Files
aimsight-labeling/auto/analyses/SNCF01_2026-10-14T0645_2026-10-22T1030/analysis.md
T
maximeandClaude Opus 5.5 ddb17c2189 auto: labels requalified under the 5-noise rules (only what stands out from the noise): 32 analyses refined, the 6 paused periods verified, the long labels requalified with the fixes the period analysts found; 1153 -> 961 labels
- 32 analyses: each label kept, rewritten or removed by its analyst (section Requalification of the report; mm magnitudes where the targets have them)
- SNCF01 x3, WILDSTRUBEL 2026-09-01 -> 2026-10-06 x3: verified from their existing labels under the new rules
- long labels (no analysis): auto/analyses/long-labels/<STATION>/; NORDEND-169 and -195 run to 07/11, so NORDEND-283 and -284 (their continuation) are removed
- reading-rules.md, stations.md: the citations of removed or rewritten labels point to their successor, or to [expert]

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
2026-11-17 23:58:00 +01:00

120 lines
16 KiB
Markdown
Raw Blame History

This file contains ambiguous Unicode characters
This file contains Unicode characters that might be confused with other characters. If you think that this is intentional, you can safely ignore this warning. Use the Escape button to reveal them.
# Labels: SNCF01, 2026-10-14T06:45Z → 2026-10-22T10:30Z (UTC)
Task: verify the 32 existing labels of the range (`work/existing.jsonl`) under the rules of 2026-11-17, keep / correct / remove, and add what they miss. Result: 21 kept, 7 corrected, 4 removed, 1 added → 29 labels in `labels.jsonl` (built by `scripts/build_labels.py`, validated 0 errors).
Context: a masonry railway viaduct seen across the tracks, 24 targets at 16 to 21 m (0 m / no factor for CV.1, no mm for it), three references BG.3.1, R1, R2 (no distance). 15 min cadence, hourly IRON images on the hour. **No weather** (no `weather/` folder: station without a Swiss position). **No temperature**: the `metrics/` files exist (BusCurrent, BusVoltage, Power, ShuntVoltage) but are empty over the window (`metrics.py`: "No value in the requested window"). No image quality columns (older camera): `quality.py` not applicable.
Own noises used (whole window, median of successive differences, `overview.py`/`ranges.py`): P targets 0.006–0.013 px in both axes, BG.2/BG.3/F4.5/F4.6 ≈ 0.011–0.013, CV.2 0.03, CV.4 0.023, CV.6 0.04, CV.9 0.08, F4.2 0.016–0.02. Threshold 5 noises: ≈ 0.03–0.065 px for the P targets (≈ 0.2–0.4 mm).
## Verdict per existing label
| id | Verdict | Evidence |
|---|---|---|
| SNCF01-38 | **corrected** (bounds, description) | First target beyond 5 noises on 14/10 at 09:45 (CV.2 cx −6.3, F4.5 cx −5.5; `ranges.py --rolling 4`), last 15:15 (CV.2 cx −5.7), CV.2 rejected 16:15 → 09:30 → 16:30 (was 06:45 → 16:45: the 06:45 start was only the range edge; 06:45–09:30 nothing beyond 5 noises). Description re-read on the day: sunny image at 13:00, the targets that jump that day. |
| SNCF01-39 | kept | P7 cx +24.8 noises at 15:15, beyond 5 noises 09:00→20:45; P6 cy +16.8; P1 cx −11; pose back overnight (`days.py --bounds`). |
| SNCF01-40 | **corrected** (description) | 14/10 10:45: CV.2, CV.4, CV.8 (and F4.3, usual) rejected; CV.6 cx −7.5, F4.2 cy −7.2, F4.6 cy −8.4 noises; BG.3.1 error +80 noises (0.656, under 0.7) not said in the old description: a reference touched explains why untouched targets jump. Bounds 10:30→11:00 right. |
| SNCF01-41 | kept | 01:45→02:15 and 02:15→02:45 two one-step gaps separated by one measurement = one No data (rule section 3). |
| SNCF01-42 | kept | 15/10 05:15→05:30 raw y of all sensors +0.25–0.35 px together (tilt step); corr_y P4 −0.06 px (−7 noises, −0.4 mm), P5 −0.045 (−6.4), P7 −0.047 (−7), CV.1 −0.05; R1 −0.02, R2 +0.027; levels kept the following hours. |
| SNCF01-43 | kept | 15/10 first exceedance 09:00 (6 sensors 5–7 noises), last 15:30; start 08:15 is two steps early (onset of a daytime agitation, F4.3 rejected 08:15–08:45 as usual): within uncertainty, not worth losing the review. |
| SNCF01-44 | kept | P7 cx +27.6 at 15:45, P5 cx +12.7, P6 cx +12.2, beyond 09:00 → gap 22:45. |
| SNCF01-45 | kept | 20 steps absent 22:45→04:00, no image 22:00→04:15. |
| SNCF01-46 | kept | P7 cx +16.6 at 13:00 (07:30→17:30), P1 cx −10.3, P5 cx +7.7; pose returns all night. |
| SNCF01-47 | kept | 16/10 exceedances 09:15, 10:45, 11:15, 12:30; CV.4 rejected 08:45 → start 08:15 one step early: kept. |
| SNCF01-48 | kept | CV.4 cx −129 noises (−3 px, −26 mm), cy +302 (+7 px) at 11:45, CV.2 rejected, back at 12:00. |
| SNCF01-49, -50 | kept | one step absent each, 13:45 and 14:30. |
| SNCF01-51 | **corrected** (description) | 16/10 16:00: all P are rejected (inventory), so "and some P" was wrong; the untouched targets that jump are BG.2 (cy −61 noises), BG.3 (−83), F4.5 (−55), plus the reference R2 (cx −32). Train seen on the 16:00 image (re-read: a blurred train across the lower scene). |
| SNCF01-52 | kept | P7 cx +12.9 at 14:15 (10:30→18:15), P5 cy +15.1, P6 cx +7.4, P4 cy +10.9. |
| SNCF01-53 | kept | first 08:15 (CV.4 cy −16.9), last ~12:15, CV.2 rejected 16:30. |
| SNCF01-54 | kept | CV.2 cx +168, cy +431 noises at 10:00 (+5.2/+12.4 px ≈ 32/77 mm); seen on the 10:00 image per its text. |
| SNCF01-55 | **removed** | Only F4.2 rejections (missing points) and an error_value rise; F4.2 accepted night points within ≈2.5 own noises, P2 within 3–4, no target beyond 5 noises at night 17→18/10 (`ranges.py --rolling 4`, whole window). |
| SNCF01-56 | kept | P7 cx +16.9 at 15:15, P5 cy +17.7 at 14:45, P6 cx +9.6, back in the evening. (Minor wording "the evening and the evening".) |
| SNCF01-57 | **corrected** (start) | 18/10 08:00 is itself touched: BG.3 cy −5.8, CV.4 −5.1, F4.6 −5.7, P2 −5.3, P4 −5.9 noises, back at 08:15 (sun arriving on the wall, image 08:00) → start 07:45 (rule: start = measurement before the first touched point). |
| SNCF01-58 | **removed** | Same as 55, night 18→19/10: F4.2 rejected at times, accepted points ≈2.5 noises; P2 deviations 17:00–19:00 are the evening of the thermal cycle (covered by 56). |
| SNCF01-59 | kept | 18/10 20:15: P3 cy −82 noises (−0.77 px, −4.8 mm), BG.2 −56, BG.3 −79, F4.5 −50, R2 −25; "some P" = P3, true; deduced (no image at 20:15). |
| SNCF01-60 | **corrected** (family Thermal → Displacement, description) | See section 1. |
| SNCF01-61, -63 | kept | 4 steps absent 09:00→10:15; 1 step absent 20:45→21:15. |
| SNCF01-62 | **removed** | One F4.2 rejection at 13:45 (missing point); its neighbours and all targets within ±1.6 noises. |
| SNCF01-64 | **corrected** (description) | 20/10 05:45: all P rejected (P3 too), so "some P" was wrong; the untouched ones are BG.2, BG.3, F4.5, F4.6 (cy −46 noises), and R2 (−35). It falls inside the new R1 episode, said. |
| SNCF01-65 | **removed** | F4.2 rejected 07:00–09:00 and CV.6 all night (CV.6 is a Target issue, spanning SNCF01-6): missing points; P2, P3 within 3.4 noises. The real anomaly of that morning (R1, 04:45→08:00) is a different event, added. |
| SNCF01-66 | kept | 12:45→21/10 10:00, two one-step gaps then 80 steps; isolated measurements at 13:15 and 13:45 do not make a resumption. |
| SNCF01-67 | kept | 21/10 exceedances 12:30, 13:00 (5 targets), 14:00, 14:30, 15:15. |
| SNCF01-68 | **corrected** (description) | "the compensation absorbs it almost entirely" is contradicted per target: corr_x of P5 dips from −0.050 (12:00) to −0.105 px (18:00), ≈7.6 noises (≈0.35 mm), P7 from −0.395 to −0.441 (≈6.4 noises), with the evening tilt rise; back at the 20:15 measurement. Bounds kept. |
| SNCF01-69 | kept | 19:30→20:15 and 20:15→22/10 10:30; single isolated measurement at 20:15 (P5–P7 cx +5–9 noises against a rolling level spanning the gaps: not read as an anomaly). |
## 1. My labels
### 2026-10-14T09:30Z → 2026-10-14T16:30Z (SNCF01-38, corrected)
- **Phenomenon of the catalogue**: Atmospheric turbulence (heat shimmer).
- **Precedents**: the same station's 13/10 and 15–18/10 day labels (same signature every sunny day); the precedents tool did not answer (Difficulties).
- **Family**: Visibility: fast one-measurement noise of the low targets, only by sunny day, night calm; not thermal (no slow movement), not Obstruction (many targets, whole day).
- **Measured**: `ranges.py --rolling 4`: 14/10 targets beyond 5 noises at 09:45, 10:15, 10:30, 10:45, 11:00, 11:30, 12:00, 12:15, 12:45–13:15, 13:30–14:15, 14:30, 15:00, 15:15 (CV.4 up to 7–10, F4.3 up to 10, CV.6 7.5, BG.2 8.3, F4.6 8.4); CV.2 rejected 10:45, 11:45, 13:30, 16:15. Nothing 06:45–09:30.
- **Images**: 13:00, sun with hard shadows on the wall.
- **Confidence**: medium (cause deduced; onset of an agitation is fuzzy by one or two steps).
### 2026-10-14T10:30Z → 2026-10-14T11:00Z (SNCF01-40, corrected)
- **Phenomenon**: A pass-by hides the targets for the length of one measurement.
- **Precedents**: SNCF01-54 (object seen at the bottom of the scene).
- **Family**: Obstruction: several low targets and a reference hit at one measurement, all back at the next.
- **Measured**: 10:45: CV.2, CV.4, CV.8 rejected; BG.3.1 error 0.656 (level 0.44, threshold 0.7); CV.6 cx −7.5, F4.2 cy −7.2, F4.6 cy −8.4 noises; 11:00 back.
- **Images**: none at 10:45 (hourly). **Confidence**: medium.
### 2026-10-16T15:45Z → 2026-10-16T16:15Z (SNCF01-51, corrected)
- **Phenomenon**: pass-by (train), with both references BG.3.1 and R1 rejected (no pose).
- **Family**: Obstruction, seen.
- **Measured**: 16:00, 22 sensors error beyond 5 MAD; BG.2 cx −26 / cy −61, BG.3 −34 / −83, F4.5 −20 / −55 noises (BG.3 −1.05 px ≈ −6.3 mm), R2 −32/−22; all P, CV, F4.1–F4.4, F4.6 rejected.
- **Images**: 16:00, a train blurred across the whole lower scene. **Confidence**: high.
### 2026-10-18T07:45Z → 2026-10-18T15:45Z (SNCF01-57, corrected start)
- **Phenomenon**: heat shimmer (sunny day).
- **Family**: Visibility.
- **Measured**: 08:00 five targets beyond 5 noises in corr_y (BG.3, CV.4, F4.6, P2, P4), back at 08:15; later 09:00–15:15 one-measurement jumps (CV.4 up to 15.6 noises at 11:45).
- **Images**: 08:00, the sun arrives on the arch (shadow edge across the wall). **Confidence**: medium.
### 2026-10-19T07:15Z → 2026-10-20T12:45Z (SNCF01-60, corrected to Displacement)
- **Phenomenon of the catalogue**: "The base changes / the camera tilts", closest: "A step of the camera that the compensation does not erase" mixed with "targets move apart in the image"; not a daily thermal cycle.
- **Precedents**: spanning SNCF01-7 (month-long drift, Displacement, reviewed): the scene slowly deforming in the image while the camera tilts; this day is its largest single step, labelled apart (rule 1, "what falls under a long label").
- **Family**: Displacement rather than Thermal displacement: the boundary of `families.md` asks that a thermal movement come back at equal temperature; here no temperature exists, 19/10 is overcast (no sun on the wall at 08:00 or 13:00, unlike every other cycle day), the pose (pan −0.007°, tilt −0.004°, scale +2·10⁻⁴) does not come back before the outage, and the targets do not return either.
- **Measured**: `overview.py --rigid 2026-10-19T04:00Z`: overall movement tx −0.35 px, ty −0.24 px by 15:00 then flat until 20/10 13:00; residuals of the targets themselves: P2 dx −0.10 px, P5 dx +0.07–0.10, P7 dx +0.04–0.07, P5 dy +0.04–0.05 px: targets move relative to each other. corr_x: P2 from ≈0.22 to ≈0.09 px (≈ −11 noises, −0.8 mm), P5 +0.08 px (+11.7 noises), P6 +11.5, P7 +9.1 (night 20/10 vs night 19/10, `days.py`). sigma0 beyond 5 noises from 19/10 10:30, R1 error elevated from 16:45 (`ranges.py` on error_value). On 21/10 P2 ≈0.10 and P5 ≈ −0.055 px: still near the new levels.
- **Images**: 19/10 08:00 and 13:00: overcast, soft image, no sun. **Confidence**: medium (the shift is certain; its cause and whether the structure moves are not established).
### 2026-10-20T04:45Z → 2026-10-20T08:00Z (added)
- **Phenomenon of the catalogue**: "A reference loses its brightness, without an obstacle" / "A reference dropped: the base changes" (family of the cause).
- **Precedents**: FLORIDA-66 and FLORIDA-71 (Visibility: a reference weakens at night, its measured position slides against the targets, the pose follows it; FLORIDA is SNCF01's neighbour), read by grep in `labeling/auto/` because the precedents tool did not answer.
- **Family**: Visibility: reference less well seen, nothing in front, in a night of poor visibility for faint targets; not Obstruction (no object, spot whole on the thumbnails), not Displacement (comes back).
- **Measured**: R1 error 0.274 → 0.318 at 05:00 (+25 own noises), elevated until ≈09:30; `overview.py --rigid 2026-10-20T04:00Z`: R1 dy −0.05 → −0.097 px at 05:30, back to −0.008 at 08:00, targets' own residuals ≈0. corr_y P7 −0.057 → 0.000 px at 05:30 (+8.6 noises, +0.39 mm), P6 0.142 → 0.19 (+7.4, +0.32 mm), P5 0.106 → 0.142 (+5.1), R2 +0.035; back at 08:00 (P7 −0.049, P6 0.156). The train of 05:45 inside (SNCF01-64).
- **Images**: thumbnails R1/R2/P7 at 19/10 05:00 (witness), 20/10 05:00, 06:00, 07:00, 09:00 (`--fixed`): spot of R1 in place, whole, nothing in front.
- **Confidence**: medium (the effect is clear; "visibility" as cause is deduced from the night's other faint targets).
### 2026-10-20T05:30Z → 2026-10-20T06:00Z (SNCF01-64, corrected)
- **Family**: Obstruction, deduced (train signature). **Measured**: 05:45: BG.2 cy −56, BG.3 −74, F4.5 −47, F4.6 −46 noises, R2 −35; every P, CV, F4.1–F4.4 rejected, BG.3.1 and R1 rejected (no pose). **Images**: none at 05:45. **Confidence**: high.
### 2026-10-21T10:00Z → 2026-10-21T19:30Z (SNCF01-68, corrected description)
- **Phenomenon**: The camera moves through a thermal effect (sunny 21/10, image 13:00).
- **Family**: Thermal displacement, kept: pose cycle of the day with partial remainder on P5/P7.
- **Measured**: see table. **Confidence**: medium (no temperature, cut by outages on both sides).
The 21 kept labels: evidence in the table above.
## 2. What I left without a label
- F4.2 night rejections 17→18/10, 18→19/10, 19/10 13:45, 20/10 07:00–09:00 (old labels 55, 58, 62, 65): missing points; accepted F4.2 within ≈2.5 own noises at night; P2, P3 error rising without corr effect (P2, P3 within 3–4.5 noises).
- References' corr alone on 19/10 17:15–17:30 (BG.3.1 cx −7, R1 cy −7, R2 cy +9 noises): a reference residual, not a target; P targets within 5 noises; inside SNCF01-60.
- Isolated measurements 21/10 20:15 and 22/10 10:30: P5–P7 cx +5–9 noises against a rolling level that spans 15 h gaps: the return of the evening dip of 21/10 and the start of 22/10 (SNCF01-71 of the next batch), not separate events.
- Single scattered daytime exceedances inside the shimmer labels (CV.9, F4.3 Target issue, CV.6 Target issue): covered.
- R2 error elevated 19/10 18:30 → 20/10 12:00 (+13 noises) without own corr effect beyond what SNCF01-60 and the added label carry.
## 3. The documentation
- `families.md` boundary "Thermal displacement or Displacement" (comes back at equal temperature) decided SNCF01-60; the catalogue line "A reference loses its brightness" and FLORIDA-66/71 decided the added label. `labeling-rules.md` section 1 (missing point not labelled) removed 55, 58, 62, 65; section 2 (start = measurement before the first touched point) corrected 57 and 38.
- `days.py --bounds` on the median of the targets says "never > 5 noises" most days, because P7/P5 rise while P1/P2 drop: the cycle is only visible per sensor (`--sensors P7`, `P5`). Worth a sentence in the guide.
- `ranges.py --rolling 4` misses slow shifts of a few hours (the R1 episode of 20/10): it was found on the per-slot table of `days.py` and on `overview.py --rigid`.
- The old labels' "and some P" sentence was copied from one train label to another although all P were rejected at 16/10 16:00 and 20/10 05:45 (rule "a sentence taken from a model is reread").
- `stations.md` says SNCF01 has no system metrics: the metric files exist but are empty; consistent.
## Difficulties
- `precedents.py` never answered: the Ollama container runs but lists no model (`/api/tags` returns an empty list); several sessions were stuck on it. Precedents were read by `grep` on `labeling/auto/*.jsonl` instead (FLORIDA-66, FLORIDA-71).
- No weather and no temperature for this station: the thermal and visibility causes are deduced from the pose and the images only.
## Sources read
`instructions/analyst.md`, `tools/GUIDE.md`, `tools/DATA.md`, `labeling/families.md`, `labeling/labeling-rules.md`, `labeling/reading-rules.md`, `labeling/stations.md`, `labeling/auto/SNCF01.jsonl` (edges of the range), `work/existing.jsonl`, `work/spanning.jsonl`, `request.json`; data/SNCF01 through `inventory.py`, `overview.py` (window, `--rigid` 19/10 and 20/10), `ranges.py` (`--rolling 4`, error_value), `days.py --bounds` (median, P7, P5, P1, P6, P4), `summary.py`, `metrics.py`, `plot.py`, `thumbnails.py`; images 14/10 13:00, 16/10 16:00, 18/10 08:00, 19/10 08:00, 19/10 13:00, 21/10 13:00; precedents by grep: CLARIDEN-12, FLORIDA-66, FLORIDA-71, NIEDERHORN-150/151/32/158, MICHIGAN-17.