.x jumps +0.048 px (≈7.5 noises, ≈0.3 mm) with its `error_value` 0.253→0.319, P5's too; BG.3.1 at 0.685 (threshold 0.7), R1 0.396. The old text said "the other targets do not move": P7 does, its point is wrong. |
| SNCF01-77 | corrected (description) | 26/10 day: P7.x up to +11 noises at 10:00 (tilt drop), P5.x +5…+7 vs night −1…0: holds. Old text (copied) said the curves come back at nightfall: they do not (evening episode, outage at 22:00). Overcast day, smaller pose cycle. |
| SNCF01-78 | kept | 14:45, 15:00 missing; common gap (other stations) as stated; I did not recheck the other stations. |
| SNCF01-79 | corrected (start 14:30→15:15, description) | Event at the resumption after the 15:00 gap: P6.y +5→+8 at 15:15, P5.x +7→+11 at 15:30, then P5.x/P6.x to +19…+22, P6.y +14, P4.y −10, P1.x −8, P1.y −7, P3.y −7 noises by 19:00–22:00 (≈0.15 px ≈1 mm on P5). `error_value` of R2, BG.3.1, P1, P3, CV.1, F4.2 above 5 MAD from 17:15; `sigma0` max of the range at 17:00. Images 16:00–21:00: nothing clear (18:00 vs 25/10 18:00). Back at level on 28/10. Gap rule: an event starting at the resumption starts at that measurement. |
| SNCF01-80 | kept | 63 + 68 missing steps around the lone 27/10 14:00 measurement: one No data. |
| SNCF01-81 | corrected (07:15–16:15 → 08:00–14:45, description) | Exceedances 08:15 (CV.4 −6.2, CV.9.y −5.1, P2.y −5.4) to 14:30 (CV.4.y +5.9); nothing beyond 5 after. 07:15–07:45 the pose is still at its night level. |
| SNCF01-82 | kept | P5.y/P6.y up to +20, P7.x +16 noises; back ≈21:30; pan plateau 22:30; start 07:30 vs pan leaving at 07:45: one step. |
| SNCF01-83 | kept | CV.2 at 10:30: −9.5 px in x, +12.6 px in y (≈−59 / +78 mm), back at 10:45; CV.4 rejected. |
| SNCF01-84 | kept | 21:15: BG.3.1, R1 rejected, no pose; BG.3.y −72, BG.2.y −49, F4.5.y −45, R2 −33 noises (BG.3 ≈−0.86 px ≈−5 mm). |
| SNCF01-85 | kept | 22:45: same signature, BG.3.y −70, F4.5.y −48, BG.2.y −47 noises. |
| SNCF01-86 | corrected (08:00–16:00 → 10:45–15:30, description) | Exceedances 11:00 (CV.9.y +5.0) to 15:15 (CV.4.x −5.6); before 11:00 nothing beyond 5 (CV.4 rejected at 08:30 only: a missing point). |
| SNCF01-87 | corrected (start 08:30→07:45, description) | Pan 14.21 m° at 07:45 → 12.11 at 08:00, tilt leaving at 07:30–08:00: the morning turning point is 07:45, three steps before the old start. Text had "the evening and the evening". P5.y/P6.y +16…+19 noises. |
| SNCF01-88 | kept | 15:00 missing, image present, common gap as stated. |
| SNCF01-89 | kept | P5.y +21, P6.y +20, P7.x +13 noises; return slow, curves back ≈00:30–01:00, pan rising all night to 06:00: without rest, ends at the next start (31/10 07:45). Start 08:00 vs turning point 07:45: one step. |
| SNCF01-90 | corrected (08:30–19:00 → 09:15–15:30, description) | Exceedances 09:30 (CV.2.y −6.8) to 15:15 (F4.2.y +5.2); hourly `error_value` steps back to night values from 16:00; the old end ran into the evening trains (labelled apart). |
| SNCF01-91 | kept | 18:00: P3/P4 −48/−56 noises, BG.3 −64; 18:15 clean (targets within 3 noises): two labels. |
| SNCF01-92 | kept | 18:30: P1 −55, P2 −66, P3 −61 noises in y. |
| SNCF01-93 | corrected (description) | 21:30: P3.x −10, P1.x −6, BG.3.x −5 noises, pan jump, BG.3.1 `error_value` 0.622; the old text named P1, P2, BG.2 in x and y. 21:45: F4.2 rejected alone (same event). |
| SNCF01-94 | removed | F4.2 rejected at 21:45 alone: a missing point; no curve beyond 5 noises at 21:45 (all targets within 2 noises). Already inside SNCF01-93. |
| SNCF01-95 | removed | F4.2 rejected at 31/10 07:15 alone: a missing point; at 07:15 no target beyond 5 noises. |
| SNCF01-96 | corrected (07:45–15:45 → 08:15–16:00, description) | Exceedances 08:30 (BG.3.y −6.7) to 15:45 (BG.2.x −5.1); P2 (up to 11 noises), CV.4, CV.2, P1 move most: the old list omitted P2 and P1. |
| SNCF01-97 | corrected (description) | Holds as a thermal day, but the curves do not come back: P6.y +15, P5.y +11…12 noises at 23:30 vs ≈0 on the previous nights, partly the tilt step of 12:30 (added label). The old text said they come back. |
## 1. My labels
Only the corrected and added labels are detailed here; the kept ones carry their old text and the evidence of the table above.
### 2026-10-22T10:30Z → 2026-10-22T15:30Z (SNCF01-71, corrected)
- **Phenomenon of the catalogue**: The camera moves through a thermal effect
- **Precedents**: SNCF01-68 (21/10, same station, the day before, same setting); the precedents tool did not answer (see Difficulties)
- **Family**: Thermal displacement: the pose has its day profile (pan low, scale high, return at 15:30) and the curves keep a day shift; no nuisance on the images (overcast)
- **Measured**: pan 5.8–8.0 m° (night ≈13), scale +194…+248 ppm, at its extreme 13:30; P5.x +8…+10, P7.x +8…+12, P6.y +7…+10 noises against the window night level, against −1/−2 on 21/10 evening; 15:30: pan 10.1, scale +141, P7.x +2, references' corr shift (BG.3.1.x −9, R1.y −9, R2.y +9 noises)
- **Images**: 13:30, 14:00: overcast, diffuse light
- **Confidence**: medium: few measurements, no night of the same day
### 2026-10-25T08:30Z → 2026-10-25T13:15Z (SNCF01-74, corrected)
- **Phenomenon of the catalogue**: Atmospheric turbulence
- **Precedents**: SNCF01-67, -81, -86, -90, -96 (same station, same template); none useful beyond
- **Family**: Visibility (turbulence): one-measurement jumps on many targets with the `error_value` agitated (CV.4 step 0.042 by day vs 0.002 at night), sunny hours only; not Thermal (that is the slow component, labelled apart)
- **Measured**: 21 exceedances by day (rolling ±4 median), CV.4 ×4 up to 7 noises, F4.2, F4.6, CV.9, P1; last at 13:00 (outside the Target issue F4.3)
- **Images**: 09:00, 10:00, 11:00, 13:00 sunny with sharp shadows; 12:00 and 14:00 cloudy
- **Confidence**: high on the agitation, medium on the end (agitation of `error_value` lingers to 14:30)
### 2026-10-25T23:30Z → 2026-10-26T00:00Z (SNCF01-76, corrected)
- **Phenomenon of the catalogue**: A pass-by hides the targets for the length of one measurement; A target left under the threshold latches onto…
- **Precedents**: SNCF01-84/-85 (train signature, stronger)
- **Family**: Obstruction (a passage, deduced)
- **Measured**: CV.1, CV.2, CV.4, CV.5, CV.8, CV.9, F4.2 rejected at 23:45; P7.x −0.4465 → −0.3983 → −0.4439 px (≈7.5 noises); P7 and P5 `error_value` 0.25→0.32; BG.3.1 0.685
- **Images**: none at 23:45 (hourly)
- **Confidence**: medium (cause deduced)
### 2026-10-26T08:15Z → 2026-10-26T22:00Z (SNCF01-77, corrected)
- **Phenomenon**: The camera moves through a thermal effect
- **Family**: Thermal displacement
- **Measured**: pan 13.4 → 9–10 m°, tilt −163 → −166, scale +70 → +160 ppm (half the sunny days); P7.x +11 at 10:00, +4…+6 by day; P5.x +5…+7; no return before the outage
- **Images**: 12:00 overcast
- **Confidence**: medium (amplitude modest; the evening is mixed with SNCF01-79)
### 2026-10-26T15:15Z → 2026-10-26T22:00Z (SNCF01-79, corrected)
- **Phenomenon**: Visibility drops over the whole scene / a reference less well seen (cause not established)
- **Family**: Visibility as before (reviewed choice): `error_value` up on references and many targets, sharp-edged episode, `sigma0` at its maximum; not a thermal return (the curves go the other way)
- **Measured**: see table; at 15:15 P6.y +8 (vs +4/+5), 15:30 P5.x +11 (vs +7); R2 `error_value` up to +36 noises at 18:15; 16 sensors above 5 MAD at 18:15
- **Images**: 16:00–21:00 night images, 18:00 compared with 25/10 18:00: same scene, nothing clear
- **Confidence**: medium on the start, low on the cause
### 2026-10-28T08:00Z → 2026-10-28T14:45Z, 2026-10-29T10:45Z → 15:30Z, 2026-10-30T09:15Z → 15:30Z, 2026-10-31T08:15Z → 16:00Z (SNCF01-81, -86, -90, -96, corrected)
- **Phenomenon**: Atmospheric turbulence
- **Family**: Visibility (heat shimmer), as before
- **Measured** (rolling ±4 median, own noise; accepted measurements; trains excluded): 28/10 35 exceedances (CV.4 ×8 up to 10, CV.2 ×6, P2, P3, CV.1); 29/10 17 (CV.4 ×6 up to 8.5, F4.2, CV.6, BG.3, BG.2); 30/10 42 (CV.2 ×8 up to 10, F4.2, CV.6, F4.6, F4.5, CV.4); 31/10 49 (CV.4 ×8, P2 ×7 up to 11, CV.2 up to 11, P1, BG.3, F4.2). Nights: 0 to 3. Magnitudes: CV.4 ±0.2–0.26 px (≈1.7–2.2 mm), CV.2 up to 0.37 px (≈2.3 mm), P2 0.12 px (≈0.7 mm). Hourly max `error_value` step (median of CV.4, CV.2, BG.3.1, R2, P2): 0.01–0.07 between 08 and 15 h on sunny days, ≤0.005 from 16 h
- **Images**: 12:00 of each day (31/10 also 13:00): full sun, sharp shadows
- **Confidence**: high on the phenomenon; bounds ±1 step (the agitation fades in and out)
### 2026-10-29T07:45Z → 2026-10-29T23:15Z (SNCF01-87, corrected)
- **Phenomenon**: The camera moves through a thermal effect
- **Family**: Thermal displacement
- **Measured**: pan 14.21 (07:45) → 12.11 (08:00) → ≈3 (15:15); tilt −161.4 → −169.5; scale +40 → +286 ppm; P5.y +19, P6.y +17, P7.x +11 noises at 15:45; back by 21:15–22:15; pan plateau 22:45
- **Images**: 12:00 sunny
- **Confidence**: high
### 2026-10-30T21:15Z → 2026-10-30T22:00Z (SNCF01-93, corrected)
- **Phenomenon**: A pass-by …; a reference less well seen
- **Family**: Obstruction (deduced passage), as before
- **Measured**: 21:30: P3.x −10, P1.x −6, BG.3.x −5 noises (P3 ≈−0.1 px ≈−0.6 mm), pan 9.82 → 12.33 → 9.73, BG.3.1 `error_value` 0.622; CV.2 rejected; 21:45 F4.2 rejected
- **Images**: none at 21:30 (21:00 and 22:00 exist, before and after)
- **Confidence**: medium
### 2026-10-31T07:45Z → 2026-11-01T00:00Z (SNCF01-97, corrected)
- **Phenomenon**: The camera moves through a thermal effect
- **Family**: Thermal displacement (plus the added Displacement for the step)
- **Measured**: pan 15.8 → 2.8 m° (15:00) → 10.3 (23:30); scale +4 → +290 → +120 ppm; P6.y up to +27, P5.y +22, P4.y +15, P7.x +12 noises; at 23:30 P6.y +16, P5.y +12 (previous nights ≈0)
- **Images**: 12:00, 13:00 sunny
- **Confidence**: medium (the part due to the step and to an incomplete thermal return cannot be separated without temperature)
### 2026-10-31T12:15Z → 2026-10-31T12:45Z (added)
- **Phenomenon of the catalogue**: A step of the camera that the compensation does not erase
- **Precedents**: none useful (tool unavailable; a grep on "the camera moves" gave thermal cases of other stations, MICHIGAN-9, LENZSPITZE-117, not a lasting step)
- **Family**: Displacement: a lasting change of the camera that the compensation does not erase, not proved thermal (no temperature, no return at equal hour: night tilt −168/−165 m° on 01/11 and 02/11 vs −161/−163 before); rather than Thermal displacement, whose boundary requires a return
- **Measured**: tilt −167.69 (12:15) → −172.75 (12:30) → −174.45 m° (13:00); `overview.py --rigid 2026-10-31T11:45Z`: ty −0.10 → −0.28 px at 12:30 (all sensors move up together), median target residual 0.02–0.03 → 0.04–0.05 px; P6.y +18 → +22…+25, P7.y +4 → +9, P3.y +6 → +10…+12, P5.y +16 → +21 noises (≈0.25–0.35 mm on P6, P7, P3); stays all afternoon. From 17:00 the references' corrections shift and stay (BG.3.1.y +3 → +10…+17, R1.x −3 → −9…−16, R2.x 0 → +5…+11 noises), through 02/11; targets not beyond 5 noises at 17:00
- **Images**: 12:00 and 13:00: same framing, full sun; nothing in front
- **Confidence**: medium: the step is clear; its cause (sun on the camera, mount) is not established
## 2. What I left without a label
- 26/10 daytime agitation: 3 exceedances (CV.4 +5.4 at 09:45, P5.y +5.1, P7.x +6.5 at 10:00 with the tilt drop): overcast day, part of the thermal label; no turbulence label.
- 22/10: P7.x −5.6 noises at 15:30: the thermal return, within SNCF01-71.
- 27/10 14:00 isolated measurement: large deviations against the rolling neighbours (P5.x −11, P6.x −10, R1.x +16) are an artefact of neighbours across the outage; inside No data SNCF01-80.
- 28/10 07:15 and 08:00: R1.x ±5, BG.3.1.y ±5–6 noises: references only, at the resumption.
- CV.7 (Target issue SNCF01-3): accepted at 28/10 14:00 and 30/10 13:15 with +4.3 / +8.8 px jumps (63 / 126 noises): covered by its Target issue.
- 31/10 17:00: the references' corrections shift (above) without any target beyond 5 noises at that instant: mentioned in the added label.
- Removed labels: SNCF01-72 (22/10, max 5.6 noises on one point, the thermal return), SNCF01-94 (F4.2 missing point; targets ≤2 noises at 21:45), SNCF01-95 (F4.2 missing point; no target beyond 5 noises at 07:15).
## 3. The documentation
- Helped: `labeling-rules.md` sections 1 and 2 (5 noises, gap edges, morning turning point, lasting jump bounded on the jump), `families.md` boundaries (Thermal vs Visibility; "A gap"), `reading-rules.md` section 5 (rigid read before saying "camera"). `tools/DATA.md` for the mm factors.
- The spanning labels: SNCF01-7 (the long drift, to 01/11) says the drift flattens at the end of the month; within the range it is right, but the step of 31/10 12:30 adds a jump on the last day, now labelled apart. SNCF01-1 to -6 hold within the range (BG.1, F4.1 rejected at all 517 measurements; CV.7 499, F4.4 482, F4.3 445, CV.6 279 rejected; CV.7's last accepted points jump as said).
- The old turbulence labels had been bounded on the `error_value` agitation and shared one copied list of targets; the thermal labels shared a copied sentence ("partly all at once at nightfall"), wrong on 26/10 and 31/10.
- Missing: no weather and no temperature for SNCF01; the sun had to be read on the images (useful: it separates the sunny shimmer days from the overcast ones).
- The precedents tool could not reach its Ollama server: precedents were read from the station's own labels and a grep.
## Difficulties
- `labeling/scripts/precedents.py` failed: Ollama unreachable (`docker start ollama-bge-m3` needed); no RAG precedents.
- `overview.py --table` and my tables: two measurements at 22/10 12:30 (15 s and 19 s), duplicate instant in the export.
## Sources read
- `instructions/analyst.md`, `tools/GUIDE.md`, `tools/DATA.md`, `labeling/families.md`, `labeling/labeling-rules.md`, `labeling/reading-rules.md`, `labeling/stations.md`
- `work/existing.jsonl`, `work/spanning.jsonl`, `labeling/auto/SNCF01.jsonl` (labels from 19/10 to the range end)
- Tools: `inventory.py`, `overview.py` (window; `--rigid 2026-10-31T11:45Z` on 31/10–02/11), `ranges.py --rolling 4 --instants 2`, `metrics.py`, `plot.py`, `thumbnails.py --zone`; whole images 25/10 18:00, 26/10 18:00, 31/10 12:00, 13:00
- My scripts: `scripts/table.py` (pose + corr in noises per instant), `scripts/agitation.py` (daily exceedances day/night), `scripts/build_labels.py`; inline checks of `error_value` steps by day and hour