- 32 analyses: each label kept, rewritten or removed by its analyst (section Requalification of the report; mm magnitudes where the targets have them) - SNCF01 x3, WILDSTRUBEL 2026-09-01 -> 2026-10-06 x3: verified from their existing labels under the new rules - long labels (no analysis): auto/analyses/long-labels/<STATION>/; NORDEND-169 and -195 run to 07/11, so NORDEND-283 and -284 (their continuation) are removed - reading-rules.md, stations.md: the citations of removed or rewritten labels point to their successor, or to [expert] Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
86 lines
15 KiB
Markdown
86 lines
15 KiB
Markdown
# Labels: NEBRASKA, 2026-10-03T00:00Z → 2026-10-13T00:00Z (UTC)
|
||
|
||
Request: verify the existing labels of the range (`work/existing.jsonl`: NEBRASKA-1), check the spanning one (`work/spanning.jsonl`: NEBRASKA-2) inside the range, look for what they miss. DETECTORS: no.
|
||
|
||
## Verdict per old id
|
||
|
||
- **NEBRASKA-1** (Displacement, 03/10 00:00 → 12/10 12:00): **kept**. The slow corr_x rise of COLJ20, POUJ20, POUJ19, COLJ19, then POUH19 and COLH19 is there (COLJ20 about 0.21 → 0.30 before the 9 October jump, 0.41 → 0.47 after; POUJ20 0.19 → 0.29, then 0.37 → 0.42; COLJ23, COLJ24, POUH21 flat apart from the jump). It reaches a plateau from 12/10 12:00 (COLJ20 0.473, 0.457, 0.475, 0.475, 0.477 up to 13/10 04:00; recedes from 13/10 08:00, the label NEBRASKA-3). Tilt 0.0129 → 0.0297 deg (peak 12/10 04:00), rotation −0.0048 → −0.0201, scale 0.99988 → 0.99968, clear step 07/10 12:00 → 08/10 00:00 (tilt 0.0178 → 0.0224) without a step in corr_x. Housing temperature 34.6 → 33.0-33.5 °C over the phase. Family, bounds and wording consistent with NEBRASKA-6 and BREITHORN-2, MICHIGAN-19.
|
||
- **NEBRASKA-2** (spanning, Target issue, 09/10 08:00 → 01/11): **holds within the range** (not modified). REFCOLH22 rejected at all 22 measurements from 09/10 12:00 to 13/10 00:00 (error_value up by about 0.96); fixed-frame thumbnails: spot sharp at 09/10 08:00, gone at 09/10 12:00 and 12/10 12:00, REFH22 intact. Jump at 12:00: corr_x COLJ20 +0.13, POUJ19 +0.115, POUJ20 +0.08, POUH19 +0.08; corr_y COLH19 +0.084, COLJ23 +0.058, COLH20 +0.055, COLJ24 +0.046, as written. corr of REFH22 and REFP''21 at 0 (1e-13) since then.
|
||
|
||
## 1. My labels
|
||
|
||
### 2026-10-03T00:00Z → 2026-10-12T12:00Z (NEBRASKA-1, kept as it is)
|
||
- **Phenomenon of the catalogue**: The camera tilts little by little (and, after 09/10, A compensation on two references)
|
||
- **Precedents**: NEBRASKA-6 and NEBRASKA-3 (same station, reviewed: the same movement later in the month, wording of the scene deforming with the tilt); BREITHORN-2 (reviewed), MICHIGAN-19 (not reviewed): the same tilt on the same dates in the same building.
|
||
- **Family**: Displacement: a drift of several days that the housing temperature does not explain alone (it drops by about one degree while the tilt keeps rising, no return at equal temperature); not Thermal displacement.
|
||
- **Measured**: see the verdict. `overview.py --rigid 03/10 00:00`: overall translation ty up to 0.56 px, rotation −0.013 deg; residual median of targets 0.007 → 0.05 px, COLJ20 dx up to +0.09, POUJ20 dx up to +0.12 px by 12/10, growing with the tilt (steps on 08/10 with the camera step): the scene deforms with the camera on the same dates (reading rule NEBRASKA-6/5), not a separate event. corr_y also drifts a little over the phase (night levels 03/10 → 08/10: COLH20 +0.044, COLH19 −0.044, COLJ20 −0.063, about 4-5 noises; POUH20 rises after 09/10): the same deformation; the label names the corr_x, which carries most of it. A small bump of the corr_y of the top targets 07/10 12:00 → 08/10 08:00 (2-4 noises per target) at the camera step: within this event.
|
||
- **Images**: whole images 04/10, 05/10, 06/10 08:00; thumbnails 05-06/10, 09/10, 12/10: nothing in front of the targets.
|
||
- **Confidence**: high for the drift and its bounds; the cause stays as written (not established).
|
||
|
||
### 2026-10-04T00:00Z → 2026-10-04T16:00Z (added)
|
||
- **Phenomenon of the catalogue**: The camera moves through a thermal effect
|
||
- **Precedents**: NEBRASKA-7, NEBRASKA-8, NEBRASKA-9 (reviewed): cool mornings, pose nodding forward at the housing temperature trough, top targets' corr out and back; BREITHORN-28 (not reviewed): same morning on BREITHORN.
|
||
- **Family**: Thermal displacement: the pose follows the housing temperature and comes back with it the same day; not Displacement (it returns), not Visibility (error_value flat, image clean).
|
||
- **Measured**: temperature 34.0 (00:00), 33.6 (04:00), 33.75 (08:00), 34.75 (12:00). `days.py --night 16-21 --bounds`: tilt +6.3 noises at 08:00 (0.0134 → 0.0174 deg), rotation −5.1 noises, scale −3.7; back at 12:00. corr_x COLJ20 0.219 → 0.259 → 0.273 → 0.242 → 0.241; POUJ20 0.215 → 0.243 → 0.257 → 0.229 → 0.207; POUJ19 0.144 → 0.177 → 0.176 → 0.164 → 0.154; POUH19 0.087 → 0.109 → 0.117 → 0.101 → 0.095; corr_y POUJ20 0.055 → 0.073 → 0.090 → 0.036, POUH19 0.069 → 0.093 → 0.086 → 0.069, COLJ23 −0.033 at 08:00. Rigid residual 08:00: tgt_med 0.021, POUJ20 dx +0.027, COLJ20 dx +0.023. 12:00 halfway (POUJ20 corr_x), 16:00 back.
|
||
- **Images**: whole image 08:00: dark indoor scene, all spots present, nothing in front.
|
||
- **Confidence**: medium: small amplitude (a few noises per target) but pose above 5 noises and the signature of the reviewed cool mornings.
|
||
|
||
### 2026-10-04T20:00Z → 2026-10-05T16:00Z (added)
|
||
- **Phenomenon of the catalogue**: The camera moves through a thermal effect
|
||
- **Precedents**: NEBRASKA-7, -8 (reviewed); MICHIGAN-17 and BREITHORN-29 (not reviewed), same morning.
|
||
- **Family**: Thermal displacement, as above.
|
||
- **Measured**: temperature 34.6 (04/10 20:00), 33.9 (00:00), 33.4 (04:00), 33.75 (08:00), 34.6 (12:00). Tilt 0.0135 → 0.0148 → 0.0152 → 0.0168 → 0.0156 → 0.0144 (+5.0 noises at 08:00); scale 0.999882 → 0.999828 at 08:00; rotation −0.0072 at 00:00, −0.0078 at 08:00. corr_y at 08:00: POUJ20 0.129 (night 0.03), POUH19 0.134, COLJ19 0.120, POUJ19 0.069, COLJ20 0.050, COLH20 0.096; median of targets +5.4 noises. corr_x at 00:00 COLJ19 0.136 (vs 0.105), at 08:00 COLJ19 0.164, POUH19 0.129, COLH21 +0.014 (vs −0.01). 12:00: COLJ19 0.151, POUJ19 0.180 corr_x, POUJ20 corr_y 0.066: still touched; 16:00 back.
|
||
- **Images**: whole image 08:00: same as 04/10, nothing in front.
|
||
- **Confidence**: medium.
|
||
|
||
### 2026-10-05T20:00Z → 2026-10-06T20:00Z (added)
|
||
- **Phenomenon of the catalogue**: The camera moves through a thermal effect; plus a deviation of two targets that follows the housing temperature (no exact entry).
|
||
- **Precedents**: NEBRASKA-8 (reviewed, top targets' corr_y out until the evening); MICHIGAN-18 (not reviewed): the same day, curves staying low until 16:00 and back at 20:00; BREITHORN-30 (not reviewed).
|
||
- **Family**: Thermal displacement: pose and the targets' own deviation follow the housing temperature and come back with it at 20:00 (boundary Thermal / Displacement); not Displacement (it returns at equal temperature).
|
||
- **Measured**: temperature 33.75 (00:00), 33.0 (04:00), 33.4, 33.9, 34.25 (16:00), 34.5 (20:00). Tilt 0.0140 → 0.0154 → 0.0166 → 0.0182 (08:00, +6.2 noises) → 0.0167 → 0.0150 (16:00, back); scale 0.999813 at 08:00. corr_y POUJ19 −0.035 (05/10 20:00), −0.074, −0.051, −0.088, −0.082, −0.107 (16:00, −7.8 noises), −0.029 (20:00); COLJ20 −0.044 … −0.078 (16:00) → −0.029; POUJ20 0.054 (04:00) → −0.040 (16:00) → 0.033; COLJ19 0.046 (04:00) → −0.014 → 0.048; POUH19 0.105 (04:00) → 0.021 → 0.049. corr_x COLJ19 0.121 → 0.164 → 0.198 (04:00) → 0.183 → 0.179 → 0.159 → 0.137; COLJ24 0.054 at 04:00. Rigid (base 03/10 20:00): POUJ19 dy −0.069, −0.073, −0.080, −0.063, −0.067 from 00:00 to 16:00, −0.026 at 20:00; COLJ19 dx +0.036 → +0.060 (12:00) → +0.050 → +0.015; tgt_max 0.07-0.08 px vs 0.03 the days around; the three references within the targets' band (sigma0 high at 04:00 only). Start: POUJ19 already slightly low at 05/10 20:00 (2 noises), kept as the bound (one step within the uncertainty).
|
||
- **Images**: thumbnails 05/10 16:00, 06/10 08:00, 16:00, 20:00 of POUJ19, COLJ19, COLJ20 and the witness COLJ23: spots sharp, round, unchanged; whole image 06/10 08:00: nothing in front.
|
||
- **Confidence**: medium: clear on POUJ19 and COLJ19, the origin of their own deviation not established.
|
||
|
||
## 2. What I left without a label
|
||
|
||
**Requalification (2026-11-17), removed labels: none.** The four labels of the analysis cross the threshold of 5 own noises on the corrected curves (values in the section below); none is a label of missing points alone, none is a thermal movement fully absorbed by the compensation, none is No data.
|
||
|
||
- **3 October morning**: tilt +2.2 noises at 08:00, corr below 5 noises, temperature dip 34.6 → 33.5; no cycle to label (rule of 5 noises); no night before the start of the data.
|
||
- **12 October morning**: the coldest housing temperature of the range (31.9 °C at 04:00), tilt +4.7 noises at 04:00, scale −2.7, corr_x COLH21 +3.5 noises, COLJ19 +2; under the 5-noise rule on pose and curves, and it falls at the tilt peak of the slow drift (NEBRASKA-1). Borderline: BREITHORN-31 (not reviewed) labels the same morning there. A reviewer may want a label 12/10 00:00 → 12/10 16:00.
|
||
- **7-8 October**: corr_y bump of the top targets at the camera step and the POUH21 corr_x dip (−0.039, −7 noises at 08/10 12:00, back on 09/10) with its corr_y rising: the scene deforming with the camera step, within NEBRASKA-1.
|
||
- **9-11 October mornings**: temperature dips of half a degree or less, pose without a cycle beyond 3 noises.
|
||
- **error_value**: slow drifts of a few thousandths, far below the thresholds (0.7), no rejection except REFCOLH22: no effect of their own on the curves.
|
||
- **12/10 12:00 → 13/10 04:00**: plateau of the drift, under NEBRASKA-2; nothing new.
|
||
|
||
## Requalification
|
||
|
||
Under the new rule (`labeling-rules.md` section 1: a movement of the corr is labelled only if one target deviates by more than 5 own noises; a thermal label only if the corrected curves keep it, beyond 5 noises from the night level). Outputs in `work/requalify/`. Result: **4 kept as they are, 0 rewritten, 0 removed.**
|
||
|
||
- **NEBRASKA-1** (Displacement, 03/10 00:00 → 12/10 12:00), **kept**. `python3 tools/scripts/ranges.py data/NEBRASKA --columns corr_x,corr_y --k 5 --start 2026-10-03T00:00Z --end 2026-10-12T12:00Z` (`ranges_N1_all.txt`): COLJ20 corr_x from −7.4 noises (03/10 04:00) to +20.1 (12/10 12:00) about the window median, POUJ20 −7.2 → +16.2, POUJ19 up to +14.7, POUH19 +13.9; this window holds the jump of 09/10 12:00 (another label). Without the jump, over 03/10 00:00 → 09/10 08:00 (`ranges_N1_prejump.txt`): COLJ20 still at −5.7 noises about the median at 03/10 04:00, about nine noises from start to end (about 0.09 px, about 0.3 mm at 3.4 mm per px, 8.6 m from the camera). After the jump, 09/10 12:00 → 12/10 12:00, COLJ20 still gains about six noises. The drift stands out by itself.
|
||
- **The three cool mornings**: `--rolling 1d` over 03/10 → 09/10 08:00 (`ranges_rolling1d.txt`) finds almost nothing (COLJ24 corr_y −5.3 at 06/10 04:00 only): at a 4 h step, ±1 day of neighbours holds the cycles of the mornings that follow each other, which pull the rolling level towards them; it is not the night level the rule asks for. So the deviation was read against the night level directly: `scripts/night_dev.py` (`night_dev.txt`): level = median of the bound measurement and the one before, noise = own noise (median of consecutive differences) over 03/10 00:00 → 09/10 08:00, 39 measurements. Cross-check with `ranges.py --outside` on the label (level and noise outside the episode): `ranges_N12.txt`, `ranges_N13.txt`, `ranges_N14.txt` (2-day windows, noise from few points, inflated values), and `ranges_N1214.txt` (03/10 00:00 → 07/10 12:00, outside 04/10 00:00 → 06/10 20:00).
|
||
- **NEBRASKA-12** (Thermal displacement, 04/10 00:00 → 16:00), **kept**: night level: COLJ20 corr_x +5.4 noises at 08:00 (+0.056 px, +0.19 mm), POUJ20 +4.9, POUH19 +4.3; `--outside`: POUJ20 +5.7, POUH19 +6.3 (wide window), POUJ20 +7.6, POUJ19 +6.5 (2-day window). Just over the threshold.
|
||
- **NEBRASKA-13** (Thermal displacement, 04/10 20:00 → 05/10 16:00), **kept**: night level: POUH19 corr_y +5.3 at 08:00 (+0.074 px, +0.50 mm), COLH21 corr_x +5.0, COLH20 corr_y +4.9; `--outside` (wide window): POUH19 corr_x +9.5, corr_y +6.2, POUJ20 corr_x +5.5. Just over the threshold.
|
||
- **NEBRASKA-14** (Thermal displacement, 05/10 20:00 → 06/10 20:00), **kept**: night level: POUJ19 corr_y −6.5 at 16:00 (−0.10 px, −0.48 mm), −5.3 at 08:00, COLJ24 corr_y −6.1 at 04:00 (−1.2 mm); `--outside`: POUJ19 −7.3 over 08:00 → 16:00, COLJ19 −6.4, POUJ20 −6.1, COLJ24 −7.2. Clearly over.
|
||
- Fragility, said for the reviewer: NEBRASKA-12 and -13 hold by a few tenths of a noise on the night level, at a 4 h step where the night has two measurements; their descriptions are kept (they rest on the corrected curves of the top targets, which is what is labelled). The rule kept them; a stricter reading of the level could drop them.
|
||
|
||
## 3. The documentation
|
||
|
||
- `families.md` (boundary Thermal / Displacement: "comes back with it at equal temperature") decided the 6 October case; the catalogue entry "The camera moves through a thermal effect" fits the three mornings.
|
||
- `labeling-rules.md`: "what falls under a long label is labeled apart" and "a signature found once is searched over the whole batch" led to the cool mornings, which the long Displacement had left out; "no thermal label under 5 noises" decided 3 and 12 October.
|
||
- Reading rule "a drift specific to a few targets that follows the camera, on the same dates, is the scene deforming" (NEBRASKA-6/5) settled the 7-8 October deviations; the 6 October deviation of POUJ19 and COLJ19 has its own dates, following the temperature rather than the pose: no rule says what that is (camera optics or targets), hence "not established".
|
||
- At a 4 h cadence, `days.py` nights have two measurements: the noise of the pose (and the 5-noise threshold) rests on very few values; 5 October sits exactly at 5.0, 12 October at 4.7. The threshold rule is fragile at this cadence.
|
||
- No image-quality metrics (old camera), no weather folder (no Swiss position): no weather available; the cause of a nuisance can only be read on the images, all dark indoor scenes.
|
||
- Precedents: the reviewed NEBRASKA cool mornings (7-11) gave the wording; the neighbours' labels of 4-6 and 12 October (not reviewed) confirmed the dates.
|
||
|
||
## Difficulties
|
||
- `overview.py --rigid --follow`: once a reference is rejected, its empty cells shift the columns of the printed table; read with care.
|
||
|
||
## Sources read
|
||
- `agents/agents/analyst.md`, `instructions/analyst.md`, `work/prompt.txt`, `work/existing.jsonl`, `work/spanning.jsonl`, `request.json`
|
||
- `tools/GUIDE.md`, `tools/DATA.md`, `labeling/families.md`, `labeling/labeling-rules.md`, `labeling/reading-rules.md`, `labeling/stations.md`
|
||
- `labeling/auto/NEBRASKA.jsonl` (all), `labeling/auto/MICHIGAN.jsonl` and `labeling/auto/BREITHORN.jsonl` (labels before 14/10)
|
||
- `precedents.py` ("cool morning … camera nods forward … top targets")
|
||
- Tools on `data/NEBRASKA` (outputs in `work/`): `inventory.py`, `overview.py` (4 h step, `--rigid` 03/10 00:00 and 03/10 20:00 with `--follow`), `metrics.py`, `days.py --night 16-21 --bounds`, `summary.py` corr_x / corr_y at 4 h (range and 11-17/10), `thumbnails.py` (05-06/10 top targets; REFCOLH22, REFH22 `--fixed` 09/10, 12/10), whole images 04/10, 05/10, 06/10 08:00, `plot.py`
|
||
- Requalification: `instructions/analyst.md`, `labeling-rules.md` section 1, `work/requalify_input.jsonl`, `tools/GUIDE.md` (ranges), `tools/scripts/ranges.py`, `common.own_noise`, `data.load`; `inventory.py` (distances, mm per px).
|
||
- Weather: no `weather/` folder for NEBRASKA. Image quality: empty.
|